Sloane Wasn't Ready for John's BIG Plans

Imagine going on ONE date with someone and suddenly feeling like you've been cast as their girlfriend. John says he and Sloane had an incredible connection, but she thinks he's moving at lightning speed... and his reasoning only makes things more awkward.

Darius Gave Phoebe MAJOR Secondhand Embarrassment

Darius was finally getting back into the dating game after THREE YEARS, and his first date with Phoebe couldn't have gone better. Or so he thought. Apparently, he got a little TOO excited about his big return to dating, and Phoebe was not prepared for what happened next.

Diego & Jessica Have VERY Different Ideas of Romance

The chemistry was there. The flirting was working. They even stayed until the restaurant closed! But one unexpected moment at the end of dinner completely changed Jessica's opinion of Diego. And when he tries to explain himself, things somehow get even WORSE.

Melody Couldn't Believe Bryce Did THIS in Public

How do you go from potential boyfriend material to getting GHOSTED over something so small?! Bryce says he treated Melody to a great dinner and thought they had an incredible connection. But apparently, something he did later that night left her questioning his entire personality.

Andre's First-Date Mistake that Laurel Couldn't Ignore

Imagine having amazing chemistry with someone, only for them to completely ruin it by opening their mouth. Andre says his date with Laurel couldn't have gone better, but she remembers one VERY specific detail that completely changed how she felt about him.

Mark & Alyssa Share Silence After Table Service

Mark thought he had a solid first date drinks turned into appetizers, the conversation flowed, and Alyssa was sharp, funny, and refreshingly direct. So when she stopped responding the very next day, he was caught completely off guard. What went wrong, and was the connection ever as mutual as it fel…

Jonah Thought Everyone Was Having Fun... April Disagreed

Nothing kills first-date chemistry quite like suddenly feeling invisible. April genuinely liked Jonah, but halfway through their night in Oakland, the attention shifted in a direction she wasn't expecting. Jonah says it wasn't a big deal. April says it told her EVERYTHING she needed to know.

Vanessa Thought Cole Was Cute...Until He Wasn't

Nothing says romance like a little friendly competition, right? WRONG. Cole and Vanessa were having an amazing first date until they decided to play trivia together. What started as a cute bonding moment quickly turned into something Vanessa says completely changed how she saw him.

Elijah's Vacation Pictures Were NOT What Renee Expected

Elijah says Renee asked to see his European vacation. Renee says she asked for PICTURES, not an entire cinematic experience. And honestly, the production value wasn't even her biggest issue once she noticed one very specific detail in the footage.

Sabrina Says Owen Needs to Mind His Own Business

When does overhearing become EAVESDROPPING? That's the debate after Owen and Sabrina's first date in SoMa. He says the people next to them were impossible NOT to hear. Sabrina says hearing their conversation didn't mean he needed to become emotionally invested in it.