We are told that failure builds character, that it teaches resilience and it points the way forward. But in real life, failure is usually less inspiring than that. It is embarrassing, exposing and harder to learn from than the slogans would have us believe.

In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui take apart the psychology of failure: why it hurts so much, why shame so often gets there first and why our instinct is usually not to learn from failure but to defend ourselves against it. They explore the difference between failing at something and feeling like a failure, the role of identity, family scripts, gender, and social pressure.

This is a conversation about how to meet failure with curiosity and let it become information rather than identity.

We are told that failure builds character, that it teaches resilience and it points the way forward. But in real life, failure is usually less inspiring than that. It is embarrassing, exposing and harder to learn from than the slogans would have us believe.
In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui take apart the psychology of failure: why it hurts so much, why shame so often gets there first and why our instinct is usually not to learn from failure but to defend ourselves against it. They explore the difference between failing at something and feeling like a failure, the role of identity, family scripts, gender, and social pressure.
This is a conversation about how to meet failure with curiosity and let it become information rather than identity.

Vol XXXI: Failure 

In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui explore the shift from the older, more clinical definition of trauma to a broader, more psychologically nuanced understanding: that trauma is not only about what happened, but about what happened inside us as a result, particularly when an experience leaves us overwhelmed, unsupported, unseen, or unable to fully process it.

They unpack the difference between distress and trauma, the distinction between big T and little t experiences, and the ways unresolved trauma can continue to shape us long after the original event has passed.

But this conversation is not only about naming trauma. It is also about recovery: the role of safety, support, remembrance, and connection, and why trauma work must be approached with care. Jacqui also walks listeners through EMDR in depth, including what it stands for, how it works, why it can sound unusual at first, and why it has become such a respected and effective treatment for trauma.

In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui explore the shift from the older, more clinical definition of trauma to a broader, more psychologically nuanced understanding: that trauma is not only about what happened, but about what happened inside us as a result, particularly when an experience leaves us overwhelmed, unsupported, unseen, or unable to fully process it.
They unpack the difference between distress and trauma, the distinction between big T and little t experiences, and the ways unresolved trauma can continue to shape us long after the original event has passed.
But this conversation is not only about naming trauma. It is also about recovery: the role of safety, support, remembrance, and connection, and why trauma work must be approached with care. Jacqui also walks listeners through EMDR in depth, including what it stands for, how it works, why it can sound unusual at first, and why it has become such a respected and effective treatment for trauma.

Vol XXX: Trauma and EMDR

Forgiveness is often spoken about as a virtue, but in real life it can feel messy, resistant, and anything but straightforward.

In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui unpack what forgiveness actually is, why it matters for our mental and physical wellbeing, and how to begin moving from hurt and resentment toward something more peaceful..with or without reconciliation.

Forgiveness is often spoken about as a virtue, but in real life it can feel messy, resistant, and anything but straightforward.
In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui unpack what forgiveness actually is, why it matters for our mental and physical wellbeing, and how to begin moving from hurt and resentment toward something more peaceful..with or without reconciliation.

Vol  XXIX: Forgiveness 

For something so ordinary, communication is anything but simple.

We tend to think of poor communication as a dramatic failure. A screaming match, a betrayal, a rupture…but the reality is it is often far more subtle than that. It lives in misread signals, conversational habits, little dismissals and the moments we leave feeling less held than we hoped.

This week, Antonia and Jacqui turn their attention to the mechanics and meaning of everyday communication: They chat about what makes a conversation feel nourishing rather than depleting, why being misunderstood can feel physically painful, and how we create connection without going from from polite small talk one minute into emotional overexposure the next.They explore listening, social anxiety, oversharing, conversational self-awareness, and the art of raising something difficult without immediately setting the relationship on fire.

It’s an episode that is less about saying the perfect thing, more about learning how to stay open, interested, and honest enough for real connection to happen.

