The "last thing" Rabbi Rachel Timoner says she wanted to do was block the street in front of New York's Israeli consulate as part of a protest calling on Israel to increase the flow of humanitarian aid in Gaza – let alone get arrested for doing so.

The Brooklyn rabbi said on the Haaretz Podcast that when she was asked to take part in the demonstration, she found it impossible to say no.

"As a leader of the Jewish community here, as a rabbi, I feel that when Israel is acting in a way that they are claiming is representing Judaism, it's part of my job to show my understanding of what Judaism stands for. We feed the hungry, and we care for the sick, and we free the captives, and we care for the human dignity of every life, of every human life."

Timoner, the senior rabbi at Congregation Beth Elohim in Park Slope, spoke on the podcast about the unease among New York Jews since October 7, and the crisis ignited by Zohran Mamdani's victory in the city's Democratic primary.

Mamdani, who will once again face voters in the November general election, has been embroiled in controversy over his support for the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement and his shifting stance on others on the left calling to “globalize the intifada.” 

While the city of New York "does not have a foreign policy," Timoner said, it is a "big deal symbolically and in terms of identity to think about the mayor being an anti-Zionist." Timoner says Mamdani must address the question of "how will Zionist New Yorkers know that they are welcome in this city, safe in this city, and know that they are part of his vision for this city."

The fact that despite his views, Mamdani received the most primary votes of any candidate, she added, points to the fact "a lot of Jews are feeling profoundly alienated from the behavior and the speech of this Israeli government, feel that it does not represent our values at all, and that it is a shameful degradation of Judaism. I don't know that you could explain the Jewish support for Mamdani without that factor."

Read more:

'It Is Impossible to Watch and Stay Silent' | Dozens Arrested as U.S. Jews Ramp Up Protests Against Gaza Starvation

Zohran Mamdani Officially Wins Democratic Primary for New York City Mayor

Mamdani Distances Himself From 'Globalize the Intifada' Slogan in Closed-door Meeting With Business Leaders

The "last thing" Rabbi Rachel Timoner says she wanted to do was block the street in front of New York's Israeli consulate as part of a protest calling on Israel to increase the flow of humanitarian aid in Gaza &ndash; let alone get arrested for doing so.
The Brooklyn rabbi said on the Haaretz Podcast that when she was asked to take part in the demonstration, she found it impossible to say no.
"As a leader of the Jewish community here, as a rabbi, I feel that when Israel is acting in a way that they are claiming is representing Judaism, it's part of my job to show my understanding of what Judaism stands for. We feed the hungry, and we care for the sick, and we free the captives, and we care for the human dignity of every life, of every human life."
Timoner, the senior rabbi at <a href="https://www.haaretz.com/life/2018-04-17/ty-article/the-notorious-b-i-g-once-worked-at-a-brooklyn-synagogue/0000017f-e92c-d62c-a1ff-fd7f3fef0000">Congregation Beth Elohim</a> in Park Slope, spoke on the podcast about the unease among New York Jews since October 7, and the crisis ignited by <a href="https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/2025-06-12/ty-article-magazine/.premium/israel-and-antisemitism-take-center-stage-in-new-yorks-mayoral-race/00000197-62f6-d34b-ad97-f2ff37840000">Zohran Mamdani's victory</a> in the city's Democratic primary.
Mamdani, who will once again face voters in the November general election, has been embroiled in controversy over his support for the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement and <a href="https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/2025-07-16/ty-article/.premium/mamdani-distances-himself-from-intifada-slogan-in-closed-meeting-with-business-leaders/00000198-148e-da26-abba-d5cf2a0a0000">his shifting stance</a> on others on the left calling to &ldquo;globalize the intifada.&rdquo;&nbsp;
While the city of New York "does not have a foreign policy," Timoner said, it is a "big deal symbolically and in terms of identity to think about the mayor being an anti-Zionist." Timoner says Mamdani must address the question of "how will Zionist New Yorkers know that they are welcome in this city, safe in this city, and know that they are part of his vision for this city."
The fact that despite his views, Mamdani received the most primary votes of any candidate, she added, points to the fact "a lot of Jews are feeling profoundly alienated from the behavior and the speech of this Israeli government, feel that it does not represent our values at all, and that it is a shameful degradation of Judaism. I don't know that you could explain the Jewish support for Mamdani without that factor."
Read more:
<a href="https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/2025-08-02/ty-article/.premium/dozens-arrested-as-u-s-jews-ramp-up-protests-against-gaza-starvation/00000198-6796-de6e-a198-efff1ca30000">'It Is Impossible to Watch and Stay Silent'&nbsp;|&nbsp;Dozens Arrested as U.S. Jews Ramp Up Protests Against Gaza Starvation</a>
<a href="https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/2025-07-01/ty-article/.premium/zohran-mamdani-officially-wins-democratic-primary-for-new-york-city-mayor/00000197-c6f2-d0a5-a3ff-eeffd66f0000">Zohran Mamdani Officially Wins Democratic Primary for New York City Mayor</a>
<a href="https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/2025-07-16/ty-article/.premium/mamdani-distances-himself-from-intifada-slogan-in-closed-meeting-with-business-leaders/00000198-148e-da26-abba-d5cf2a0a0000">Mamdani Distances Himself From 'Globalize the Intifada' Slogan in Closed-door Meeting With Business Leaders</a>

From Haaretz – Israel's oldest daily newspaper – a weekly podcast in English on Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World, hosted by Allison Kaplan Sommer.

From Haaretz – Israel's oldest daily newspaper – a weekly podcast in English on Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World, hosted by Allison Kaplan Sommer.

Your audio guide to Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World.

Haaretz Podcast

From Haaretz – Israel's oldest daily newspaper – the Haaretz weekly podcast in English on Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World, hosted by Allison Kaplan Sommer. 

From Haaretz – Israel's oldest daily newspaper – the Haaretz weekly podcast in English on Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World, hosted by Allison Kaplan Sommer.

Advertisement