Former Republican operative turned Harris campaign strategist Maria Comella joins Chuck Todd to deliver a brutal post-mortem on Democratic failures and to reflect on her unique career path across the political spectrum. From her early days in Republican politics to the inner workings of the Harris campaign, Comella offers candid insights on what it takes to run for office in an era defined by partisanship, shifting voter coalitions, and struggling party identities. She shares stories about Christie’s sharp self-awareness, Giuliani’s early years, and the challenges Harris faced in balancing her legal background with her political ambitions.

Together, Chuck and Maria dive into the pitfalls of Democratic messaging in the Trump era, why Harris couldn’t connect with Republican voters, and how Biden and Harris miscalculated their approach to the left. They also explore the rise of outsider candidates like Sanders and Trump, the failure of movements like “No Labels,” and whether a third party—or even a unifying military figure—could ever gain traction. With upcoming races in New Jersey and New York on the horizon, Comella weighs in on the donor class panic over Mamdani, Cuomo’s uncertain future, and what it will take for either party to break through with an electorate hungry for reform.

Timeline:

(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)

00:00 Maria Comella joins the Chuck Toddcast

02:00 Maria’s origin story

06:30 Difficulty running for state/local offices after being in unpopular congress

07:30 Experience of working for Rudy Guiliani

11:15 Moving from Republican politics to the Harris campaign

12:15 Do Cuomo, Giuliani and Christie have much in common?

13:15 All three are voracious readers

14:15 Chris Christie was the most self-aware of the three

15:30 Christie was mad at Chuck over Meet the Press interview

18:00 Did you have a seat at the table with the Harris campaign?

19:45 Kamala Harris tried to be everything to everyone

21:30 Harris seemed like a more natural fit in law than in politics

22:15 Harris had ideological identity issues 

23:45 Why Harris didn’t appear on Joe Rogan’s podcast

24:45 Harris for Republicans vs. Republicans for Harris

25:30 Biden & Harris didn’t know how to talk to Republican voters

27:00 Liz Cheney wasn’t effective as a surrogate

29:00 Biden & Harris were afraid to go after the left

30:15 Harris campaign said she’d be different, but didn’t show it

31:30 Harris’s appearance on The View symbolized her loss

33:15 Harris had nearly a difficult, but not impossible task

34:30 Harris didn’t need to campaign with never Trump Republicans

36:00 Harris was too late with her closing argument message

37:30 Dukakis’s closing message was just an airing of grievances

38:45 Harris’s closing message didn’t meet voters where they were

40:00 Democratic messaging has been dumb and lazy in Trump era

41:30 Obama was the last candidate the public voted “for”

42:45 Rise of Sanders and Trump show how weak the parties are

43:15 Is there room for a third party?

44:45 Why the “No Labels” party fell flat

47:30 Could a less partisan military leader bring the country together?

49:15 The system was built to force compromise rather than win/lose

51:00 Voters want a reformer/change, Harris didn’t offer that

53:30 The GOP “establishment” let problems fester and ended up with Trump

55:30 Rand Paul & Josh Hawley have stayed true to themselves

57:15 Imitating Trump doesn’t ever work for GOP candidates

59:30 Who on the Democratic side could break through with GOP voters?

1:01:30 The “Stop Mamdani” movement can’t coalesce around one candidate

1:03:00 Donor class panicking they can’t stop Mamdani

1:04:15 Schumer & Jeffries failed to find good NYC mayor candidate

1:06:30 What will Cuomo do? Could he drop out?

