Madeline thought she knew exactly why Jesse was ghosting her after their first date. After all, she had accidentally punched him in the nuts while trying to go in for a handshake. But when Jesse finally explains why he really disappeared, there’s another unforgettable moment from the date that changes everything.

What happened at dinner involving a shoe, a smell test, and a plate of calamari? And why does Jesse immediately know he never wants a second date? Listen to this hilarious First Date Follow Up on The Jubal Show to hear the full story—and the absolutely wild misunderstanding that sends the conversation completely off the rails.