Explicit

Escaping a Cult with Bethany Joy Lenz

Published Dec 12, 2024, 8:05 AM

 

One Tree Hill star Bethany Joy Lenz joins Chelsea to discuss what it was like to fall prey to a religious cult, to be taken for every penny she had, and finally find small moments of joy after escaping their grasp.  Then: A child of powerful members of a *certain religious organization* works to accept that she may have lost her parents forever.  

*

Need some advice from Chelsea? Email us at DearChelseaPodcast@gmail.com

*

Executive Producer Catherine Law

Edited & Engineered by Brad Dickert

*

*

*

*

*

The views and opinions expressed are solely those of the Podcast author, or individuals participating in the Podcast, and do not represent the opinions of iHeartMedia or its employees.  This Podcast should not be used as medical advice, mental health advice, mental health counseling or therapy, or as imparting any health care recommendations at all.  Individuals are advised to seek independent medical, counseling advice and/or therapy from a competent health care professional with respect to any medical condition, mental health issues, health inquiry or matter, including matters discussed on this Podcast. Guests and listeners should not rely on matters discussed in the Podcast and shall not act or shall refrain from acting based on information contained in the Podcast without first seeking independent medical advice. 

 

Hi Catherine, Hi Chelsea.

How are you?

Readings from Whistler, Canada, my new home for the next three weeks.

I'm so pleased for you. You're always happier when you're chilly. Yes, I am. I needed a real fucking break this year, real break.

I needed to take my own advice, read my own book, and then reread Letting Go.

I need lots of help, so I am now decompressing.

Amazing is your new book? Is it like a little bit advice based as well or more personal?

St It's pretty much how to be optimistic in the dark, how to inject yourself with positivity and optimism.

And I have lost.

My way with positivity and optimism, so I really need to reread it.

It does happen sometimes where you like need a little bit of a reset.

Yeah, absolutely absolutely.

My schedule for the last two months has just been was just insane. Why and the travel and the shows, and then the my house never being done, and then the podcasts. You know, we're kind I've been running her ragon. They decide to it's your fault. They decide to do construction when I'm recording. You know, I'm gone fifty days a fucking month. It feels like, and then the one day they're doing stuff is when I'm home.

So it has just.

Been Yeah, nobody seems to understand how to manage a schedule, including myself.

Just twenty different groups all pulling you in different.

Directs, right right, right.

I mean, I'm grateful for the work, but it's hard to be grateful when you're so fucking tired, and then you start pitching, and then you start getting negative and all of that stuff, and then you go RecA I am recharging as we speak. I'm plugged into a recharger. It's in my butt, by the way, speaking of recharging. My two last shows of the year in America, well until further notice, because I don't know that I'm going to be touring next year. So I have a show in New Orleans on December twenty eighth, and on December twenty ninth, I'm in Atlanta, Georgia, So get your tickets at Chelseahandler dot com. You can also find out where I'll be doing live book events next year, for I'll have What She's Having, which comes out February twenty fifth. That's on my website too, where I'll be signing books, talking taking pictures all of that stuff.

Awesome.

Yeah, And just to clarify, since we promised we would last week, that's where you can get your signed copies of the book. And you can also get them at books a million in Barns and Noble.

Right, yes, yes, I signed lots of books for books a million of Barnes and Noble. So many books. My back went out. I aalira happy there are boxes.

Yeah. Yeah.

The day of Thanksgiving, my sister was cooking a turkey in the kitchen, even though I can't tell her she can't cook and why does she keep trying? And I sat there for five hours and signed books and I made like a dent in the I was like, oh, I didn't realize how many books.

Ten thousand books.

I didn't realize that that's just almost it's almost a bond.

With my lifestyle. Who are we introducing.

We are introducing Bethany Joy Lens.

This was a good interview and a great book. Okay, So our guest today is an actress, singer, songwriter and co host of the One Tree Hill Rewatch podcast drama Queens. Her new memoir, Dinner for Vampires is out now. Please welcome Bethany Joy Lens Hi NOI.

Hi, oh hello, Hi, How are you great?

How are you girls?

I'm just so happy you're cult free?

Me too, Mama.

Oh my god, that book. Oh my god.

I have never really ever been interested in colts, So I don't I haven't watched all of these shows that everyone has watched in all of these docuseries or whatever they are, and I've never really read about a cult.

This is my first reading about a cult.

Really, yeah, and it was pretty stunning. I guess I want to ask you now that you're out of it for how many years have you been out of it? Five?

Oh?

No, longer about thirteen?

Oh?

Oh wow, twelve thirteen?

Yeah? Oh okay, So now you have some real perspective.

Yeah, okay, Yeah, that's I think that's what made it okay for me to write the book without feeling like I was going to fall apart every day, because there's I have a certain measure of objectivity about it now, I think.

