How Profanity in America Went From Saloons and Sailing Ships to Presidential Campaigns
In 1665, a Massachusetts man named John Porter Jr. stood on a gallows ladder with a rope around his neck for calling his mother a "ram bugger" and his father something even worse. Only his mother's plea to the court saved him from hanging. The Puritan magistrates who sentenced him believed that cursing your parents violated the Fifth Commandment and warranted death. Three and a half centuries later, profanity is mainstream and used by presidential candidates of both parties. Donald Trump and Kamala Harris trotted out the f-word when they wanted to appear authentic or unfiltered. Nobody has suggested they should be arrested for it. Between those two moments, something fundamental changed about what Americans are willing to say out loud and what they think it means when they say it.
Today's guest is Steven H. Jaffe, author of Four-Letter Nation: A History of Dirty Words in America. We discuss how colonial court records reveal that profanity was a crime in Puritan America but was widely used in certain contexts, like saloons or sailboats, why Mark Twain was the first writer to weaponize profanity as a declaration of national identity, how Ernest Hemingway fought his publisher to print the f-word in A Farewell to Arms and lost, how twelve million World War II soldiers brought their language home and couldn't unlearn it. We see that American profanity has traveled a four-hundred-year arc from the language of the gutter to the language of our highest politicians and whether language has changed or we have changed.



