The Legal Rights of Foreign Shop Owners Versus Community Activism (MELUSI XULU - ATTORNEY - AT DONDA ATTONEYS)

 

The growing tensions between foreign-owned businesses and anti-immigration activists in South Africa are once again raising difficult questions about the rule of law, constitutional rights and the
limits of community action. Several foreign shop owners have approached the courts in an
attempt to obtain legal protection against Phakel Umthakathi Ndabandaba and seven other activists. The shop owners are seeking an interdict amid allegations of intimidation and actions
targeting their businesses. The case brings into focus a fundamental question: Can individuals
or community groups take it upon themselves to investigate immigration violations, shut down businesses or prevent foreign nationals from operating, even where they believe the law is being
broken? South Africa has laws governing immigration, business compliance and the operation of commercial premises. But those laws also establish processes and identify which authorities have the power to enforce them. Being concerned about undocumented immigration or alleged illegal business operations does not automatically give private citizens the authority to enforce the law themselves.
Tonight, we speak to a legal expert about the case, the grounds for the court application, the rights of the affected shop owners and where the law draws the line between legitimate protest and
unlawful conduct.