Wow, okay, So I'm curious to see before we get into all the details or whatever we decide to talk about, what do you think now when you think about why you were susceptible in the first place to being commandeered in that way and falling into that.

What do you think it was.

I think it was a longing for attachment, which is a pretty human need. I think it's the same thing that draws anyone into any kind of abusive situation, whether it's a workplace environment that you just can't seem to leave, or a toxic relationship, or staying in a family environment, a biological family environment that's just super toxic and abusive. There's this sense of a need for attachment that we all have. And I was twenty years old. It's so different now, having so much mileage in my life that I feel like my radar is so much better. But back then I was twenty, It's like, what did I know. I was taught to respect authority. I was taught to believe your elders and believe people who seem like they have your best interests at heart. And I wanted a family.

Yeah, yeah, you wanted a family. That's true.

Like I could see that, and you can see that in the book because there were so many hints, like even the first time you met Less, the cult leader, when you met him, you were grossed out, like itcked out by him initially right, and then so like, there were so many instances that you write about in the book from the beginning of meeting this like kind of seemingly harmless group of people and all being kind of involved in religion and Christianity and wanting to spend time together in your own kind of like prayer group or spirituality group or however you know we can frame it. There were all these little signs along the way, but you always kind of convinced yourself that it wasn't your place to judge them or have an opinion about them, and instead convinced yourself it was the right thing to do to stick with.

Isn't that amazing? Like the testament to the fact that we all have this innate guttural knowledge like compass, where we know, you know something's off, and we talk ourselves out of things, into or out of things all the time, even from a young age. I mean, I write about in the book how my mom and dad when they would be arguing. There were so many moments I'd walk into the room or they would leave a room that they had been arguing behind a closed door, and I'd be like, what's wrong? And I was just met with like everything's fine, No, nothing's wrong, And as a kid, you just start to think, oh, I guess I guess it's me, Like maybe I'm crazy. I guess I'm the one that thinks everybody is being tense and there's nothing wrong. So you really start to doubt your own gut and your own instinct. And you do that enough, then people can come in and take advantage of you if they recognize that trait in you.

Yeah, I think that's going to be interesting to a lot of callers and a lot of mothers listening to this conversation, because you basically got swept up in this group of people and started to believe they were your real family, as they convinced you that they were really the only people that cared about you and that understood you right. And any time your father or your mother came on the scene, who were both concerned because they could see something was a little bit off, they were met with silence or kind of like you know, they were ignored or dismissed as not even really having a valid place in your life anymore. And this went on from when you were on One Tree Hill, which you were filming for how many seasons. Were you on their seven We did nine seasons, which was even doubt about ten years. So ten years on that show, and the whole time you were in this cult, the whole time flying back and forth to Idaho from North Carolina, right was North Carolina a.

Whole Yeah, from North Carolin. We were in Wilmington. Wilmington, North Carolina, which is like one of the small, super small beachy town that has no direct flights to the West coast at all. I have to always take double flights. It was exhausting. It was like eight to twelve hour travel days every time.

And there was nothing glamorous about it at all. Like when you described the house in Idaho the big house in Idaho, because you met these people in La first, right, and then they had this other house in Idaho, which was already there was a lot of not normal behavior around that, like it was someone else's house that they kind of commandeered. And then all of you guys, kind of all these vagabonds for lack of a better word, people who were a little bit lost, kind of like yourself, would move into this house and kind of created this family. And then over the course of the time you were there, they basically embezzled over two million dollars from.

You, right, Yes, that is true.

And you got married and had a baby within the cults.

I'm just so glad that you're free. I'm so happy for you. That is incredible.

That's all that matters, right, is that you're out of that situation.

Yes, and I look at it bizarrely. I mean, I know it might sound kind of strange, but I do look at it as a blessing. I mean, I think we all deal with crazy shit in our lives and when one way or another, if it's not one thing, it's something else. Mine falls under a category that in our culture right now is deemed really strange and weird and crazy. But my aim with this book is to show how what a slow burn it is, and how even though the narcissistic abuse was in a group format, for what I experienced, the top notes are all the same in any kind of abusive relationship across the board. And that's what I want people to take away, that, like, you don't have to have been in a cult in order to deeply relate to the sense of being gas lit and love bombed and coerced and taken advantage of and yes, to your point, thank god, I'm out, Like I'm so happy that I'm out, But I'm really I'm grateful that I went through it because now I feel like I've got something in my life that I can help other people with.

So are you coming into with being on this book tour and now going public with this story because a lot of people, your cast members were also They all kind of suspected that you were involved with something that wasn't really on the up and up, and you had some close friends on the cast and some friends that you missed an opportunity at that time to develop relationships with because you were in such a kind of controlling environment.

So are people asking you?

Are there women and young women and men asking you questions about whether or not they're in an abusive or narcissistic dynamic?

