Teddy thought his first date with Maya went great. They had good conversation, talked about their goals, and seemed to have plenty in common. But after the date, Maya suddenly stopped responding—and Teddy had no idea why.

When The Jubal Show gets Maya on the phone for a First Date Follow-Up, she finally explains what happened. Her version of the date is very different from Teddy's, and one unexpected detail about how they met has him questioning everything.

Then Teddy hears the entire conversation live. What follows is an awkward—and brutally honest—conversation about dating apps, first impressions, compatibility, and whether Teddy was actually trying to get to know Maya… or interviewing her for the role of girlfriend.