1:08:15 Money & ad buys won’t stop Mamdani

1:10:30 New Jersey governors race will be the closest race in November

1:12:00 The Democratic consultant class is out of touch with voters

Former Republican operative turned Harris campaign strategist Maria Comella joins Chuck Todd to deliver a brutal post-mortem on Democratic failures and to reflect on her unique career path across the political spectrum. From her early days in Republican politics to the inner workings of the Harris campaign, Comella offers candid insights on what it takes to run for office in an era defined by partisanship, shifting voter coalitions, and struggling party identities. She shares stories about Christie’s sharp self-awareness, Giuliani’s early years, and the challenges Harris faced in balancing her legal background with her political ambitions.Together, Chuck and Maria dive into the pitfalls of Democratic messaging in the Trump era, why Harris couldn’t connect with Republican voters, and how Biden and Harris miscalculated their approach to the left. They also explore the rise of outsider candidates like Sanders and Trump, the failure of movements like “No Labels,” and whether a third party—or even a unifying military figure—could ever gain traction. With upcoming races in New Jersey and New York on the horizon, Comella weighs in on the donor class panic over Mamdani, Cuomo’s uncertain future, and what it will take for either party to break through with an electorate hungry for reform.Timeline:(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)00:00 Maria Comella joins the Chuck Toddcast02:00 Maria’s origin story06:30 Difficulty running for state/local offices after being in unpopular congress07:30 Experience of working for Rudy Guiliani11:15 Moving from Republican politics to the Harris campaign12:15 Do Cuomo, Giuliani and Christie have much in common?13:15 All three are voracious readers14:15 Chris Christie was the most self-aware of the three15:30 Christie was mad at Chuck over Meet the Press interview18:00 Did you have a seat at the table with the Harris campaign?19:45 Kamala Harris tried to be everything to everyone21:30 Harris seemed like a more natural fit in law than in politics22:15 Harris had ideological identity issues 23:45 Why Harris didn’t appear on Joe Rogan’s podcast24:45 Harris for Republicans vs. Republicans for Harris25:30 Biden & Harris didn’t know how to talk to Republican voters27:00 Liz Cheney wasn’t effective as a surrogate29:00 Biden & Harris were afraid to go after the left30:15 Harris campaign said she’d be different, but didn’t show it31:30 Harris’s appearance on The View symbolized her loss33:15 Harris had nearly a difficult, but not impossible task34:30 Harris didn’t need to campaign with never Trump Republicans36:00 Harris was too late with her closing argument message37:30 Dukakis’s closing message was just an airing of grievances38:45 Harris’s closing message didn’t meet voters where they were40:00 Democratic messaging has been dumb and lazy in Trump era41:30 Obama was the last candidate the public voted “for”42:45 Rise of Sanders and Trump show how weak the parties are43:15 Is there room for a third party?44:45 Why the “No Labels” party fell flat47:30 Could a less partisan military leader bring the country together?49:15 The system was built to force compromise rather than win/lose51:00 Voters want a reformer/change, Harris didn’t offer that53:30 The GOP “establishment” let problems fester and ended up with Trump55:30 Rand Paul & Josh Hawley have stayed true to themselves57:15 Imitating Trump doesn’t ever work for GOP candidates59:30 Who on the Democratic side could break through with GOP voters?1:01:30 The “Stop Mamdani” movement can’t coalesce around one candidate1:03:00 Donor class panicking they can’t stop Mamdani1:04:15 Schumer & Jeffries failed to find good NYC mayor candidate1:06:30 What will Cuomo do? Could he drop out?1:08:15 Money & ad buys won’t stop Mamdani1:10:30 New Jersey governors race will be the closest race in November1:12:00 The Democratic consultant class is out of touch with voters

The Chuck ToddCast is back! If you're looking for smart, no-nonsense political conversation, you've come to the right place. The Chuck ToddCast goes beyond the headlines, featuring conversations with top reporters, insiders, and newsmakers from D.C. to the heartland. No scripts, no spin—just real discussions about what’s shaping our politics and why it matters.

The Chuck ToddCast

Chuck Todd sits down with former GOP operative turned Harris campaign strategist Maria Comella to discuss the messaging mistakes made by the Harris campaign and why the Democratic establishment failed to field a viable challenger to Zohran Mamdani in New York City.

Full Interview w/ Maria Comella - The Mistake That Doomed Kamala Harris Against Donald Trump

https://api.omny.fm/orgs/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/clips/ff82e936-57c8-40e6-8a70-b34600a08a65/transcript