Now I do get some of those. I get more of people who say they know someone who's in an abusive dynamic and they don't know what to do and they don't know how to help them, And.

What do you say to that?

It's hard. It's hard, you, guys, because the very nature of it is your identity, your whole construct of your identity becomes tied up in the approval or the attachment that you have with this person or these people. So for some to say to you, hey, I think you're in an abusive relationship, Hey I think you're in a cult, or anything to that end is not just It's not just information that you can objectively sit back and say, let me take a look at this and see if that's true. Your heart and soul and identity are already bound up in it. So how could anybody say something to you that's going to make you The stakes are so high, you know. And I know for me at that time, nobody could have said anything, and they tried. There were people that tried. Nobody could have said anything to me that would have convinced me of a different reality than the one I was living in in my mind. And so long winded answer to your question, what I try and advise people is be a friend. If you can manage to maintain a friendship of honesty, where the person trusts you and values you. You know, there's a little bit of pushback, but not too much. Don't give them too much pushback because then they might just cut you out of their life. If you become this sort of like suppressive person or whatever the version of that.

Is, which also I just sorry, I want to interrupt you, because that's the very important thing you say in the book. Is the first sign that you are in something that is not cool or you're being coerced is when anyone who's not part of that group becomes someone you're not.

Allowed to talk to. Right, Like I forget the word.

They use in scientology, like suppressive personality, but like anyone who doesn't agree with that, if you're not allowed to talk to certain people because they don't subscribe to your religion or your spirituality, then that is a big red flag anyone who tries to cut you off from other people.

And what you're saying is it's so accurate. And also think about it doesn't necessarily come out from the abuser as the words you're not allowed. In my case, it came out as much more condescending, much more like it's masked as kindness in a way, like that person is not maybe not safe for you, guard your heart, look out for yourself, look out for them too. You don't want to be talking to them about spiritual concepts that they can't understand. That's going to set up a representation of Christ for them. That's too confusing. So keep you know the language. You really have to pay attention not just to what someone is saying, but what they're doing. And if the byproduct of what's being said is isolation, that's you have to pay attention to that, because it's not going to come out as obvious. If the person is a real narcissist, if they're good at their job, if they're controlling you, it's going to come out much more veiled.

Do you think that Christianity, like your childhood Christianity, had any factor in this?

Sure? Oh yeah, it was massive. I mean, as for anyone out there who has not read Dinner for Vampires. I grew up in a charismatic evangelical church, non denominational, not super political or anything. It wasn't extreme in that way it was it was just very loose, like there was no when it's non denominational, there's no system or structure that you have that the pastor has accountability to. They kind of can say whatever they want and maybe there's elders in the church, but it's not part of like if you're Presbyterian, you're part of the presbytery, and there's this like long overarching community of leaders and people who've been holding on to hundreds of years of theology and things like that. So there's this like accountability that comes with a lot of denominations. So non denominational is what I grew up in, which also made me a lot more comfortable to be in an environment where some guy comes in says whatever he wants and I'm like, well, you're a pastor, so I guess I can believe you too, with no accountability. But I do think that I mean, it's actually I feel like it's kind of a miracle that I still have managed to have a relationship with God and with christ. I really hesitate to use the word Christian because of what it means, especially in this country right now, but that relationship is still exists for me, but in a much more authentic way because I think what I was taught, I know what I was taught when I was young was very much Here are the things you need to do. Here are the rules you need to follow in order to have the kind of life that God wants you to have. In order to get the life that you want to get, God to give you the life that you want. You just need to follow all these rules and then you'll be happy. Turns out that's not so true. Turns out bad things happen to people who are following all the rules too.

No, I would have been so jypped. I would have felt so jypped.

You were bleeding God's life and then God did that, Like I would be so fucking pissed.

Yeah, I was.

Because in the beginning of.

The book, like when you're kind of not on the fence about joining this group of people because they kind of wind and dined you, so to speak. You talk about a moment where you're asking you're silently sitting there alone, trying to feel God's presence and giving you guidance and what to do. And in that moment you talk about feeling it and that was this signal that you needed to actually get more involved or I think it was. Was it to get more involved in the group, where maybe it was to give up a job. No, No, it was to get more involved in the group.

Right, which moment are you talking about? I'm trying to I might have missed something. You said.

There's two moments. I'll tell you about your own book. Let me tell.

You, there's one moment where you're at the beginning of becoming very involved with this group of people at the beginning, and you were like waiting to hear God's voice, and God's like, I'm here with you, you know, kind of like almost a confirmation of maybe you were hesitant or wavering. So tell us about that moment when you felt God's energy in that moment.

Yes, okay, this is one of my favorite moments in life. And I really didn't tell very many I mean maybe like three people in my life. I've ever told about this before I wrote this book because I know it kind of sounds crazy. So anyway, I well it's all out there now.

