Garrett thought his first date with Natalie was a huge success. They laughed all night, enjoyed dinner together, and one spontaneous decision at the restaurant seemed harmless in the moment. But Natalie says that one small choice revealed something much bigger about Garrett, and it completely changed how she saw him. Find out what happened on a BRAND NEW Second Date Update!

Madison & Tyler - All Bark No Bite - 07-09-26
08:20

Evan & Tessa - Phoning It In - 07-08-26
07:00

Marcus & Danielle - Dinner Dealbreaker - 07-07-26
07:05