Lauren found out her friend is planning to propose to his longtime girlfriend soon—and over the weekend, she hung out with the couple and almost spilled the secret! She spent the rest of the night carefully choosing her words to avoid ruining the surprise.

Meanwhile, Kincaid shares the time he knew someone was about to get fired and how awkward it was trying not to let it slip. This sparked a big question: Would you rather not know these kinds of secrets?

Listeners call in to share the hardest secrets they’ve had to keep