It's 1-1 on Nicola Willis, for me.
Three economists were asked in an article last week what her legacy was. "Inconsequential" was the reply.
A good politician but made no real difference as minister.
I thought it was harsh, not because it's necessarily untrue (because it might not be), but we do have a habit in this country of kicking people when they're down.
Willis is an unusual victim of a government that most likely will be returned without her. It doesn’t happen every day.
Maybe a week or two's grace before we trash the reputation would have been nice.
Anyway, counter balancing that was perhaps the reason they called her more the 'politician' than the Finance Minister.
The MBIE advice released last week that shows very clearly National's obsession with blowing up the supermarket game was selectively used, at best, and abused at worst.
In a nutshell the so-called high prices we pay have less to do with the so-called monopoly, or oligopoly, and more to do with transport between islands, a small population, use of glass, wages, a whole bunch of stuff.
The market shape is a very small part of it and as the advice very clearly points out that blowing it up, as was promised by everyone in the election bar ACT, would not fix it.
Even the Prime Minister just yesterday was still defending it, although I increasingly think he is defending it because
1) He's in too deep,
2) He got in too deep because he got sucked in by Willis, who was clearly obsessed.
As I've argued all along, I don’t care what you do as long as it is evidence-based. And at no point did taking what clearly is a competitive market in a tiny country, and via Government decree reshaping it to your will, make any obvious sense.
There are, and MBIE agree, very clear reasons for why things at the bottom of the world spread over two islands, cost a bit more than they do at Walmart in Kansas City.
National, the party of business, betrayed our trust when they became the party of spin, led by a minister who, for whatever reason, saw scandal around every corner.
When she sought the advice, she got it. And yet it wasn’t the advice she wanted, so she kept the real stuff out of sight while she cherry-picked the bits that suited the cause.
That’s politics, not businesses, and she should have known better.
And for those who are left and still pedalling her myth, they might like to revisit the MBIE advice and amend their outlook.



