Jared thought he'd hit it off with Melinda after a fun first date filled with arcade games, friendly competition, and winning prizes. But when Melinda stopped returning his calls, Jared couldn't figure out what went wrong. Turns out, while Jared thought he was just joking around and giving her a hard time, Melinda felt like he was judging her the entire night. What Jared considered harmless teasing ended up being anything but fun for Melinda!