A 28-year-old high school teacher called the show with a confession that's putting his heart and his reputation on the line. After running into a former student, now 23 years old and years removed from graduation, the two reconnected and started texting regularly. While nothing inappropriate ever happened when she was in school, he's now wondering if pursuing a relationship would be perfectly acceptable... or a line that should never be crossed. Billy, Candice, and Producer Pooh tackle the tough question: Does the "former student" label make the relationship off-limits forever, or are they simply two adults with a five-year age gap? The debate quickly turns into one of the most divided Dirty Little Secrets yet, with opinions ranging from "follow your heart" to "the optics just don't feel right. It's a complicated confession filled with questions about love, ethics, perception, and second chances. Tune in to hear the full story and decide for yourself: Would you date a former student if enough time had passed?

Got a Dirty Little Secret of your own? You can stay completely anonymous and share your confession with us. Your secret might be featured on a future episode of Billy The Kidd In The Morning!