Story analyst Billy Mernit joins Michael Phillips to test one of Hollywood’s most enduring (and slippery) unofficial rules: Howard Hawks’ idea that a good movie is three good scenes and no bad ones.

Mernit, an instructor and writer known as the “guru of rom-com,” brings nearly three decades of reading studio scripts and a working knowledge of how films get evaluated before they ever reach the screen. Together, they dig into what makes a “good scene” in the first place.

Is Hawks’ dictum still useful? Or, like so many Hollywood rules, is it less a law of motion pictures than a reflection of how we choose to remember them?

Story analyst Billy Mernit joins Michael Phillips to test one of Hollywood&rsquo;s most enduring (and slippery) unofficial rules: Howard Hawks&rsquo; idea that a good movie is three good scenes and no bad ones. Mernit, an instructor and writer known as the &ldquo;guru of rom-com,&rdquo; brings nearly three decades of reading studio scripts and a working knowledge of how films get evaluated before they ever reach the screen. Together, they dig into what makes a &ldquo;good scene&rdquo; in the first place. Is Hawks&rsquo; dictum still useful? Or, like so many Hollywood rules, is it less a law of motion pictures than a reflection of how we choose to remember them?

Adam Kempenaar and Josh Larsen review new and classic movies, offering "affable, insightful film analysis since 2005" (NY Times).

New and classic movie reviews and top 5 lists.

Filmspotting

"A good movie is three good scenes and no bad ones” with Billy Mernit  | The Movie Racket

https://api.omny.fm/orgs/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/clips/08c45202-f971-4a26-9e31-b494010555d6/transcript