The College Football Playoff bracket is officially set — and the biggest story of the day is the three-team debate everyone is talking about: Notre Dame, Miami, and Alabama.

In this reaction episode, Barrett Sallee and John Michaels break down every angle of the controversy:

🔥 Did Notre Dame get screwed?
The Irish beat big brands, stayed consistent, and still got pushed out of the final CFP field. Was the committee’s decision justified — or a total miss?

🔥 Miami Hurricanes crash the playoff field
For the first time in decades, the Canes are in the national title hunt. Did Miami truly earn their spot, or did the chaos around them open the door?

🔥 Alabama makes the CFP after getting smoked by Georgia
The Tide were blown out 28–7 in the SEC Championship. So how did they still make the bracket? And should they have?

We also dive into:
• Strength of schedule arguments
• Head-to-head that finally mattered
• Why Notre Dame was the “odd team out”
• Whether Alabama’s résumé was overrated
• How Miami flipped the narrative late in the season
• What the new 12-team format gets right — and wrong

This is the MOST controversial CFP bracket yet, and we’re breaking it all down.

👇 Drop your take in the comments:
Who deserved it more — Notre Dame, Miami, or Alabama?

 

#CFP #CollegeFootballPlayoff #NotreDame #MiamiHurricanes #AlabamaFootball #RollTide #CFPReaction #CFPBreakdown #CFPSelectionShow #NCAAF #CollegeFootball #SECFootball #ACCFootball #IrishFootball #MiamiFootball #BamaFootball #PlayoffDebate #CFPControversy #CFPBracket #SportsPodcast #680TheFan #BarrettSallee #JohnMichaels #FootballTalk #CollegeFootballNews

The College Football Playoff bracket is officially set &mdash; and the biggest story of the day is the three-team debate everyone is talking about: Notre Dame, Miami, and Alabama.
In this reaction episode, Barrett Sallee and John Michaels break down every angle of the controversy:
🔥 Did Notre Dame get screwed? The Irish beat big brands, stayed consistent, and still got pushed out of the final CFP field. Was the committee&rsquo;s decision justified &mdash; or a total miss?
🔥 Miami Hurricanes crash the playoff field For the first time in decades, the Canes are in the national title hunt. Did Miami truly earn their spot, or did the chaos around them open the door?
🔥 Alabama makes the CFP after getting smoked by Georgia The Tide were blown out 28&ndash;7 in the SEC Championship. So how did they still make the bracket? And should they have?
We also dive into: &bull; Strength of schedule arguments &bull; Head-to-head that finally mattered &bull; Why Notre Dame was the &ldquo;odd team out&rdquo; &bull; Whether Alabama&rsquo;s r&eacute;sum&eacute; was overrated &bull; How Miami flipped the narrative late in the season &bull; What the new 12-team format gets right &mdash; and wrong
This is the MOST controversial CFP bracket yet, and we&rsquo;re breaking it all down.
👇 Drop your take in the comments: Who deserved it more &mdash; Notre Dame, Miami, or Alabama?
<hr data-start="1548" data-end="1551">
&nbsp;
#CFP #CollegeFootballPlayoff #NotreDame #MiamiHurricanes #AlabamaFootball #RollTide #CFPReaction #CFPBreakdown #CFPSelectionShow #NCAAF #CollegeFootball #SECFootball #ACCFootball #IrishFootball #MiamiFootball #BamaFootball #PlayoffDebate #CFPControversy #CFPBracket #SportsPodcast #680TheFan #BarrettSallee #JohnMichaels #FootballTalk #CollegeFootballNews

Did Notre Dame Get Screwed? Miami Jumps In and Alabama Survives the Cut | CFB Playoff Reaction

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, breaks down the latest College Football Playoff rankings with a focus on Alabama, Notre Dame, and Miami. The hosts examine how outcomes on conference championship weekend could reshape the playoff picture, especially for teams on the bubble. They also dive into Lane Kiffin’s departure from Ole Miss, discussing how the coaching change may impact the Rebels’ postseason readiness.

