The Salvation Army says sanctions on beneficiaries which force people to find volunteer work for a few hours a week isn't the best use of resources.
New 'non-financial' sanctions are set to come into force for beneficiaries who don't meet their obligations - including having part of their weekly benefit put on a payment card or finding volunteer work for at least 5 hours a week.
But Salvation Army principal social policy analyst Paul Barber doesn't believe that's the right way to go for people who are struggling to find work.
"There are already a lot of sanctions available... we're talking about a relatively small group of people within the total number of people who are receiving welfare."
LISTEN ABOVE

Gavin Grey: UK correspondent on Labour's poor showing at the local elections
03:41

Geoff Bertram: energy economist on the Greens calling for the Government to bring down power prices
05:43

Shane Solly: Harbour Asset Management expert on the market reactions to the 'no deal' announcement on the Middle East conflict
03:07