Why I Think The 50/30/20 Budgeting Rule is Bullshit and what really works

 

SugarMamma’s Fireplay

Having been a Financial Planner for over 15 years, I have seen first hand how money problems can breed stress. Often, people make wrong money decision… 
352 clip(s)
Loading playlist

The 50/30/20 budgeting rule sounds simple: 50% of your income goes towards needs, 30% towards wants and 20% towards savings and financial goals.

But I think treating this as a universal rule for a “healthy” budget is bullshit.

Why? Because personal finance is personal.

The rising cost of living means many households simply can’t keep their essential expenses within 50% of their take-home income. At the same time, someone living at home with minimal expenses could potentially be saving and investing far more than 20%.

Different incomes. Different families. Different goals. Different stages of life. So why are we trying to squeeze everyone into the same three percentages?

In this episode, I unpack:

• How the 50/30/20 budgeting rule actually works
• Why it can be unrealistic in today’s cost-of-living environment
• Why your stage of life matters when building a budget
• How following the rule could actually hold some people back financially
• Why allocating 20% towards “goals” doesn’t necessarily mean you’re using that money efficiently
• How rigid budgeting rules can create unnecessary guilt and financial shame
• Why your budget needs to change as your life changes
• The budgeting approach I prefer instead
• How to create your own healthy ratios based on what you can genuinely afford
• Why your financial goals should help shape your budget
• How a strong cashflow system can make sticking to your budget much easier

I’m not against using percentages. In fact, percentages can be incredibly useful for understanding and measuring your money.

I just don’t believe somebody else’s percentages should dictate what financial success looks like for you.

Money is fluid. Life is fluid. Your budget needs to be fluid too.

You don’t need your budget to look perfect on a pie chart.

You need it to work in your real life.

💡 If you want my help with your Budget or Money Mindset

Want more support on your financial journey? Here’s how we can work together:

  1. The SugarMamma Budget & Cashflow Academy
    Sick of living paycheque to paycheque or feeling overwhelmed by your money?
    This course includes aone-on-one appointment with me so I can personally help you.
    👉 Enrol here
  1. Money Mindset & Manifestation Mentorship
    Join my program for ongoing support, clarity, and motivation around the way to show up and work on your financial goals and dreams, including attracting the life that you want. Get started here.

📚 My Books

If you’re ready to deepen your financial knowledge, check out my books, including our new one:

(These are Amazon affiliate links to my own books.)

🌟 Stay Connected & Inspired

⚖️ General Advice Warning

While we discuss financial topics, everything shared here is general information only — never personal, product, or investment advice. Always:

  • Do your own research.
  • Weigh up the pros, cons, fees, caps, taxes, and risks.
  • Seek professional advice before making financial decisions.

📜 Financial Planning License Details

The information in this podcast does not take into account your personal circumstances, goals, or needs. Always read relevant Product Disclosure Statements before acquiring any financial product, and seek independent financial advice where appropriate.

Canna Campbell is an Authorised Representative and Financial Adviser of Links Licensee Services Pty Ltd (AFSL No. 700012 | ABN 97 678 975 589).

 

Loading transcript