Nate and Siena met online and went out for steaks and drinks at Original Joe's in San Jose. The atmosphere was great, Nate thought there was a connection but was surprised to be ghosted. Siena was turned off by Nate because Nate pulled out a pocket knife and started cutting his steak with it. On top of that, Nate repeatedly made distasteful dad jokes, even after Siena asked him to stop.