The show previews this weekend’s marquee conference championship matchups, including:
Big Ten: Ohio State vs. Indiana 
ACC: Duke vs. Virginia
Big 12: BYU vs. Texas Tech
SEC: Georgia vs. Alabama

Michaels and Sallee assess each game’s stakes, implications, and potential pathways to the playoff as Championship Weekend arrives.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, breaks down the latest College Football Playoff rankings with a focus on Alabama, Notre Dame, and Miami. The hosts examine how outcomes on conference championship weekend could reshape the playoff picture, especially for teams on the bubble. They also dive into Lane Kiffin&rsquo;s departure from Ole Miss, discussing how the coaching change may impact the Rebels&rsquo; postseason readiness.
The show previews this weekend&rsquo;s marquee conference championship matchups, including:
<ul>
<li>Big Ten: Ohio State vs. Indiana&nbsp;</li>
<li>ACC: Duke vs. Virginia</li>
<li>Big 12: BYU vs. Texas Tech</li>
<li>SEC: Georgia vs. Alabama</li>
</ul>
Michaels and Sallee assess each game&rsquo;s stakes, implications, and potential pathways to the playoff as Championship Weekend arrives.

CFP Rankings Reaction, Conference Championship Games & the Playoff Path Ahead

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, delivers an in-depth look at the biggest storylines shaping the college football landscape. The hosts analyze the latest developments surrounding Lane Kiffin’s coaching future, discussing how his pending decision could impact his program’s trajectory as it continues its push for a playoff berth. They also offer their reactions to the most recent College Football Playoff rankings, breaking down what the committee got right, what raises questions, and how the race may unfold.

With Rivalry Weekend headlining the schedule, Michaels and Sallee preview all the marquee matchups, including the Iron Bowl (Alabama vs. Auburn), Clean Old-Fashioned Hate (Georgia vs. Georgia Tech), the Lone Star Showdown (Texas A&M vs. Texas), Tennessee vs. Vanderbilt, and The Game (Ohio State vs. Michigan). The show provides insight, context, and expert analysis on how these rivalry clashes could shape the postseason landscape.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, delivers an in-depth look at the biggest storylines shaping the college football landscape. The hosts analyze the latest developments surrounding Lane Kiffin&rsquo;s coaching future, discussing how his pending decision could impact his program&rsquo;s trajectory as it continues its push for a playoff berth. They also offer their reactions to the most recent College Football Playoff rankings, breaking down what the committee got right, what raises questions, and how the race may unfold.
With Rivalry Weekend headlining the schedule, Michaels and Sallee preview all the marquee matchups, including the Iron Bowl (Alabama vs. Auburn), Clean Old-Fashioned Hate (Georgia vs. Georgia Tech), the Lone Star Showdown (Texas A&amp;M vs. Texas), Tennessee vs. Vanderbilt, and The Game (Ohio State vs. Michigan). The show provides insight, context, and expert analysis on how these rivalry clashes could shape the postseason landscape.

Rivalry Weekend Tension: Kiffin’s Next Move and the Playoff Rankings Shake-Up

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, recaps Week 13 highlights, including Georgia Tech’s escape at Boston College and their positioning just one win away from clinching an ACC Championship Game berth. The hosts cover Oklahoma’s victory over Alabama, Georgia’s dominant win over Texas, and Texas A&M’s stunning 27-point second-half comeback against South Carolina. The discussion then shifts to this week’s CFP rankings, debating whether the committee accurately reflected team performances, particularly Miami’s placement below Notre Dame despite an earlier head-to-head victory. The show concludes with an in-depth look at the biggest storyline in college football, as Lane Kiffin faces pressure from LSU and Florida and must decide whether to remain at Ole Miss or pursue other opportunities.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, recaps Week 13 highlights, including Georgia Tech&rsquo;s escape at Boston College and their positioning just one win away from clinching an ACC Championship Game berth. The hosts cover Oklahoma&rsquo;s victory over Alabama, Georgia&rsquo;s dominant win over Texas, and Texas A&amp;M&rsquo;s stunning 27-point second-half comeback against South Carolina. The discussion then shifts to this week&rsquo;s CFP rankings, debating whether the committee accurately reflected team performances, particularly Miami&rsquo;s placement below Notre Dame despite an earlier head-to-head victory. The show concludes with an in-depth look at the biggest storyline in college football, as Lane Kiffin faces pressure from LSU and Florida and must decide whether to remain at Ole Miss or pursue other opportunities.

