Classic Replay with Nic Collins from The Effect

Published Apr 13, 2025, 7:05 PM

Join @thebuzzknight for this classic replay with Nic Collins from the band The Effect. Nic is the son of the great drummer of the band Genesis Phil Collins. He takes us inside his creative process along with stories of his father.

A Note to our Community

 

Your support means everything to us! As we continue to grow, we’d love to hear what guests you might find interesting and what conversations you’d like us to explore nest.

 

Have a friend who might enjoy our conversations? Please share our podcast with them! Your word of mouth recommendations help us reach new listeners that could benefit from our content.

 

Thank you for being part of our community. We’re excited for what’s ahead!

 

Warmly

 

Buzz Knight

Founder Buzz Knight Media Productions

Taking a Walk.

My biggest teacher now is YouTube.

You know, I spend hours watching all my favorite drummers, and I think that's such a huge asset. Now you can just watch a drum play through and see exactly what's happening, and you have so much access to information that it's become.

A great tool.

But I see it, you know, being able to listen to as many drummers and just kind of you know, add different colors to.

Your to your palette and to your to your arsenal of sounds.

Welcome. This is the Taking a Walk Podcast with Buzznight, the podcast that delves into the stories of musicians and their passion for their music. Today, Buzz is joined by drummer Nick Collins. Nick is Phil collins Son and he's carving out his own musical journey. Here's Buzz Night and Nick Collins on Taking a Walk.

Nick Collins, it's so great to have you on this virtual edition of the Taking a Walk Podcast.

Of course, thank you so much for having me.

Man, Congratulations on all of your work. We're going to talk about the effect and how excited you are about that, but I do want to get into a little, uh talk about your father and your work with him as well. First of all, how is your dad these days?

Yeah, yeah, he's doing good.

He's uh retired, uh, you know, until until maybe he gets the itch again to do it. But at the moment he's he's enjoying the retired life.

Well, how does it make you feel when fans and fellow musicians are wowed by your playing? Oh?

It's great.

I mean, you know, obviously, it's a it's a huge compliment in a in an honor that you.

Know, get to do things people like it, that's great.

Obviously If people don't like it, that's fine too, you know what I mean. I think it's it's awesome to be to be doing this the thing that that I love, you know, and uh, I've been very lucky to have been able to do it in different context, different artists and bands, and so yeah, it's a very huge compliment.

Well, besides your dad, talk about the other drummers that you've studied very closely.

Oh yeah, I mean, dude, the laundry list goes on and on, you know, it's always always growing. But I think my main drum heroes are Danny Carey, John Bonham, Abe Cunningham, who from Deftones, Stuart Copeland. I mean there's so much John Theodore from Mars Vilta and Queens of the Stone Age. It's just so many all the time. Coming Taylor Hawkins, he was a huge one.

You know.

It's like different eras of like what in different parts of my life and which drummers really grabbed me at different times, you know, like growing up it was obviously apart from my dad, the first three were bottom and then Taylor Hawkins and Chad Smith from the Chili Peppers. And Taylor and Chad I felt this huge you know, I really idolized them just because it felt like I these were like my generation of guys, you know, like they had you know when I when I say Bonham and Stuart Copeland that you know they'd been around for such a long time.

That you know, those are their favorite drummers.

And it felt like with Chad and Taylor, it was like, oh, this is like the new the new guys that those are like my guys, and it was like, you know, not like my dad's guys and stuff like that. So I felt like a real connection to them and it made me fall in love with the idea of being in a band and you know, playing live and and then since you know, different eras where I get started getting into prog music. And that's when Danny Carey, Gavin Harrison, I started really John Theodore looking up to them, but the same way that I'll also look up to like the jazz fusion world, and you know, get into guys like Billy Cobbham or even more newer guys like Larnel Lewis from Starky Puppy.

You know, they all have.

Such an equal influence on me because to me, that's the best teacher is just being able to listen to as much music and as many drummers as possible.

You know, we had Kenny Aronoff on the podcast previously, and Kenny talked about a lot of his disciplines to sort of stay in tune and primed for every performance, you know, his whole practice session and regiment. How do you go about that sort of process?

Yeah, I think.

