In a quiet Ohio town, unsettling letters began arriving in mailboxes, each filled with accusations, secrets, and threats. Even after a man was convicted, the letters didn’t stop. In this episode, we drift back to Circleville in the late 1970s to explore one of America’s most chilling unsolved mysteries: the Circleville Letters.
As you drift off to sleep, ask yourself, who was watching? Who kept writing? And why has the truth remained hidden for decades?

The Call That Went Silent
13:33

Whatever He Saw, It Made Him Run
11:42

The Footprints That Never Left
12:06