Sawyer thought his first date with Keely was full of chemistry, shared love languages, and what he believed was mutual affection. But while Sawyer saw constant hand-holding as a sign of connection, Keely experienced it very differently. By the end of the night, something that felt small to him became a dealbreaker for her. Find out everything on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

Brooks & Taryn - Nickname Nincompoop - 03-19-26
08:31

Ashlynn & Don - Like the Movies - 03-18-26
07:09

Robbi & David - Germaphobe - 03-17-26
08:13