It's not as crazy as you call.

So.

Yeah, I'm nineteen years old, I'm living in New York. I'm happy. I've got a great life, i got a great job. There's really no problem. And I'm sitting in this cafe on a rainy Tuesday or whatever, and I look out and I'm thinking to myself, huh, you know what, you know, it would be weird if all this Christianity stuff, like all this Jesus stuff that I grew up with, if that was all just made up in somebody's imagination and a bunch of people believe it and it's just not true. And then I was like, oh, well, I mean it's working for me, like my life is happy, I'm doing well, like I guess I'll find out when I die, and really just kind of moved on from it. I didn't think much more beyond that, and I write about it more in detail in the book of Really What It felt like. But I felt like it was like I was in a slow motion movie, like every molecule in my body just went to the perfect temperature. Everything got really still and quiet, and I felt the physical presence of a body sit next to me in this booth that I was in at this empty cafe, and obviously there was no one there. And I heard a voice, like an audible voice, very close to my ear, and it said, never doubt that.

I am real.

And then it went away, and I remember, like immediately, you know, tears in my eyes, and I was like desperately trying to remember the sound of the voice, and it just was gone, like everything was just gone instantly. And I was confused by it for years because I thought of all the time I've all the times in my life I've been in pain and anguish in my knees, like, God, where are you? Give me a sign? Tell me something? What should I do? What choice should I make? How do I feel better from this or that? Nothing? And I would feel like radio silence. Why in the world would God have bothered to come and let me know that I was I was seen, not just like some random universal feel like this thing that loves me, whatever love means, and that sort of like vast context, but like a very intentional personal joy. I see you, I hear you, I love you. I'm real. Why would you bother doing that in a moment that was completely insignificant where there was nothing at stake? And I didn't realize until all those years later, when I was in exactly the moment that you were talking about, Chelsea saying I was fucking pissed. I was jypped. I was like, I just devoted my whole life to you. I did all the right things, and this is what I get. Fuck you? And I really like, I literally just said that to God, fuck you, fuck you, I hate you. I'm so mad at you. How dare you? And it was like there was this big, cosmic sigh of relief, like thank you, thank you for finally being honest with me and stopping all of this pretending to be somebody that you're not. Can you just be real? And it all just dropped in and I felt like, oh my god, that's why, because I would have just abandoned God. I would have just walked away and said this God stuff is total nonsense and I don't want to have anything to do with it ever again. But I couldn't because I knew too much. Because I had one moment that I just could not explain when I was nineteen, and that's what kind of kept me in a space where I could still move forward with an authentic version of my fate and abandon all the rest of the garbage.

Oh God, just this, It's just.

People are going to eat this book up because of this first hand account of just what you went through and all of the like levels of pervasiveness that they had in your life. You had so many opportunities in your field, acting, singing, all of these opportunities that you had, and many of them you didn't pursue because of these cults and those cult leaders or the cult leader the main one less and they prohibited you from They wanted your money, but they didn't want you to be too exposed to other people that may have an influence on you and call out the fact that this was not on the up and up.

Yeah, that was one of the craziest things to me.

You think that these people who are motivated by like using you would want you to take more opportunities. But I think you're right. It's like keeping you away from people who might convince you like, hey, there's a bigger world out there.

Yeah. And I had been out on my own for so long, and like, I think they had to do more work with me because I had so much unusual backlog of life experience for someone my age of being independent, being on my own, being in all these different experiences and connecting deeply with groups of people and then fragmenting off and then getting involved in another group of people because that's what theater is. That's what you do for you know, your two months, your non stop with the same people, and every job you do, it's like that. So I think they think he and the Pam character the sort of mother of the group. I think they knew in some way that they were going to have to really work hard at convincing me how important it was to be a part of a family and make that my priority over work. And also I don't think Les wanted the group to really grow because I think he was kind of lazy and there's just so much work involved with so many.

People drolling people.

Yeah, you know, that's got to be exhausting. So I think he just didn't want me to make too much money because if I'm out there in the world making too much money and converting too many people to be a part of our little family, then the liability goes up.

So yeah, but those people are all on power trips, you know what I mean. They want the power, They love the power, they love the control. So I don't even know if you can mitigate your desire for power when you're that much of a narcissist. But maybe because of you know, you bring up some legal aspects and you know, like you can't you're not technically accult unless you're like influencing or damaging more than seventies people's lives or something.

I think you give us, Yeah, some stats at the end.

In the state of Idaho, how does it work having a child with someone that you're now separated from in such a big.

Way, Like, yeah, there are some unique challenges with that. It's something that I spent some real time considering how much I wanted to say about that in the book, because the truth is that they do still have a relationship, and so I don't want to I just don't want to interfere with that. And I don't know him anymore really really, so I can't say much about him.