Lane Kiffin’s Crossroads, Georgia Tech’s Title Push, and CFP Rankings Debated

On The Fan’s College Football Show, hosts John Michaels and Barrett Sallee recapped Week 11 of the college football season. Highlights included Indiana’s narrow victory over Penn State on a late drive from Heisman favorite Fernando Mendoza, Texas A&M’s continued push as national championship contenders, and Oregon’s dramatic road win at Iowa with a game-winning drive from Dante Moore. The hosts also debated whether teams would rather compete in conference championship games or prioritize playoff preparation, discussed benching decisions involving preseason standout quarterbacks LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier and Florida’s DJ Lagway, and analyzed the evolving Heisman conversation. The show concluded with a preview of Week 12 matchups, including Oklahoma vs. Alabama, Notre Dame vs. Pittsburgh, and Texas vs. Georgia.

On The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosts John Michaels and Barrett Sallee recapped Week 11 of the college football season. Highlights included Indiana&rsquo;s narrow victory over Penn State on a late drive from Heisman favorite Fernando Mendoza, Texas A&amp;M&rsquo;s continued push as national championship contenders, and Oregon&rsquo;s dramatic road win at Iowa with a game-winning drive from Dante Moore. The hosts also debated whether teams would rather compete in conference championship games or prioritize playoff preparation, discussed benching decisions involving preseason standout quarterbacks LSU&rsquo;s Garrett Nussmeier and Florida&rsquo;s DJ Lagway, and analyzed the evolving Heisman conversation. The show concluded with a preview of Week 12 matchups, including Oklahoma vs. Alabama, Notre Dame vs. Pittsburgh, and Texas vs. Georgia.

Indiana & Oregon Escape, Benched Preseason Heisman Favorites, & Pitt Eyes Playoff Upheaval

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, recapped a headline-filled Week 9 across the college football landscape. The hosts broke down Texas A&M’s dominant win over LSU, which led to the breaking news of LSU parting ways with head coach Brian Kelly. They also discussed the rising stock of Ole Miss head coach Lane Kiffin, calling him one of the hottest coaching commodities in the country, and debated whether he might consider leaving for a premier program such as LSU or Florida. Additionally, the show reviewed Ole Miss’ win over Oklahoma and the mounting pressure on Sooners head coach Brent Venables as playoff hopes fade. Looking ahead, Barrett and John previewed an exciting Week 10 slate featuring marquee matchups including Vanderbilt vs. Texas, Georgia vs. Florida, Oklahoma vs. Tennessee, and Cincinnati vs. Utah.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, recapped a headline-filled Week 9 across the college football landscape. The hosts broke down Texas A&amp;M&rsquo;s dominant win over LSU, which led to the breaking news of LSU parting ways with head coach Brian Kelly. They also discussed the rising stock of Ole Miss head coach Lane Kiffin, calling him one of the hottest coaching commodities in the country, and debated whether he might consider leaving for a premier program such as LSU or Florida. Additionally, the show reviewed Ole Miss&rsquo; win over Oklahoma and the mounting pressure on Sooners head coach Brent Venables as playoff hopes fade. Looking ahead, Barrett and John previewed an exciting Week 10 slate featuring marquee matchups including Vanderbilt vs. Texas, Georgia vs. Florida, Oklahoma vs. Tennessee, and Cincinnati vs. Utah.

Brian Kelly’s Firing Rocks the SEC | Texas A&M’s Title Push & Oklahoma’s Struggles

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, recapped a wild Week 8 that saw major shakeups across the Top 10. Both #2 Miami and #7 Texas Tech suffered upset losses, while #9 Georgia outlasted #5 Ole Miss in a high-scoring thriller. #12 Georgia Tech narrowly escaped Duke, and #17 Vanderbilt stunned #10 LSU in one of the weekend’s biggest surprises.

