Last night on 1News I heard the single most logical and sane thing said in the entire bulletin in a long time.

It was said by Simon Upton, the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment. A very smart man. A Rhodes Scholar. A Former Minister for the Environment for National. 

Simon Upton said we should in, an ordinary way, take forestry out of the Emissions Trading Scheme. 

And I thought, why has it taken so long for someone to say it?

We should, in an orderly way, take forestry out of the Emissions Trading Scheme. 

Forestry for climate change has been a Ponzi scheme. The 1News reporter called it a golden ticket. 

It’s swamped productive land for easy gain. It’s caused rampant wilding growth through our wild lands. 

In essence, it’s a very big weed unless you’re farming it for wood and paper and even then, that market is turning sour - ask Tokoroa and Kawerau.  

But has it done anything to reduce emissions? We’ve had long enough for proof. It has not.  

It’s provided excuses for well-meaning pop bands to travel the world in private jets, planting useless forests in their wake and claiming moral superiority.  

But the 1News bit then went and missed the point. 

The headline was that we should plant natives instead of pine. 

Which he did say, but only if we keep with the nutso forest planting scheme.  

What Simon proposed was completely removing the ability of carbon polluters to rely on planting trees to meet their climate obligations. 

He said what New Zealand currently had been mostly a "tree planting scheme" that did little to cut planet-heating gases. And then the zinger quote:

"The world actually needs real reductions in gross emissions, not an accounting triumph".  

If you want to cut your emissions, then cut your emissions. But don't plant a tree.

Last night on 1News I heard the single most logical and sane thing said in the entire bulletin in a long time.
It was said by Simon Upton, the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment. A very smart man. A Rhodes Scholar. A Former Minister for the Environment for National.&nbsp;
Simon Upton said we should in, an ordinary way, take forestry out of the Emissions Trading Scheme.&nbsp;
And I thought, why has it taken so long for someone to say it?
We should, in an orderly way, take forestry out of the Emissions Trading Scheme.&nbsp;
Forestry for climate change has been a Ponzi scheme. The 1News reporter called it a golden ticket.&nbsp;
It’s swamped productive land for easy gain. It’s caused rampant wilding growth through our wild lands.&nbsp;
In essence, it’s a very big weed unless you’re farming it for wood and paper and even then, that market is turning sour - ask Tokoroa and Kawerau. &nbsp;
But has it done anything to reduce emissions? We’ve had long enough for proof. It has not. &nbsp;
It’s provided excuses for well-meaning pop bands to travel the world in private jets, planting useless forests in their wake and claiming moral superiority. &nbsp;
But the 1News bit then went and missed the point.&nbsp;
The headline was that we should plant natives instead of pine.&nbsp;
Which he did say, but only if we keep with the nutso forest planting scheme. &nbsp;
What Simon proposed was completely removing the ability of carbon polluters to rely on planting trees to meet their climate obligations.&nbsp;
He said what New Zealand currently had been mostly a "tree planting scheme" that did little to cut planet-heating gases. And then the zinger quote:
"The world actually needs real reductions in gross emissions, not an accounting triumph". &nbsp;
If you want to cut your emissions, then cut your emissions. But don't plant a tree.

A fresh and intelligent start to your day - catch the very latest international and domestic news developments, sport, entertainment and business on Early Edition with Ryan Bridge, on Newstalk ZB.

A fresh and intelligent start to your day - catch the very latest international and domestic news developments, sport, entertainment and business on Early Edition with Ryan Bridge, on Newstalk ZB.

Early Edition with Ryan Bridge

Andrew Dickens: Why forestry should be removed from the ETS

https://api.omny.fm/orgs/7784f840-c291-422a-924b-ad9000bbad71/clips/8da0849d-e995-42ee-bff9-b2bb0129b093/transcript