A great first date can fall apart over the most random thing. Mitchell calls us after getting ghosted by Brooke, but when she joins the conversation, she reveals one oddly specific habit that had her doing a double take all night. Would it be a dealbreaker for you?

Colleen Caught What Derek Was REALLY Doing
05:56

Jenna Found THIS Under Calvin's Seat
04:45

Mitchell Says It's Efficient... Dana Says It's INSANE
06:09