John Michaels also weighed in on Florida’s decision to fire head coach Billy Napier, discussing potential replacements in Gainesville and evaluating Florida State’s Mike Norvell, whose seat is heating up amid growing pressure. The hosts examined the staggering buyouts for fired college coaches and previewed a loaded Week 9 slate featuring #8 Ole Miss vs. #13 Oklahoma, #4 Alabama vs. South Carolina, and #15 Missouri vs. #10 Vanderbilt. Michaels closed the show with his bold prediction of the weekend, forecasting another major upset in the making.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by John Michaels and Barrett Sallee, recapped a wild Week 8 that saw major shakeups across the Top 10. Both #2 Miami and #7 Texas Tech suffered upset losses, while #9 Georgia outlasted #5 Ole Miss in a high-scoring thriller. #12 Georgia Tech narrowly escaped Duke, and #17 Vanderbilt stunned #10 LSU in one of the weekend&rsquo;s biggest surprises.
John Michaels also weighed in on Florida&rsquo;s decision to fire head coach Billy Napier, discussing potential replacements in Gainesville and evaluating Florida State&rsquo;s Mike Norvell, whose seat is heating up amid growing pressure. The hosts examined the staggering buyouts for fired college coaches and previewed a loaded Week 9 slate featuring #8 Ole Miss vs. #13 Oklahoma, #4 Alabama vs. South Carolina, and #15 Missouri vs. #10 Vanderbilt. Michaels closed the show with his bold prediction of the weekend, forecasting another major upset in the making.

Top-10 Chaos: Miami Falls, Texas Tech Stunned & Florida Fires Napier

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, recap Week 6 of the college football season. The hosts discuss teams and coaches under fire, including Miami’s dominant performance over Florida State, raising the question of whether Miami should be the #1 ranked team in the country. They also cover Penn State’s upset loss to UCLA, with James Franklin facing scrutiny over program concerns, and Texas’s loss to Florida, highlighting developmental questions for Arch Manning and former QB Quinn Ewers. Other topics include Bill Belichick and UNC’s struggles.

Looking ahead, the hosts preview Week 7 matchups, including:

#8 Alabama vs. #14 Missouri 

#10 Georgia vs. Auburn

#1 Ohio State vs. #17 Illinois

Virginia Tech vs. #13 Georgia Tech

Game of the Week: #7 Indiana vs. #3 Oregon

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, recap Week 6 of the college football season. The hosts discuss teams and coaches under fire, including Miami&rsquo;s dominant performance over Florida State, raising the question of whether Miami should be the #1 ranked team in the country. They also cover Penn State&rsquo;s upset loss to UCLA, with James Franklin facing scrutiny over program concerns, and Texas&rsquo;s loss to Florida, highlighting developmental questions for Arch Manning and former QB Quinn Ewers. Other topics include Bill Belichick and UNC&rsquo;s struggles.
Looking ahead, the hosts preview Week 7 matchups, including:
#8 Alabama vs. #14 Missouri&nbsp;
#10 Georgia vs. Auburn
#1 Ohio State vs. #17 Illinois
Virginia Tech vs. #13 Georgia Tech
Game of the Week: #7 Indiana vs. #3 Oregon