For something so ordinary, communication is anything but simple.
We tend to think of poor communication as a dramatic failure. A screaming match, a betrayal, a rupture&hellip;but the reality is it is often far more subtle than that. It lives in misread signals, conversational habits, little dismissals and the moments we leave feeling less held than we hoped.
This week, Antonia and Jacqui turn their attention to the mechanics and meaning of everyday communication: They chat about what makes a conversation feel nourishing rather than depleting, why being misunderstood can feel physically painful, and how we create connection without going from from polite small talk one minute into emotional overexposure the next.They explore listening, social anxiety, oversharing, conversational self-awareness, and the art of raising something difficult without immediately setting the relationship on fire.
It&rsquo;s an episode that is less about saying the perfect thing, more about learning how to stay open, interested, and honest enough for real connection to happen.

Vol XXVIII: Comms 101 

How do you know if you’re in a good relationship…Not a perfect one, but a genuinely good enough one? 

In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui take that question seriously and pull it apart with far more honesty than romance culture usually allows. They break down what being in a ‘good enough’ relationship actually means? How to tell the difference between ordinary disappointment and something more fundamental? And how to evaluate a relationship without getting lost in comparison?

This is a conversation about letting go of perfection without lowering the bar, and about recognizing that a strong relationship is not necessarily one without friction.

How do you know if you&rsquo;re in a good relationship&hellip;Not a perfect one, but a genuinely good enough one?&nbsp;
In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui take that question seriously and pull it apart with far more honesty than romance culture usually allows. They break down what being in a &lsquo;good enough&rsquo; relationship actually means? How to tell the difference between ordinary disappointment and something more fundamental? And how to evaluate a relationship without getting lost in comparison?
This is a conversation about letting go of perfection without lowering the bar, and about recognizing that a strong relationship is not necessarily one without friction.

Vol XXVII: Is My Relationship Good Enough

Ambition is one of those qualities we are taught to admire almost without question. In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui unpack ambition as both a personality trait and a cultural obsession.

They explore the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic ambition, why striving can be life-giving when it is rooted in values and meaning, and why it can become corrosive when it is driven by status, comparison, and the exhausting need for external validation. Together they talk about capitalism, identity, social media, quiet ambition and the tension between gratitude for what we have and the desire to build something more. This is a conversation about achievement, yes, but also about contentment, self-awareness, and the deeper question underneath so much striving: is this actually mine, or have I just inherited it from the world around me?

Ambition is one of those qualities we are taught to admire almost without question. In this episode, Antonia and Jacqui unpack ambition as both a personality trait and a cultural obsession.
They explore the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic ambition, why striving can be life-giving when it is rooted in values and meaning, and why it can become corrosive when it is driven by status, comparison, and the exhausting need for external validation. Together they talk about capitalism, identity, social media, quiet ambition and the tension between gratitude for what we have and the desire to build something more. This is a conversation about achievement, yes, but also about contentment, self-awareness, and the deeper question underneath so much striving: is this actually mine, or have I just inherited it from the world around me?

Vol XXVI: Ambition

There can be a particular kind of melancholy that settles in when you catch your reflection in the mirror of your life and realize it looks different from the blueprint you once carried so confidently. The slow-dawning awareness that somewhere between your twenties and now, the GPS of your dreams got quietly recalibrated.

In the latest episode of What Matters Most, Antonia Prebble and clinical psychologist Jacqui excavate this millennial anxiety: the gnawing sense that everyone else received a roadmap you somehow missed. Prebble admits to wrestling with the subtle ache of realizing that life has panned out differently than she once dreamed.

Jacqui draws a razor-sharp distinction between aspirations and expectations. Aspirations are living documents, hopes that breathe and evolve with us. Expectations are fixed contracts we inherited from parents, absorbed from culture, crystallized from dreams we've outgrown. Our expectations are often someone else's entirely.

The conversation dives into the weaponization of the word "settling." In our optimization-obsessed culture, settling has become synonymous with surrender. Jacqui suggests we're simply evolving. The life that looks like compromise is actually the one that fits.

The episode's most potent insight: Recognizing that dreams change because we change is the key to moving forward.

