Off to the Races”: Barnhart and Dodd Pick Apart the First CFP Rankings Ahead of a Historic Saturday

 

 Coach uses a horse-racing theme to open an hour-long roundtable with Tony Barnhart and Dennis Dodd, timed to the release of the first College Football Playoff rankings. Barnhart, who has covered the sport for 50 years, says he has never seen a Saturday like this one: 10 of the top 14 teams face another top-14 opponent, including No. 1 Miami vs. No. 11 Notre Dame, Georgia at Ole Miss, Utah vs. BYU, Alabama at LSU, and Kentucky at Tennessee. Dodd says the committee “did a disservice” to its job. He points to Indiana at No. 4, a struggling Oregon getting ranked, New Mexico left out, Tennessee sitting at 13 after beating Alabama badly, and Notre Dame at 11, a ranking he says no one who has watched them play would agree with. Both analysts read the rankings as a reward for the SEC’s schedule strength. They also see a message to two teams: Notre Dame gets one more chance, and Alabama is finished if it loses today. In a quick “staying power” round, they decide which top teams can survive November. Matthews names Missouri, Dodd’s alma mater, as his under-the-radar pick because the Tigers play Texas, Georgia and Kentucky in the next three weeks. Dodd doubts Missouri can win out.

The second half moves to game previews and off-field issues. Barnhart tells an old Bill Curry story about Alabama’s “Tide don’t lose in Baton Rouge” history. Dodd predicts Notre Dame vs. Miami will be an “instant classic” and calls Utah-BYU a “Church and State” rivalry with real hatred behind it. The group also notes that Lane Kiffin has turned Ole Miss games against Georgia and Tennessee into rivalries. On policy, Dodd says the SCORE Act is “essentially dead” after the midterm elections. Matthews predicts the SEC and Big Ten will eventually govern themselves, citing the SEC’s luxury-tax proposal and the Big Ten’s possible $48 million cap. He warns that boosters will find ways around any cap. Dodd closes with Miami receiver Cooper Barkate, who replaces the injured Malachi Toney and reunites with his Duke quarterback Darian Mensah. Barnhart tells listeners to enjoy the day because “we’re never going to see a Saturday like this again.”