I mean when I'm on tour, it's a different thing to when I'm like at home, and it's more studio stuff.

You know, on tour I do.

I am very disciplined in like a warm up routine, just because when you're doing it, you know, playing two and a half hours every night. You want to make sure that you're not hurting yourself. So I'll go through like a thirty to forty five minute warm up routine with like a metronome and go through a bunch of different rudiments at different speeds and get my body warmed up and just get the blood flowing to the wrists.

And because I used to have some.

Risk problems, I started using heavier sticks and that kind of took a lot of it away. But I still want to make sure that I'm you know, able to keep it up for as long as possible. But I do also realize I need to do a better job of that when I'm at home or when I'm like, you know, just this week, we were rehearsing with the Effect, and you know, I I'll like just jump into rehearsals and then now I'm like, oh, my arm kind of hurts, you know, and I should just like, just because it's rehearsals does not mean you should not warm up, you know, just because it's not a show. So that's something I've got to get better at. But definitely taking care of myself, you know, and staying active going to the gym and you know, always making sure that my body is in shape because drumming is very physical and I don't want to be injuring myself.

And so far everything's been good. I try to make that a priority.

I love what I saw online the Grooves of Genesis, that whole presentation there with Duke's intro and cinema show and behind the lines, so many great songs. Watcher of the Skies, did you have fun doing that particular session?

Yeah, that was great. I mean, you know, the shout out to the guys at Drummio.

They were you know, they're incredible guys in the platform that they've built. I mean, I've been a fan of theirs for since I was like twelve, you know, looking up look watching those videos on YouTube. So to find be in the space and doing stuff with them was really awesome. That that was probably like two years ago that we filmed it, which is a trip because like you know, not all the videos have come out yet, so we had like another video come out in like January, and like you know, I remember my girlfriend being like, you look really young, and I'm like, yeah, that was two years ago.

Like you know, I've aged, but no, that was a lot of fun.

It was a lot of rehearsal, and because basically we shot a course about my dad's playing, and you know, that's kind of that was the live stream that we did and that's out on YouTube, and we actually did a more in depth course about each of those songs kind of by themselves, plus some additional ones.

And it was great fun, you know.

I mean, I think to me, it was it felt like, this is the thing I want to do for my dad. And you know, also, I think the younger generation maybe don't know my dad as a drummer and know him more as the Indi era guy or the Tarzan guy, and I feel like I wanted to showcase like, no, you know, my dad was a was a badass drummer, you know. And that was after doing the Genesis thing. We shot like a huge core and I learned forty songs, like some of the songs we were playing in the show, but then a bunch of other of like the really heavy prog tunes that which we didn't do it in rehearsal. So it was a lot of work and a lot of pressure, but it was, you know, a great time. I had a lot of fun doing that session and so many great drum parts. And it is a weird thing when you're trying to explain and teach parts that you didn't write or that you weren't involved in, you know, because I'm like, this is like some of these songs were thirty years before I was even born, you know what I mean, So like it can be a bit interesting, But I thought it was you know, it was good fun and you know, I'm excited for that course to finally come out. When it does, you know, there's just a you know, some copyright things that need to be cleared up.

First, I thought it was fantastic, And I have to tell you, Nick, you make it look really easy, and I know it's not.

Ah, thank you so much.

No, I mean, you know, like it's I've been around those parts for a while, but it's definitely takes a long time of getting it down like I wouldn't you know, I'm not going to be like, oh yeah, I just went in there and just played them, you know, Like that was maybe two months worth of repetition, multiple days a week to try and be comfortable with the songs because some of those songs are just like really complex and a lot of improv, and when you're trying to learn somebody's improv, it's very you know, I can get very tricky.

I was privileged to see your dad play with Genesis a few times, also to see him play with a brand X, and I wanted to share one of those experiences that I'll never forget. It was the Trick of the Tail tour, and it was the dual drumming of your dad and the great Bill Bruford. I was wondering if you ever got to see any sort of video form anything from that tour.

I've seen videos. I don't know if it's from that tour.