There can be a particular kind of melancholy that settles in when you catch your reflection in the mirror of your life and realize it looks different from the blueprint you once carried so confidently. The slow-dawning awareness that somewhere between your twenties and now, the GPS of your dreams got quietly recalibrated.
In the latest episode of What Matters Most, Antonia Prebble and clinical psychologist Jacqui excavate this millennial anxiety: the gnawing sense that everyone else received a roadmap you somehow missed. Prebble admits to wrestling with the subtle ache of realizing that life has panned out differently than she once dreamed.
Jacqui draws a razor-sharp distinction between aspirations and expectations. Aspirations are living documents, hopes that breathe and evolve with us. Expectations are fixed contracts we inherited from parents, absorbed from culture, crystallized from dreams we've outgrown. Our expectations are often someone else's entirely.
The conversation dives into the weaponization of the word "settling." In our optimization-obsessed culture, settling has become synonymous with surrender. Jacqui suggests we're simply evolving. The life that looks like compromise is actually the one that fits.
The episode's most potent insight: Recognizing that dreams change because we change is the key to moving forward.

Vol XXV: I Am Not Where I Thought I Would Be 

Change is the one thing we count on in life and yet it gets easier. Whether it's a career shift, a new relationship, a move, or just a subtle shift in priorities, change has a way of throwing us off balance.

In this episode of What Matters Most, Antonia and Jacqui take on the complex topic of navigating life transitions, big and small. Our brains treat change as a threat, even when it's something positive or long-awaited. Jacqui dives into the neuroscience behind why our minds crave stability, how rapid changes overwhelm us, and why our ancestors had to deal with the pace of change we face today.

They explore why some people thrive on novelty while others struggle to adapt, and how personality traits and attachment styles play a huge role in how we cope.

Jacqui offers insight into why emotional regulation is crucial when life throws us a curveball and why sometimes, just getting up and taking a shower is the best first step. The episode focuses on practical strategies like practicing cognitive flexibility and reframing our mindset. One key tip: shift from "bouncing back" to "bouncing forward," focusing on how you grow from the experience rather than trying to get back to how things were.

It's about being adaptable. Learning to handle change is like building a muscle: it takes conscious effort, but the results are worth it.

Change is the one thing we count on in life and yet it gets easier. Whether it's a career shift, a new relationship, a move, or just a subtle shift in priorities, change has a way of throwing us off balance.
In this episode of What Matters Most, Antonia and Jacqui take on the complex topic of navigating life transitions, big and small. Our brains treat change as a threat, even when it's something positive or long-awaited. Jacqui dives into the neuroscience behind why our minds crave stability, how rapid changes overwhelm us, and why our ancestors had to deal with the pace of change we face today.
They explore why some people thrive on novelty while others struggle to adapt, and how personality traits and attachment styles play a huge role in how we cope.
Jacqui offers insight into why emotional regulation is crucial when life throws us a curveball and why sometimes, just getting up and taking a shower is the best first step. The episode focuses on practical strategies like practicing cognitive flexibility and reframing our mindset. One key tip: shift from "bouncing back" to "bouncing forward," focusing on how you grow from the experience rather than trying to get back to how things were.
It's about being adaptable. Learning to handle change is like building a muscle: it takes conscious effort, but the results are worth it.

Vol XXIV: Navigating Change: Why It's So Hard and How to Move Forward

In this episode of What Matters Most, Antonia and Jacqui tackle one of psychology's most misunderstood concepts: boundaries. Despite becoming a pop psychology buzzword, the reality of setting healthy boundaries is far more nuanced than social media makes it seem.

The hosts explore why boundary-setting feels so intimidating, particularly when online discourse oversimplifies their true purpose. As Antonia observes, "The problem with how boundaries are often discussed online is that they sound like ultimatums. That's not how relationships actually work." Jacqui builds on this insight, explaining that boundaries are fundamentally about your own behavior: what you're willing to do or accept, rather than controlling others.

Together, they discuss practical strategies for recognizing when a boundary is needed, how to communicate it effectively, and why consistency matters even when others push back. At their core, boundaries protect your emotional space while respecting others' autonomy. They're about creating clarity, not building walls.

This episode offers a thoughtful, real-world perspective on honoring your needs while preserving your relationships. As Jacqui emphasizes, boundaries aren't about cutting people off. They're about being clear with yourself first, then communicating those limits with grace and intention.