And so when you were able, when you did leave finally, were you scared for your safety?

Definitely the first because you were.

Living in the same state and you had your own house and they were trying to bully you and intimidate you.

Oh yeah, awful. I was scared because as I started to accept the fact that this was a cult, a high demand group. I mean, it took me a minute, like I really didn't want to admit that that's what I had been involved in. But once I started to admit that, then I was like, oh my god, I know what cults are.

Like.

I used to study scientology when I was in high school because I was fascinated by it irony. I didn't remember doing a paper on it once and there, and I was always kind of interested in the idea of a cult and how somebody could get sucked into that careful what you uh? What you what you was for for studies, I don't know anyway. I knew what the patterns looked like in a lot of these other groups, and I really felt this sense of maybe I don't know how deep this rabbit hole goes with this group, Like maybe I've only been shown what I've been shown, and there's so much more under the surface that I've never been a part of. I was living in North Carolina for nine months out of the year. There could have been all kinds of things going on that I didn't know about. And the buzzword of toxic masculinity could never have been more true in an environment like this. I mean these the sense of machismo and how important it was for the men in the group to feel like warriors. They had to be warring against something at all times, including the women in their life, if there was nothing else for them to fight against. So since I knew that their identity was wrapped up in needing to feel like they were fighting something, I knew they were going to come out after me. Because I was now the thing that they all needed to fight against. And it's I was really scared, I think for about a year until I saw enough consistent creepy, weird behavior, but nothing overly aggressive. It's not like the people. It's not like it was certainly wasn't like scientology where people get stalked in their home and they're you know, being threatened in things.

And when you when you started like allowing them, like to be a co signer on your account, when you opened up like a joint bank account with the leader of this cult and you're basically signing your earnings away to him.

What was with his son? So that was with the my husband at the time, because he so his I mean less it's kind of brilliant about not or oh god that just yes, I didn't still good in my mouth. He's he's very savvy about how to keep his name off of things, how to get people to give him what he wants, about having to put his name on it.

I mean so yeah, So that joint bank account was with your ex husband who was his son? Yes, okay, So did you ever tell anyone in your real life that you did that or did you keep that a secret?

I mean, my business manager, my former business manager who I was transferring the funds away from.

And what did they say to you?

We're like, Joe, I think this is a mistake, Like I really, these people are not qualified to take care of your money. They don't have the experience. Come a little worried about you. But they weren't my close friends. They were right people that I had hired, So what else would I expect them to do? Like they I think he even went on a limb out on a limb saying that much so and I felt it too. I'm just having this visceral memory of being in his office in New York too. I remember feeling it and feeling like he was right, and also knowing the day to day verbal and mental abuse that I was living in and how much relief I was going to get by moving this money because I just wouldn't be berated every day anymore about that.

The pressure would be off of letting them control. You're exactly, yeah, I could. I could just let them handle it. And it was like, fine, if this will make you stop yelling at me every day, if this will make us stop fighting, then yes, go ahead. You be in charge of the money. You be in charge of the money, honey, and I will go to work.

Because you don't talk about that a lot in the book, like there's obviously the control happening, but it didn't.

I didn't get the impression that.

You were being yelled at or berated on a daily basis. With your ex you kind of you talk about that, but with Less and Pam and Kurt and all those guys, it seemed much more manipulative rather than on the face rage or yeah right.

So, yeah, I may not have been clear just now. What I meant was that the day to day that I was living with in my marriage, of the constant conflict.

Controlling reading your scripts, being not allowing you to do scenes with men, not allowing you to rehearse with men, go out to dinner with any of your cast members, that were then right.

Yeah, and everything I wore, not even on the show, but in real life too, just every aspect of my life was under a microscope and controlled. And money was one of the one of the biggest topics that we would fight about all the time. And I was just like, yeah, I wanted to spend three hundred and fifty dollars at J Crew. It's not a big deal. Why is this a two hour conversation? And it became so much of that that I was like, there are so many other things that were fighting about all the time. If the money will alleviate a lot of this stress, then go ahead and be in charge of the money.

So when you get out of a cult and you realize that they have drained your bank account, you had two hundred and twenty thousand dollars I think left at the end, and you realize there was two million missing. So that's one set of problems. You have a child, that's another issue. How does one move on? Like what kind of therapy did you go into when you left this cult?