I've seen some videos of him and my dad and Bill doing cinema show that may have been from the seconds out or before for that, like maybe that the tour after Trick of the Tale. I'm not sure when that video was, but I've seen some of it. I mean, you know, Bill is another guy who's become such a big influence, and he's like the prog drummer of the seventies. You know, it was in every great prog band. Bill Bruford was in it at some point, you know, and he's what a great drummer, and that was you know that the double drums became a theme in my life, from watching those videos to watching him and Chester do it to actually watching it live between them.

So yeah, I mean, amazing stuff.

It was the Ohio Theater in Columbus, Ohio where I saw it and our mind was completely blown from that show and it changed us really.

Oh wow, that's amazing.

Yeah.

And of course were you able to sort of go back and study some of the Brand X work from your dad?

Yeah, we didn't do as much for the course.

You know, it's funny like I've kind of gotten more into the Brand Deck stuff more recently, you know, after the Genesis thing and getting into the Prague side of their sound and getting into Brand X and the more fusion stuff. It started really impacting me also as a drummer, and like going from playing the really heavy, loud beats to like the really quiet, intricate, more fusiony stuff. But you know, that's some great material with Brand X, and we did I think we broke down maybe one or two for the Drummo thing. But now it's you know, it's one of those things that I get into more now, Like it's just you know, the evolution of what you listen to and what you decide to get into. And yeah, you know, I mean, it's it's funny to see that different sides of like my dad's playing, which I haven't, you know, been familiar with until I'm like twenty one or twenty you know what I mean. It's strange to be like, oh, you did this too. You're not just this guy, you also happen to do something that's completely totally different.

And on the dual drumming theme, what's your personal take on the dual drumming that was so part of the Allman Brothers and obviously The Grateful Dead as well.

Yeah, I thought it was great.

I mean, you know, I think it's like my opinion is always dependent on like the context, you know. I think as like as a drummer, you kind of want to go into be like I don't need another drummer.

I could do everything, you know what I mean, Like there's like that ego side of things.

But I think when Genesis were doing it, it was such an amazing asset to have to the to the show, not only just in like the progue bits and the instrumental parts where both my dad and whether it was Bill or Chester when they would play it became it just added this layer to the music both visually and you know, sonically. But I also think, you know, to have those drum featured moments where you know, not every band can just get two guys to do to do it at that level, you know what I mean. I think you can get some guys where I don't know, a lead singer a band will go and play some you know, toms or something, but it doesn't you know, to have two guys who were just like absolute monsters at drums, doing and playing off of each other and creating compositions together. I thought it was you know, it became something that I was just so familiar with from watching all the live DVD and just being there and watching the shows, you know, like later on. And it was a weird thing when I joined Genesis, and it was just me because we had something similar in my dad's band where me and the percussionists would do a drum bit, like a drum part kind of not a solo, like a drum duo kind of thing, and we'd play off of each other. But with Genesis, you know, we didn't do that because my dad can't play drums anymore. But you know, it was tricky playing navigating some of the instrumental songs which used to have double drum featured moments, you know, especially Cinema show had like a call and response on the snares and it was just me and so I think, you know, Daniel Pierce, who was one of the backing singers, did do a little bit of Timbali's to like do have that effect, like the call and response. But it was also for me trying to find like, okay, how can I play the groove but also still include some of that double drum stuff because it's hard when you're just one person. When you know, back then it would be like Chester would keep the groove going and my dad would go and you know, play off the keyboards or something. So well, it was a bit tricky to find the right balance, but you know, by the end it was you know, I think we got it down by the end, hopefully.

I pretty sure you did. So the great movie Whiplash, I guarantee you probably saw it. The question is did it scar you for life?

That's you know what's funny is the Whiplash. When I did the drummo thing.

One of the first time listening videos was the song Whiplash, which I've seen the movie Whiplash, but for some reason didn't connect the song. I've just like, I was like, something sounds familiar about it. But then you know, Brandon starts riffing off Whiplash quotes and you know it's threatening to throw a symbol at me, and that's when I was like, oh, that's from Whiplash, you know what I mean. But I really liked the movie when it came out. I was young enough where like it was just like it made me really interested in jazz. But you know it is now I look at it and I can see why it would upset some people just because it's very unhealthy. But I think that was the point, like the point and the great you know.

