Valerie Thought James Was Normal...Until the Next Day

Imagine having an AMAZING first date, only to discover something about the guy the very next day that gives you the BIGGEST ICK. James says he was just being cautious, but Valerie thinks he took things WAY too far. Is this a dating red flag or just someone protecting themselves?!

So…What Happened Between Chris & Lauren?

Lauren called us about Chris after what felt like a promising drinks date in San Carlos. She said he was funny, relaxed, and easy to talk to, with great back-and-forth energy. They chatted about travel, favorite shows, and how they like to spend their weekends. The conversation flowed, the vibe was…

Beck's Ex-Wife Detail That Changed EVERYTHING for Sofia

Beck was giving boyfriend material... until his ex-wife entered the conversation. Sofia thought she'd met a funny, charming guy, but one unexpected detail about his past had her questioning whether she was about to walk into some serious relationship DRAMA

This One Thing About Jason Gave Kim the Ick

Jason thought drinks in Campbell couldn't have gone any better. Great conversation, nonstop laughs, and instant chemistry. So why did Kim completely disappear afterward? Turns out one tiny habit may have been a much bigger deal than he ever realized.

Rose Realized Will Wasn't Who He Pretended to Be

The chemistry was there. The conversation was flowing. And then Will decided to FLEX a little too hard. Rose thought she'd met a great guy, but something that happened after dinner had her questioning whether he was being completely honest about himself.

Gwen Was SO Embarrassed by What Spencer Did at the Dinner Table

Spencer and Gwen were giving cute couple energy...until dinner took a VERY unexpected turn. He says he was just trying to make the most of the evening, but she says his behavior was a massive red flag. What exactly happened that made her disappear after such a promising date?

Kendall Wasn't Ready for Jesse's Next Day Surprise

Some guys send a cute good morning text. Jesse decided to take a slightly DIFFERENT approach. Kendall thought she'd met a genuinely sweet guy, but his attempt to impress her after their first date left her feeling more uncomfortable than flattered.

Melissa Was NOT Prepared for Kian's Dinner Date Rules

Some guys have high standards. Kian apparently has a completely different set of RULES. Melissa says their first date was going great until he did something at dinner that left her absolutely speechless. The worst part? He genuinely doesn't understand what he did wrong.

Kevin Was Paying Attention to Everything EXCEPT Rachel

Some people go to restaurants for the food. Kevin apparently has OTHER priorities. Rachel thought she was getting a cute Italian dinner date, but what happened before they left had her questioning whether she'd accidentally signed up for something completely different.

Alan & Allison Date Was Perfect...Until They Got in the Car

Some guys come with baggage. Alan apparently brought his along for the RIDE. Allison thought she'd met a sweet, funny guy in Tiburon, but one unexpected moment at the end of their date had her wondering what she'd accidentally gotten herself into.