Multiple? Multiple, And even therapy was hard because I had just spent ten years in an environment where I was quote unquote going to therapy every week with my church leader, my group leader, both of them actually last and Pam couples therapy, individual therapy, group therapy in the basement like it was all and so even being able to trust a therapist walking into an office and not like it was real work to a let myself to trust someone that was a total stranger based on maybe a friend's reference or a diploma on the wall that was that was its own journey, and I did go through a few different therapists before I found somebody that I really just felt in my gut, and they probably all were trustworthy, but I finally did find someone that I really connected with. But it was so it was so difficult, and even paying for it was hard because I left with two hundred and twenty thousand dollars, but it all ended up going into my divorce and my rent. Within two years it was gone and I had I was upside down on my mortgage. We had to do a short sale, but there was another house that I had to take on debt for the retirement account got split and half like there was so much that I couldn't I couldn't pay rent. There were months when I didn't know how I was going to pay rent and I had to call my landlord and be like, can you wup me till next month? Is this going to be okay?

Oh God?

Which is just so crazy, or nine years on a series and it was really humbling. It was really really hard. But I feel like I learned so much about joy in the midst of suffering.

Where did you find that joy? In the midst of suffering. When were those moments.

Those moments were in They were in the little things. It was just a day to day. And it's one of the things where I say my faith has become the most authentic version of it for me, because rather than feeling like I was going to achieve some sense of peace by doing a bunch of things the right way, I got to just live in a place of abandon like I don't know what I'm going to do. I'm not gonna I refuse to allow this to make me more anxious, more stressed, more like more confined in my life. I've been confined for the last ten years and probably the ten before that growing are you joining before that? Growing up? So I don't want to live confined anymore. I want to be free. So how do I be free while I have all of these outside circumstances confining me? And it was really it was really interesting, the little moments were looking at the I actually just posted a poem about this today, a poem that I wrote. When we were living in Studio City, we had this little apartment. It was a house. It was like a two bedroom, little bungalow house on the corner behind the oyster bar, which was just a total I mean at the parking lot at two am, Like I remember, I would always scream up the window. Dane Cook was outside my window one time at the oyster Bar in the parking lot. I just knew that voice, and I was opening up my window, like, go home, home, and there's children sleeping. But we had They had a dumpster in their parking lot that they would leave the flap open all the time and it would hang over into my backyard lovely, and it used to make me so mad. I would go out there in the morning with a broomstick and shove that lit over and like, h my life and what these people did to me. And little by little we had a rose bush, and the rose bush started growing, and eventually it got so big and high that you couldn't see the dumpster lid when it came over. And that's how slow it grows. It wasn't an overnight thing. But I learned moment by moment how to just slow down and appreciate the things that I do have. I learned there's nothing that says I'm entitled to a perfect, happy, golden little life. I get to be happy with where I am and what I have, and I don't. I'm not entitled to not suffer that I'm human. Things are going to happen. Wow. How can I be at piece when no matter, I mean, when.

Growing over your dumpster?

That's it.

And Dane Cook is no longer in your parking lot? Thank god. That is a nightmare.

Okay, we're gonna take a break and we're gonna come back with Bethany Joy Lens. Okay, and we're back. Okay, Joy Joy, you go by Joy. My middle name is Joy also, so we know.

That double Joy.

So we have a double Joy today. Thank you so much for sharing that. This book is incredible. Everyone's going to want to read it. It really is important. I think every woman should read this, because every every girl, I mean, I know boys are susceptible too, but obviously my main concern are women.

Yeah, young girls.

Thank you.

Well, I think we have a perfect question for you. We have Mariah on the line, and she'll be joining us here in a moment, she says, Dear Chelsea, last year, just a couple of days before my thirtieth birthday, I got the call I had been expecting for some time from my mother, who informed me she was quote unquote parting ways with me. My parents both work for the Church of Scientology, as well as my siblings. There's an episode in Leah Remeni's TV show about the Seattle Church of Scientology which covers a document my father wrote about how to get money from parishioners. I really can't emphasize enough how deeply involved my family is. My parents felt the need to disown me after I left Scientology, but that's because it's one of the church rules. My mom had been holding out on disconnecting from me for a while, but I could see her growing more distant over the last year, so I did know it was coming. As I reached out to try and keep a connection alive with her. She eventually stopped responding, but then at the end of October she finally called and told me. I'm still doing a lot of work to recover and deprogram myself, but I feel so devastated for my mom. I could hear over the phone that my mom was crying and reading from a script in front of another person who was monitoring our call. I hate that the hard life she had landed her in a cult. She's now been in for nearly forty five years, and she felt like she had to cut me off despite us having an otherwise very good relationship. Of course, I'm also so angry and hurt that my own family would do.

This to me.

I missed my so much, but I don't want to cross the boundary she's set. But I also want her to know if she can come to me if she needs. I'm successful in my own right and I have no plans on having kids, so I keep a spare bedroom available just in case my siblings or my mom managed to escape and need to go somewhere. The holidays are coming up and we won't spend them together, and I don't know if I should reach out or if I should just focus on protecting myself and just move on.

Do you have any advice?

Sincerely, Mariah?

Oh h II, I'm Mariah.

