Sabrina and Carter's flirty Hinge messages translated into plenty of chemistry when they finally met, and the night eventually continued back at Sabrina's place. Sabrina thought everything went great, but Carter couldn't get past her habit of calling out song requests to Alexa in the middle of their hookup, turning their romantic night into a bizarre live soundtrack featuring Shania Twain, Boyz II Men and Eric Church. Apparently Alexa made one third wheel too many. It's a BRAND NEW Second Date Update