Maria Muglia goes on trial for the murder of her sister-in-law, Connie Armaro. To the family, the case against her appears overwhelming — but inside the courtroom, serious questions begin to emerge.The prosecution relies on a web of circumstantial evidence: phone records, soil, fibres, tyre impressions, footprints and black plastic. Yet Maria’s defence exposes weaknesses in almost every strand. And one question refuses to go away: could Maria really have killed Connie and disposed of her body alone?We examine a mysterious man who visited Maria’s brothel on the night Connie disappeared, evidence of a possible accomplice, and a family secret that never became central to the prosecution case.As the jury considers its verdict, a seemingly certain murder conviction is suddenly anything but certain.