JK.

Simmons is amazing in that movie, and.

Like that role, like where you really hate the teacher and you hate the band leader. I think it was supposed to be kind of influenced by Buddy Rich.

Obviously I'm not I'm not sure.

I never met Buddy Rich, but that was what I've heard that that was the influence of of like the harsh, the harshness, and I think, you know, maybe it was a bit extra, but it's a movie, you know.

What I mean.

Like it's also you know, when when Miles Teller puts his hand in the you know, jug of water and he's all bleeding, I'm like, that doesn't happen either, you know what I mean. It's it's it's the dramatization of the of of Hollywood.

But I thought it was a good movie.

You know, I understood the you know, the message, and obviously I think it's not supposed to be taken literally. You know, if a teacher was really like that, then there'd be a problem because I don't think that's really healthy. But I think for a movie and to almost put drums in the limelight, especially jazz drumming, which became this huge, you know thing around the world when that movie came out, I think it was great to be able to feature the drums that way.

We'll be right back with more of the Taken a Walk Podcast. Welcome back to the Taking a Walk Podcast.

Who are the teachers? Aside from your father? Obviously that made an impact on you and really shaped you to this moment today.

Yeah.

I mean, I've only really had one drum teacher. His name is John Pierre Espiritu Santo, and I started taking lessons with him when I first moved to Miami, Florida, and I was like eleven or twelve, and you know, originally I kind of wanted to be a soccer player. That's really that was what I wanted to do. And then I moved to Miami and kind of realized I'm.

Not that good at soccer, and I'm like, oh, I guess I'm okay at this other thing. Let me take this more seriously.

But my technique, you know, I played drums and I had a good sense of groove and rhythm, but my technique was just not there.

And so he really was able to.

Help me, hone in on that technique, and he was, you know, taught me about all the different rudiments but also different Latin grooves, which at the time, I you know, didn't understand why I was playing boson nova or samba.

I was like, this is this you? I don't want to play Foo Fighters music? Like what do you? Why are we doing this?

But then I've understood as I got older, and then I started getting into progressive music and polyrhythms. I was like, no, it was about the lim in dependence, you know. So I'm very grateful to for him teaching me that.

But you know, we don't we don't.

I don't take lessons necessarily anymore. Honestly, My biggest teacher now is YouTube.

You know.

I spend hours watching all my favorite drummers, and I think that's such a huge asset that I don't think, you know, young people nowadays realize how lucky we are to have the access to YouTube, because I you know, I talk about it with different guys and they're like, yeah, well, back when I was grown up, it's like you had to like rewind the DVR and like try and like play it so you could see what was happening, or just like you just had to listen, whereas now you can just watch a drum play through and see exactly what's happening, and you have so much access to information that.

It's become a great tool.

But I see it, you know, being able to listen and to as many drummers and just kind of you know, add different colors to your to your palette and to your to your arsenal of sounds. I think that's such a you know big asset nowadays.

And the interesting thing about YouTube as a teacher is it doesn't really do any good to get angry at YouTube for like teacher.

Yeah, you can get angry at yourself, but you know, or you see like you know, I will say sometimes on YouTube it's like, you know, you'll see some seven year old from you know, Japan or something and he's just like way better than you, and you're just like it makes you like, You're like, what the hell is you know, it's like but that's the only thing I think, you know, you can maybe get you lose sight of what the point is and be and because you see so many people that are just so great and it can like damage your confidence. But I think it's better to just look at it and an approach of like a learning side of things. And you see these people and it's you know, what can you take from these different drummers to add to your own uh, to your own drum?

So let's talk about the Effect. How did the Effect come together? Talk about all the key players there in the band that make up the Effect, and how excited you are about the project.

Yeah, the so the Effect came about Trev Lucather who's the guitar player and producer of the band.

His dad is Steve Lucather from Toto.

You know, we actually Leland Skalar and Amy Keys, who were both in my dad's solo band and Toto at different points. You know, they'd been telling Trev and I that, like, you know, you guys need to get together. You know, you guys would really get along, and you know, you need to do something together. And you know, I think we followed each other on Instagram and just like connected on social media, you know, supported each other here and there. But it wasn't until January of twenty twenty three, where he was in Miami for some reason, you know, for our TV show that kind of went south. It was like he was going to be hosting this thing and producer and director kind of went at it and so the show was canceled.