Miami #1, Coaches Under Fire & Indiana Goes West to Make a Statement

The Fan’s College Football Show, hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, recaps Week 5 of the college football season, highlighting major upsets and storylines. The hosts discuss #17 Alabama’s victory over #5 Georgia, continuing Kirby Smart’s struggles against the Crimson Tide; #6 Oregon’s win over #3 Penn State in their Whiteout game, examining Drew Allar and James Franklin’s ongoing challenges in big matchups; and #13 Ole Miss’ upset of #4 LSU, raising questions about Brian Kelly and Garrett Nussmeier while praising Lane Kiffin. They also preview Week 6’s top matchups, including #3 Miami vs. #18 Florida State and #16 Vanderbilt vs. #10 Alabama. Additionally, Sallee and Michaels analyze Arkansas’ decision to fire head coach Sam Pittman, the appointment of interim coach and former OC Bobby Petrino, and potential offseason candidates. The episode concludes with their bold predictions and weekend locks.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show, hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, recaps Week 5 of the college football season, highlighting major upsets and storylines. The hosts discuss #17 Alabama&rsquo;s victory over #5 Georgia, continuing Kirby Smart&rsquo;s struggles against the Crimson Tide; #6 Oregon&rsquo;s win over #3 Penn State in their Whiteout game, examining Drew Allar and James Franklin&rsquo;s ongoing challenges in big matchups; and #13 Ole Miss&rsquo; upset of #4 LSU, raising questions about Brian Kelly and Garrett Nussmeier while praising Lane Kiffin. They also preview Week 6&rsquo;s top matchups, including #3 Miami vs. #18 Florida State and #16 Vanderbilt vs. #10 Alabama. Additionally, Sallee and Michaels analyze Arkansas&rsquo; decision to fire head coach Sam Pittman, the appointment of interim coach and former OC Bobby Petrino, and potential offseason candidates. The episode concludes with their bold predictions and weekend locks.

Alabama's Kirby's Boogeyman, Penn State Drops Their Whiteout, & Pittman's Out at Arkansas

The Fan’s College Football Show hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, deliver a comprehensive Week 4 recap, highlighted by Auburn’s controversial loss to Oklahoma after the SEC ruled one of the Sooners’ touchdowns should not have counted. The show also covers Indiana’s dominant win over Illinois and turns the spotlight to Week 5, previewing marquee matchups including No. 21 USC at No. 23 Illinois, No. 4 LSU at No. 13 Ole Miss, No. 6 Oregon at No. 3 Penn State, and No. 17 Alabama at No. 5 Georgia. Additionally, the hosts examine Clemson’s latest setback with a loss to Syracuse and discuss what it could mean for Dabo Swinney’s future at the program.

The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, deliver a comprehensive Week 4 recap, highlighted by Auburn&rsquo;s controversial loss to Oklahoma after the SEC ruled one of the Sooners&rsquo; touchdowns should not have counted. The show also covers Indiana&rsquo;s dominant win over Illinois and turns the spotlight to Week 5, previewing marquee matchups including No. 21 USC at No. 23 Illinois, No. 4 LSU at No. 13 Ole Miss, No. 6 Oregon at No. 3 Penn State, and No. 17 Alabama at No. 5 Georgia. Additionally, the hosts examine Clemson&rsquo;s latest setback with a loss to Syracuse and discuss what it could mean for Dabo Swinney&rsquo;s future at the program.

Auburn vs Oklahoma Controversy, Georgia vs Alabama Showdown & What’s Next for Dabo Swinney

Hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, The Fan’s College Football Show is your all-access pass to the biggest games and boldest storylines across the nation each week. As the College Football Voice of the South, Barrett and John break down matchups, share insider analysis, and even sprinkle in a little gambling talk along the way.

From SEC Saturdays to playoff predictions, this is the show for fans who live and breathe college football.

Hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Show is your all-access pass to the biggest games and boldest storylines across the nation each week. As the College Football Voice of the South, Barrett and John break down matchups, share insider analysis, and even sprinkle in a little gambling talk along the way.
From SEC Saturdays to playoff predictions, this is the show for fans who live and breathe college football.

The Fan's College Football Show

Hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, The Fan’s College Football Podcast is your all-access pass to the biggest games and boldest storylines across the nation each week. As the College Football Voice of the South, Barrett and John break down matchups, share insider analysis, and even sprinkle in a little gambling talk along the way.

From SEC Saturdays to playoff predictions, this is the show for fans who live and breathe college football.

Hosted by Barrett Sallee and John Michaels, The Fan&rsquo;s College Football Podcast is your all-access pass to the biggest games and boldest storylines across the nation each week. As the College Football Voice of the South, Barrett and John break down matchups, share insider analysis, and even sprinkle in a little gambling talk along the way.
From SEC Saturdays to playoff predictions, this is the show for fans who live and breathe college football.

The Fan's College Football Show

Social links:

Follow the podcast:

13 clip(s)