



Ethan & Marissa - Date Night to Dad Mode - 06-30-26
Ethan and Marissa met at a networking event and hit it off enough to grab drinks afterward. He thought their first date was going perfectly, laughs, good conversation, even walking her home like a gentleman. But Marissa never called him back. What did Marissa see after their date that had her confi…

Ava & Brent - Red Head Redemption - 06-26-26
Ava thought she had one of those rare, instant-chemistry first dates with Brent, great conversation, future talk, and even a kiss to seal it. But after the date, Brent quietly disappeared, leaving her completely confused. When the truth comes out, it turns out something he saw after the date sent h…

Mikey & Annie - Safety First, Romance Second - 06-25-26
After a great dinner together, Mikey was shocked when Annie suddenly went from talking about extending the night to completely ghosting him. When we finally get Annie on the phone, she reveals that one habit of Mikey's was simply too much for her to handle.

Kim & Jeffrey - CSI: First Date - 06-24-26
Kim thought she had found a genuinely thoughtful guy when she met Jeffrey on Hinge. He seemed to remember every detail, asked all the right questions, and somehow knew things about her that made it feel like they had known each other for years. But after the date, Jeffrey disappeared, and when the …

Jennifer & Raymond - Nailed It - 06-23-26
Jennifer thought her date with Raymond was a success, but afterward he completely ghosted her, leaving her confused about what went wrong. When we get him on the phone, Raymond admits she “had it going on”… except for one detail that instantly turned him off and made him question everything. Jennif…

Derek & Lila - The Laugh Factory - 06-22-26
Derek thought he had a near-perfect first date with Lila, easy conversation, and a connection based on their shared sense of humor. He walked away thinking his personality carried the night and maybe even earned him a second date. But now? Total silence. When Lila finally joins the show, she admi…

Coleman & Briar - The Night She Wanted To Erase - 06-18-26
Coleman thought his first date with Briar was a movie-worthy success, instant chemistry, flirty conversation, and a connection that carried all the way back to his place. But by the next morning, Briar was gone and completely cut off contact. When we hear her side, it becomes clear that the night t…

Sawyer & Keely - Can't Let You Go - 06-17-26
Sawyer thought his first date with Keely was full of chemistry, shared love languages, and what he believed was mutual affection. But while Sawyer saw constant hand-holding as a sign of connection, Keely experienced it very differently. By the end of the night, something that felt small to him beca…

Brooks & Taryn - Easy on the Nicknames - 06-16-26
Brooks thought his high-energy personality made for a fun, memorable first date, great conversation, and even introducing Taryn to his friends mid-date. But what he saw as playful and outgoing quickly turned awkward, and Taryn says something about the way he interacted with his friends completely c…

Megan & Kyle - The Steakhouse Standoff - 06-15-26
Megan thought her first date with Kyle was going great, a fun dinner at a new restaurant, and plenty of signs there could be a second date. But by the end of the meal, Kyle had clearly changed his tune and never reached out again. When we finally get Kyle on the phone, he reveals that something tha…