Filling in for Lance this week are 'One Tree Hill' alums Tyler Hilton and Robert Buckley... and it's a magical episode!

In this wand-erful chat, Robert reveals he grew up with a 'magic room' in his house full of thousands of dollars worth of illusions and props! His stories of being a magician during his most awkward years and performing at birthday parties leave Tyler totally spellbound!

Plus, they both share how they got into acting, including Tyler's first movie role that almost didn't happen until a random run-in with Joaquin Phoenix changed his course! And, of course, they talk about their fondest memories of being on 'One Tree Hill!'