Joey Chestnut on Chasing Title 18, His Toughest Loss, & the Perfect Fourth of July Hot Dog | BONUS EPISODE

Seventeen-time Nathan's Famous Hot Dog Eating Contest champion Joey Chestnut joins Covino and Rich, in for Dan Patrick, the day before he chases his 18th title. Joey opens up about the loss to Matt Stonie that reset his career, the protester he wrestled off the stage mid-contest, why he never uses …

World Cup Is Healing the World & Mets Are Beyond Saving | Ep #145

The world is coming together and the New York Mets are coming apart. On Overpromised Episode 145, Covino and Rich make the case that the World Cup is healing the world, from Norway fans rowing in the Citi Field outfield and Scottish fans draining Fenway to Mexico taking over Los Angeles and Japanes…

Gym Class Heroes & Knicks Love A Parade | Ep #144

Dodgeball turns 22, so Covino and Rich make the case that gym class was the best part of the school day. They run through the parachute, the rope climb, the Presidential Fitness Test, the funky gym clothes everyone forgot in their locker, and the gym sports that turned into all-out wars. Then it is…

MJ's $53K Sticker & Ranch Goes Global | Ep #143

A Michael Jordan prism sticker sold for over $53,000, and odds are you had one stuck in a binder as a kid. Covino and Rich unlock the forgotten childhood sports memories nobody talks about: the quarter vending machine stickers, supermarket helmet collectibles, Helmet Day giveaways, the Beckett book…

He-Man Hotness & Josh Hart's Headband Hall of Fame | Ep #142

He-Man and Masters of the Universe finally hit theaters this weekend, so Covino and Rich do the only responsible thing and rank the hottest cartoon characters of all time, from Evil-Lyn and Teela to Lola from Shark Tale, April O'Neil, Cocomelon's surprisingly hot Mrs. Apple Berry, and the undispute…

The Knicks Are Back in the Finals! Welcome Back to 1999 | Ep #141

The Knicks are back in the NBA Finals for the first time since 1999, so Covino & Rich rewind to the last time the Garden was this loud. On Overpromised Ep 141, C&R relive exactly where they were in 1999: the radio come-up, Y2K, the Pokémon explosion, AOL Instant Messenger, dial-up internet, Nokia S…

A-Rod's WILD Dating Resume + MLB's Tarps Off Movement | Ep #140

A-Rod just got dumped again, so Covino & Rich run through his legendary dating resume (J.Lo! Madonna! Cameron Diaz! Kate Hudson!) and ask: could you ever date someone who dated a superstar athlete? Plus, Covino drops the wildest stat of the day - Madonna might be the only woman who's been with a co…

Cal Raleigh's INSANE Shower Trick & Athletes That Might Be Aliens | Ep #139

Cal Raleigh went from MVP runner-up to an 0-for-38 nightmare, then Logan Gilbert told him to take a shower in full uniform. The Big Dumper actually did it, snapped the slump with two singles against Houston, and now Covino & Rich are deep in the greatest sports superstitions of all time: Wade Boggs…

Worst Sports Insults Ever, Is Boxing Really Your Favorite Sport? + Mets Are ASS | Ep #138

Covino & Rich break down the worst insults in sports, starting with Shilo Sanders telling Cleveland reporter Mary Kay Cabot to "go make me a sandwich" and spiraling into hairline jokes, short-king disrespect, and Dalton Rushing getting caught lip-reading at Miguel Amaya. Then Max Kellerman's viral …

Bret Michaels on Pittsburgh's NFL Draft + Our Top 5 Draft Moments | Ep #137

Poison front man Bret Michaels joins us the week of the 2026 NFL Draft, in his hometown of Pittsburgh, where he's headlining Friday night of Day 2. Before he hits the stage, he's sitting with Covino & Rich! We get into his lifelong obsession with sports and how it collides with the music world, th…