In this episode of What Matters Most, Antonia and Jacqui tackle one of psychology's most misunderstood concepts: boundaries. Despite becoming a pop psychology buzzword, the reality of setting healthy boundaries is far more nuanced than social media makes it seem.
The hosts explore why boundary-setting feels so intimidating, particularly when online discourse oversimplifies their true purpose. As Antonia observes, "The problem with how boundaries are often discussed online is that they sound like ultimatums. That's not how relationships actually work." Jacqui builds on this insight, explaining that boundaries are fundamentally about your own behavior: what you're willing to do or accept, rather than controlling others.
Together, they discuss practical strategies for recognizing when a boundary is needed, how to communicate it effectively, and why consistency matters even when others push back. At their core, boundaries protect your emotional space while respecting others' autonomy. They're about creating clarity, not building walls.
This episode offers a thoughtful, real-world perspective on honoring your needs while preserving your relationships. As Jacqui emphasizes, boundaries aren't about cutting people off. They're about being clear with yourself first, then communicating those limits with grace and intention.

Vol XXIII: Why Setting Boundaries Feels So Hard (And How to Do It Anyway)

In the hierarchy of modern relationships, friendship occupies a peculiar position: essential to our wellbeing, central to our happiness, yet always relegated to the emotional back burner when life gets serious. Romance gets the red carpet but friendship gets the leftover energy.

The episode looks at the particular challenges of millennial friendship maintenance, the juggling act of careers, partnerships, children, and the basic maintenance of adult existence. Balancing connection with the demands of daily life feels overwhelming, and friendships slip through the cracks.

Jacqui takes us back to basics: friendship is about presence. Small, consistent actions make all the difference. The voice note trumps the dinner party. The quick check-in beats the elaborate gesture. Consistency is the currency that matters. They tackle the friendship emotions everyone talks about: the guilt of being available enough, the little pang of jealousy when a friend's life looks more polished than yours, and why being a good friend means showing up as you are.

The episode's most potent revelation: being a good friend means resisting the urge to fix, to solve, to optimize. The most profound gift you offer is being willing to sit in someone else's mess while trying to clean it up.

In a world obsessed with romantic partnerships, this is a love letter to our friends. 

In the hierarchy of modern relationships, friendship occupies a peculiar position: essential to our wellbeing, central to our happiness, yet always relegated to the emotional back burner when life gets serious. Romance gets the red carpet but friendship gets the leftover energy.
The episode looks at the particular challenges of millennial friendship maintenance, the juggling act of careers, partnerships, children, and the basic maintenance of adult existence. Balancing connection with the demands of daily life feels overwhelming, and friendships slip through the cracks.
Jacqui takes us back to basics: friendship is about presence. Small, consistent actions make all the difference. The voice note trumps the dinner party. The quick check-in beats the elaborate gesture. Consistency is the currency that matters. They tackle the friendship emotions everyone talks about: the guilt of being available enough, the little pang of jealousy when a friend's life looks more polished than yours, and why being a good friend means showing up as you are.
The episode's most potent revelation: being a good friend means resisting the urge to fix, to solve, to optimize. The most profound gift you offer is being willing to sit in someone else's mess while trying to clean it up.
In a world obsessed with romantic partnerships, this is a love letter to our friends.&nbsp;

Vol XXII:  How to Be a Good Friend

What Matters Most shines the light on the therapy we need in our everyday lives. Drawing from the minds of two friends, Jacqui Maguire a clinical psychologist and Antonia Prebble, an actress and presenter, we create a space for exploring everyday issues that make up the moral and cultural climate of our era. Each week Antonia will bring the topic, Jacqui will bring the therapist lens, and together they will get curious. It’s as simple as that!

Conversations between two friends that support, provide practical tools, are light-hearted at times, joyful, soulful and offer that little bit of ‘friendship mixed with therapy’ on the days that you might need it.

Returning in 2027

What Matters Most shines the light on the therapy we need in our everyday lives. Drawing from the minds of two friends, Jacqui Maguire a clinical psychologist and Antonia Prebble, an actress and presenter, we create a space for exploring everyday issues that make up the moral and cultural climate of our era. Each week Antonia will bring the topic, Jacqui will bring the therapist lens, and together they will get curious. It&rsquo;s as simple as that!
Conversations between two friends that support, provide practical tools, are light-hearted at times, joyful, soulful and offer that little bit of &lsquo;friendship mixed with therapy&rsquo; on the days that you might need it.
Returning in 2027

What Matters Most

Social links:

Follow the podcast:

32 clip(s)