TTS Test 1All Blacks v France: Why Scott Robertson must stick with Vaa'i and Proctor projects - Gregor Paul
THE FACTS
The All Blacks face a decision on continuing with Tupou Vaa'i at blindside and Billy Proctor in the midfield.
Vaa'i's role is complicated by Scott Barrett's injury, with options to keep him at blindside or move him back to lock.
Proctor's potential requires more test experience, despite some inexperience showing against France, to develop his skills.
Having not necessarily obtained conclusive answers as to whether Tupou Vaa'i is a genuine option at blindside and whether Billy Proctor can deliver his all-court game in the higher intensity world of test rugby, the All Blacks face a stick-or-twist scenario this week in selecting their team.
Will the coaching panel double down on the two, first-test selections that arguably created the most dramatic sense yet about what type of rugby Scott Robertson's All Blacks want to play?
Or will they pause the Vaa'i and Proctor projects in pursuit of answers about other possible experiments they may be pondering?
The picture with Vaa'i is slightly changed due to the injury to captain Scott Barrett, which, as assistant Scott Hansen confirmed, has left the coaches working through their replacement plans.
For the second test in Wellington, there is a relatively simple option of elevating Patrick Tuipulotu to the starting team at lock alongside Fabian Holland and retaining Vaa'i at blindside.
The alternative would be to restore Vaa'i to his usual position of lock, pick Samipeni Finau at No 6 and have one of Tuipolutu or Holland start and the other on the bench.
The first option appeals as less disruptive and more productive.
Tuipulotu has the experience and maturity to guide the one-cap Holland through another test, and if the All Blacks coaches are serious about Vaa'i becoming a hybrid tight-loose forward, then the commitment to get him to that point has to be greater than one test.
Throughout the past 20 years, the All Blacks have dabbled in what could be called lock-conversion therapy - periodically they have been taken with the athleticism, mobility and size of various players and tried to develop them into dual options in both the second and back rows of the scrum.
The list includes Troy Flavell, Jackson Hemopo, Scott Barrett and now Vaa'i - while so too at various times were the likes of Reuben Thorne, Steven Luatua, Jerome Kaino and Kieran Read considered loose forwards with the capacity to cover lock.
It's been an ongoing theme, but the success rate would be considered low, primarily because coaches have only ever dabbled and never properly committed to the concept.
And if Vaa'i is to become what this coaching panel wants him to be, then he needs to play more than one test at blindside to develop greater affinity for and understanding of the role.
His performance in Dunedin was good enough to suggest he's worth another look, but not so good as to say he can now be ticked off as a blindside option and put back into cold storage, as it were, by being returned to his first home in the locks.
Presumably the long-term plan is to build Vaa'i to the point where he comes under consideration to start against South Africa later this year as the antidote to the supremely influential Pieter-Steph du Toit.
Ideally, he would then develop through to the World Cup where his versatility could be hugely advantageous in how it would enable the All Blacks to vary their selections and adapt their bench to face different opponents.
Proctor currently finds himself in a group of six midfielders and a desire within the coaching group to give everyone in the squad game time against France.
His selection fate is also perhaps further compromised by the fact his inexperience at test level was exposed at times in Dunedin, nowhere more noticeable than midway through the first half when French fullback Théo Attissogbe beat him on the outside.
It was a classic case of a player used to Super Rugby Pacific being surprised by the pace of the international game. While some will have interpreted that incident as ...
The All Blacks face a decision on continuing with Tupou Vaa'i at blindside and Billy Proctor in the midfield.
Vaa'i's role is complicated by Scott Barrett's injury, with options to keep him at blindside or move him back to lock.
Proctor's potential requires more test experience, despite some inexperience showing against France, to develop his skills.
Having not necessarily obtained conclusive answers as to whether Tupou Vaa'i is a genuine option at blindside and whether Billy Proctor can deliver his all-court game in the higher intensity world of test rugby, the All Blacks face a stick-or-twist scenario this week in selecting their team.
Will the coaching panel double down on the two, first-test selections that arguably created the most dramatic sense yet about what type of rugby Scott Robertson's All Blacks want to play?
Or will they pause the Vaa'i and Proctor projects in pursuit of answers about other possible experiments they may be pondering?
The picture with Vaa'i is slightly changed due to the injury to captain Scott Barrett, which, as assistant Scott Hansen confirmed, has left the coaches working through their replacement plans.
For the second test in Wellington, there is a relatively simple option of elevating Patrick Tuipulotu to the starting team at lock alongside Fabian Holland and retaining Vaa'i at blindside.
The alternative would be to restore Vaa'i to his usual position of lock, pick Samipeni Finau at No 6 and have one of Tuipolutu or Holland start and the other on the bench.
The first option appeals as less disruptive and more productive.
Tuipulotu has the experience and maturity to guide the one-cap Holland through another test, and if the All Blacks coaches are serious about Vaa'i becoming a hybrid tight-loose forward, then the commitment to get him to that point has to be greater than one test.
Throughout the past 20 years, the All Blacks have dabbled in what could be called lock-conversion therapy - periodically they have been taken with the athleticism, mobility and size of various players and tried to develop them into dual options in both the second and back rows of the scrum.
The list includes Troy Flavell, Jackson Hemopo, Scott Barrett and now Vaa'i - while so too at various times were the likes of Reuben Thorne, Steven Luatua, Jerome Kaino and Kieran Read considered loose forwards with the capacity to cover lock.
It's been an ongoing theme, but the success rate would be considered low, primarily because coaches have only ever dabbled and never properly committed to the concept.
And if Vaa'i is to become what this coaching panel wants him to be, then he needs to play more than one test at blindside to develop greater affinity for and understanding of the role.
His performance in Dunedin was good enough to suggest he's worth another look, but not so good as to say he can now be ticked off as a blindside option and put back into cold storage, as it were, by being returned to his first home in the locks.
Presumably the long-term plan is to build Vaa'i to the point where he comes under consideration to start against South Africa later this year as the antidote to the supremely influential Pieter-Steph du Toit.
Ideally, he would then develop through to the World Cup where his versatility could be hugely advantageous in how it would enable the All Blacks to vary their selections and adapt their bench to face different opponents.
Proctor currently finds himself in a group of six midfielders and a desire within the coaching group to give everyone in the squad game time against France.
His selection fate is also perhaps further compromised by the fact his inexperience at test level was exposed at times in Dunedin, nowhere more noticeable than midway through the first half when French fullback Théo Attissogbe beat him on the outside.
It was a classic case of a player used to Super Rugby Pacific being surprised by the pace of the international game. While some will have interpreted that incident as ...
In 1 playlist(s)
TTS Test 1
TTS test 1Social links
Follow podcast
Recent clips
Gaza civil defence says Israeli strikes kill 43 as truce talks deadlocked
05:11
Travel Alerts: Tortoise encounters, french feasts, and a crocheted wharenui
03:55
Queenstown, Air NZ shine in Travel + Leisure's World's Best Awards
03:30