Suzanne blows our minds with a wild theory about what really happened to Jess and that mysterious black eye, and it completely changes how Tara sees the episode.

Rory is giving us major red flags, from her relationship insecurities to Friday Night Dinner. Is Jess really the problem…or is it Rory?

Plus, this is Alex’s last appearance as Lorelai’s boyfriend. Hear how we knew they wouldn’t last.