I'm Mariah.

Hi.

Nice to meet you, guys.

It's great to meet you too.

Nice to meet you too. What do you think about that? Joy?

This breaks my heart. You don't deserve Mariah. You do not deserve that, and nobody does. That is not okay, It's not okay. I guess I would say that maintaining any kind of contact. I guess it's what feels authentic to you. I don't know that there's a hard and fast rule. If you have it, then you even a thread of it to be able to still Happy birthday, thinking about you, Mom, Love you, Merry Christmas. Dropped off some flowers for you. I hope you enjoy them, Like if you had that in you, if you can find that place, that would be beautiful, and I think that would be meaningful. But you're not obligated if you can't if you don't have that capability, like you are not responsible for saving your mother. So it's I think it's got to be from what is going to feel for you, like what you need to do?

What are you Mariah? What are you doing?

Like?

How are you coping?

What are you doing for yourself to help yourself get through being excommunicated from your own family?

Yeah, I see a therapist, but I kind of like mentally left before this happened. And it was a balance of like, Okay, how much do I don't I tell my parents about my life and just being honest and stuff about everything going on in my life, But it really is just my mom like that I wonder about and so I talked to my therapist about this a lot, and I'm kind of just still dealing with it my journal and stuff and just still trying to figure out everything about how to move forward and what I took from this that's bad and good, you know. So I don't know if I answered your question good enough, but I'm just trying to kind of make my way through.

Can I I have a question? And I also want to tell you, like, because my mom stayed in relationship with me by not asking too many questions I pushing too hard. She just kind of like kind of stayed on the surface, knowing that eventually I was going to come around. But my dad was different and became estranged. I did essentially to him what your mom has done to you, and I, even in my delusion, I never stopped loving my dad. They lied to me. They tried to make me believe terrible things about my father that were not true. And even as I was trying to like navigate through that, he started sending me letters, handwritten letters. He started sending me photos of my little brother and birthday parties and what was happening in life. And they used to make me really angry. I used to not want to read them. I didn't want to deal with the emotions that they brought up, but it it made a difference for me, like it did when I got out. I knew he was there. I knew I was going to have to make one hard phone call, to pick up the phone and call and say, hey, Dad, I'm really sorry. It's been six years, but I did it. And you know that's that's possible. But at the same time, that's not to say that again, you're not responsible for her journey, but that just something. But my question, if it's okay, do you feel comfortable telling us what your what advice your therapist has given you, because I haven't. I haven't been put in a position to give advice much other than like one on one if I see people and they're asking me. But this is new for me, so I would love to know what that advice is, if you're okay with sharing.

Yeah. Well, first of all, I just finished reading your book and it's really good, So I think your story is incredible. Just for the record, and I did get kind of emotional hearing you talk about your dad because I listened to the audiobook, which was definitely good with it hear your voice and get your take on what you went through. But yeah, that is something that I exactly talk to my therapist about. Is like, Okay, so I feel bad that my mom is in this, but also I was born into it. I didn't have any choices and she made choices. And am I being you know, am I being delusional that it's like it was our relationship actually what I thought it was? And did all the rules that I was taught growing up actually come from her place of like I think this is right versus I'm told to tell you this, you know, and this is what I've been led to believe. But yeah, the advice my therapist is given is to just try to move on and try to accept that I might never hear from her. She's been in it for longer than I've been alive, So she has been an ally of scientology longer than she has been my mother. So that's something that is like, realistically, yeah, if you're going to get past that, you have to leave a very powerful cults, one of the more powerful ones, and like that's not super realistic. And then there's like my siblings and my dad, Like my dad is almost sort of the less type of person to compare it to your wow situation. Yeah, and so he's a narcissist. He is really good at getting people to give money to Scientology done to lots of people what last did to you in terms of like money management and stuff like that. So my mom sees their relationship as the greater good. She's helping the world be better by supporting him. So she's like the breadwinner. She's kind of been supporting my dad my whole life while he works for the Church of Scientology and she works part time for the Church of Scientology.

So just to give you.

Some context of why my dad's not I'm not interested in being in my life, you know what I mean. So, Yeah, my therapist and they mostly talk about just kind of moving on from this and if she ever does reach out, like just take it from there.

Yeah.

And also to be able to remind yourself that this isn't really who your mother is. You know, it's almost like dealing with an addict where you have to remember that they're on a drug and that this isn't a reflection of how she really feels about you. You know that she was upset during that phone call. You know that she was being monitored during that phone call. We all know all of these things that cults do to their cult members, but to remember that, Like, it's so sad what you've experienced and what you're still going through, and I totally I can feel you, you know, but that's not who your mother really is, and that's not a reflection.

Of her love for you. Your mother does love you.

