Chuck Todd’s MVP of the midterms is John Roberts. In the first Super Tuesday after Democrats swept the House, the Senate and a majority of governorships, Chuck and Chris Cillizza go straight to superlatives — five best-run campaigns, five worst, five most overrated ideas, five biggest ironies — and the thread through all of them is that Republicans beat themselves. Mid-decade redistricting is Chuck’s worst campaign of the cycle: maps drawn off Trump’s 2024 numbers blew up in South Texas and South Florida, while the Court’s gutting of the Voting Rights Act helped produce what may be the largest Black midterm turnout on record. Plus the best-run campaign nobody mentioned on election night, the case that polling isn’t broken (paying for polling is), why Trump’s voters showed up and declined to vote Republican, what Stephen Miller replacing Susie Wiles means for the next two years, and a personal account of Miami’s loss at Notre Dame.
Timeline:
00:00 The first post-election show, and the five best-run campaigns of the cycle
08:00 Ayotte, Colom, Andrews, Ossoff — and why Talarico didn’t make the list
14:00 Five worst campaigns: redistricting, Paxton, and Vivek Ramaswamy
20:00 Marshall, Platner, and whether any Democrat actually blew it
25:00 Overrated ideas: vouchers, third parties, and super PAC money
30:00 Polling isn’t broken, and the Roberts court as a turnout machine
36:00 Voter ID everywhere, a red undertow, and the Schumer question
44:00 Media winners and losers, and Silicon Valley’s failed bet
50:00 Why the Miller pick is catastrophic, and the Sun Belt’s takeover
56:00 South Bend: the call, Catholics versus Convicts, and the ghosts of 1988
1:04:00 Notre Dame deserved it, a tribute to a friend’s mother, and 100,000 subs