And he was like, well, I'm stuck in Miami. Who do I know?

And so he invited me out to dinner and it was him and his wife, Madison, and then me and my girlfriend Isabelle, and we got together on like a double date and that was the first time we met, and we totally hit it off. You know, we connected and found that we related a lot on you know, in different ways. Almost felt like we'd live parallel lives and just so many things that were in both of our lives that we really were able to kind of bond on. And but at the time, you know, he did he was he still does a lot of production work, and I think that was the extent of what we thought was going to happen if we work together. Was just like, oh, I'll play on a session or you know, something like that. But then fast forward a couple months. I was on the road with Mike and the Mechanics and Trev sent me a text and he was like, hey, dude, I'm thinking of putting a group together, just an experiment.

And this is who's in the band? Are you down? And I'm like, well maybe, I was like what do you have in mind?

And then he sent me the guitar riff to Unwanted Like that was literally the first tune we ever did together, and I was like, oh, yeah, I'm down, Like, let's do it. I didn't get to record my parts until I got back from the road, and then we did that first song, and then it turned let's do another, and then two three, songs turned into well, no, let's let's actually be a band, you know, let's actually do it. But the funny thing is we by the we had written, recorded, and mixed three songs before all four of us were ever in the same room together, which is because you know, we've done like I live in Miami, Trev lives in la and then Steve Majoriya who plays keyboards and does background vocals, he lives in Palo Alto, like so NorCal and then Emmett Stang who's the singer, he lives in Vegas.

So it was all being done very remotely.

But then we got together and we all kind of really hit it off, and you know, we all really got along. And basically that was in June. June was when we started the record and and basically we finish the record by December. It was very We didn't go like, let's write the whole record and then record it. It was we were just do We were recording it and mixing it as it was being written, and you know, everybody brings such an interesting take to the whole you know band. You know, we never had a conversation what kind of band do we want to be?

What genre?

Like you know, what bands are we going to try and emulate like it was? Literally this is what the four of us sound like when we are writing music together.

And you know, the first song I recorded last. But typically what we've done is Trev.

Trev will come up with a guitar part and a guitar idea, and we'll essentially map out a whole song's worth of like Okay, here's the verse, precorers, chorus, whatever, and he'll just send it to me blank with just the guitars, and then I will go and other than Unwanted where I was the last one, every other song has been this way, where I'll go and basically write a drum part and you know, go into the rehearsal room, and then I'll FaceTime Trev and we'll basely bounced notes off of one another of what he likes, what I like, what I don't like, and you know, and then from there I basically record the drums the day that they're written, which is not what I'm not very used to because usually with you know, with other you know, with my other band, better strangers, like, I'm very.

Meticulous about how much work.

I can put it, you know, and overthinking my drum parts, and trev wanted me to just be very instinctual, like, no, I want to capture whatever magic you were able to get. So then once I've done that, you know, Trevill laid down his real guitars, and Steve Matroy will lay down his keyboard parts, which you know he always The textual stuff that Steve is able to create is is really amazing on a both keyboard wise and also background vocals. And then Emmett gets together with Trev and they write the lyrics and top playing together, and you know, Emmett's voice is the range that that guy has, not just literally on a musical range, but I mean the fact that he goes from being like this really heavy rock singer to also being able to dial it back and do the total pop thing. You know, it's a really you know, the whole band is just a class musicians and it's lots of fun to be able to create and work with those guys.

Everybody brings just so much to the table.

And what is the expectation on the band in terms of touring and just getting out for people to see it.

Yeah, So we finished the album at the end of last year, so we just put out another single a couple of weeks ago, and.

Actually I was just in La last week.

We just recorded and did a video for something very exciting that we'll be announced soon, so we're very pumped about that. But no, we've got some American dates that it will be announced eventually for in May, and then we've got a European tour happening this summer where we've got our own headline shows, but we're also playing the Isle of Wight Festival and also the KUP Live Festival in France, and then we're opening for Toto in Germany, which you know, huge shout out and thank you to you know, Luke and everybody in the total crew for being able to for wanting us out there and for for having us.

