It’s the kind of first date that feels straight out of a rom-com: live music, cozy tables, and a little too much overheard drama from the table next to you. Colin says Tessa had him hooked from the first joke. He walks her to her car convinced there’s more to come. Instead? Silence. Did he miss a red flag… or did she?

Jason's Free Food Hack Gave Nicole the Ick
04:54

Five Minutes in Ryan's Apartment Changed Everything for Vanessa
07:11

Why Did Lauren Ask Reid About THAT on a First Date?!
05:31