It's going to be a great time.

So yeah, basically, you know, we're gonna be playing some shows and getting on the road this year and hopefully the album.

You know, we don't have a set release date.

We've released three singles so far and you know, everything's finished. It's just basically about finding the right time and place to put it out. Whether you know, nowadays so much music gets put out every day on streaming services, that like, if you do it wrong, you just end up being another drop in the ocean. And I think for us, like we believe in the record and everybody's put in spark into the album that we feel like it deserves the you know, to get the right attention.

And will Better Strangers still still exist as well?

Yeah, of course, you know, I'm I'm doing both, and you know, it's funny. I grew up in from a dad who you know, had a solo, very successful solo career and a very successful Genesis career as well, So the idea of doing both is not something that scares me, you know, and I really like actually doing both because they are such different bands and like almost every way, you know, the effect is more of a pop rock that's what I consider it, pop rock, but we do get pretty heavy sometimes, whereas Better Strangers is more of a progressive, you know, progressive band, you know, with that goes a bit heavier, maybe like the line between progressive hard rock and progressive metal at this point. But it's great, you know, I get different creative outlets in different ways, and you know, it's it's been lots of fun to be able to do both.

So when you're playing live. How much of playing live as a drummer is about getting in a particular zone that you're just kind of off at a different place and it's coming so naturally.

Yeah, I mean, I think again it depends on the band and what the role is, because you know, with the effect we play, I played a click and so that is different because you really have you got to be really locked in with what you're playing along too, because if you're often it becomes a whole train wreck. But it's a different kind of thing because you're not really worried about whether it's with Genesis or my dad or better strangers. Where I don't play to click, those become more like I have to get in the zone where I'm I got to make sure I don't let the adrenaline take over and I'm playing things too fast too slow.

I think with the.

Effect, it's like making sure obviously you know the songs and really locking in and you know it comes. It's it's a mix of muscle memory but also really being familiar and becoming almost one with the material. That's always something I've said to anybody when I've done you know, the few clinics that I've done. My biggest advice is when you get hired to or ask to play a gig, you know, familiarize yourself with the songs in a way where they become second nature and you're listening. You're not just listening to them in the rehearsal room, but you're listening to them on the way to the grocery store or on the way to.

The gym or whatever it is.

I think that's the biggest thing, is being aware that, like you know, this is what's best for the song, this is what the song needs, and really kind of getting into that mindset.

In closing, is there a dream band that you I realize the effect is a dream right now because there's a great amount of a serendeputy to it. But is there some dream players that you think about and go, my god, if I could ever do a session with this group of people, this would be incredible.

That's a great question.

I think it really it really depends, And I mean there's obviously the guys, like you know, I would love to play a song with Chino from the Deftones, Gina Moreno singing, or Maynard James Gena from Tool Singing. I love both of those guys as you know, they're they're singing so much in their vocal parts and their sound that I'd love to do a song with them on it. Then as far as musicians, I mean, there's so many. I think off the top of my head now I'm thinking John for Shante or Flee from the Chili Peppers. I mean, those guys are such a big deal for me growing up that to be able to be on a track with them would be a dream.

I'll have to get back to you on that one, you know what I mean.

Like, there's so many different you know, there's different producers and you know, guys that I look up to that that I of course I want to work with. But also I I you know, I that in that same way, it motivates me to try and make my own thing and with my own uh you know, bandmates and and be able to like create something that I believe in and that's unique that way as well.

Well. Definitely get back to me, because I'm not going to be surprised that anything you pull off.

Nick. Okay, amazing, Thank you so much.

Yeah, congratulations on everything. Congrats on the new project The Effect and Better Strangers and all your work around Genesis and your dad and Mike and the mechanics. Please tell your dad and give them our love. And it's so great to have you on Taking a Walk.

Nick, I appreci it. Buzz, thanks so much for having me.

Thanks for listening to this episode of the Taking a Walk podcast. Share this and other episodes with your friends and follow us so you never miss an episode. Taking a Walk is available on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, and wherever you get your podcasts.