I believe that you know that she loved you because she was so upset during that phone call, and you know that that is the drug making her do that, and as painful as that is, you can't have that in your life unless she has the gumption to leave the church at some point, and like you said, she's been in there for forty five years, that is very unlikely. So what you do have to do is try to make peace with the idea that you did have a family they're not themselves in this current state, that you did experience tons of love and joy, and take a lot of pride in the fact that you were able to remove yourself from a situation that puts you at odds with your family because you were standing up for what you know is right. Yeah, and that that wasn't for you and that is really ballsy and really brave, and as heartbreaking as it is, that is what is going to carry you forward to the rest of your life so that you can pursue a successful life. You could have a success cessful romantic relationship with whomever you want.

You can have your.

Own family, and you have to carry on like these people aren't going to leave scientology because the likelihood is slim, but it's never You never know.

It could happen, but you just can't count on it happening.

And I think you should get up every day and think about the things that you have in your life that you're grateful for and write them down, you know, every morning, write down the ten things that you have that you are your own, and those things can be that you had the goodwill and the good sense to get out of a cult.

You know, I got myself out of it.

I'm standing here on my own two feet without any of them because I had the presence of mind to do something better for myself. Don't diminish any of the gains that you made by getting out of that.

That is great advice. And also think about this as an opportunity because there are older women who are brilliant mentors who can step into that role for you and be a friend and be nobody's ever going to replace your mother. But I think that as I was just saying before, you know, there's no sort of like get out of suffering free card. We all have something that we encounter that's just like, how am I going to get through this? What am I going to do? And there is opportunity in every one of those moments. And there may be somebody out there who you're going to encounter that you never would have encountered if this hadn't happened, and they need you in their life and you need them in your life, maybe multiple people you don't know. So while that doesn't wipe away the pain, and you still can hold that pain and process through it as you need to, there is opportunity and there are really good things that can come from hardship.

How did you decide to leave scientology?

That's it probably, I think anyone who leaves a cult, there's not like a single moment that they like just decide I've a light, you know, it's usually a ton of moments. But for me, I mean the silver lining of being born into it was that my parents were quite busy with it and quite neglectful, so I was sort of left to my own devices most of the time. I read the Internet. I got an education because I eventually had to start working like retail jobs to just like having money for food and stuff. When I was a teenager, and I was like, well, I want a better life than what a retail job can give me, you know. So I went to school and that was sort of the beginning of the deprogramming. That was how I kind of learned how to determine if something is real or not when the claim is made. That is how I learned how to, Like I got, I got a science degree, so I learned a lot about how science works and what is and isn't science. So for me, that's that was how it went down, because it's scientology is not really a sort of god type religion. It's like it's barely a religion.

It's like more about, oh.

Yeah, if you do A B and C, this will happen. But then there's actually no real evidence, no real anything but claims.

You're amazing, that's such a great story the progression of.

That, And how did you tell your parents you were leaving.

I actually didn't. Someone thought that I was following some people on Twitter I'm not supposed to follow and they reported me. So then my dad, because he's like one of the leaders, he got the report and he called me and was like, hey, we need to talk. And uh so my parents scheduled a few meetings with me to talk about my thoughts and what they wanted me to do, and I kind I just had to stay my boundaries over and over again, like yeah.

You guys can't defy this for me.

I'm not going to unfollow someone just because you want me to.

Wow. Oh good for you. Yeah, that's incredible, it really is.

I'm just gonna let my dog outside of this room real quick.

Okay, sure, I'm really glad she has a dog.

I know.

Yeah, yeah, that's one of the things that you're going to write down that you're grateful for, is your dog every morning. When we talk about these gratitude like journaling and gratitude lists, like to all of our listeners, it could be anything.

It can be like it can be material things.

It could be your sofa, it can be your personality, it can be someone else, it can be your friend. Like when I'm saying to write down things, like some people people always ask me, They're like, well, what if it's materialistic, that's okay. Just write down ten things that you're grateful for. You know, your sensibility can be one of the things. Your dog can be another thing. The house that you're staying in, the apartment that you're renting, whatever, it is, your job, and I just slowly want you to get yourself to a place where of acceptance rather than grief, because of course you're going to feel grief for a really long time. But if you can get to a place of acceptance and understanding that this really has very little to do with you. Unfortunately, however personal it feels. I know, it's your mother and you're it must feel like a huge rejection. But when you really look at it from an outside perspective, these people have been infected with ideas and thoughts and and you have the good sense not to have been.

Yeah. I mean, one of the things that Joy you talked about in your book was these moments of like, oh, I didn't feel right about that, But then I was like, well, I'm being cynical or I'm being you know, a problem in some way, I'm not having a generous mindset here and the aftermath of all this has been like realizing those moments and you're like, wait, I did know, Like I was smart enough to see this stuff the whole time, and I just kept telling myself what I needed to survive because I needed the group that I mean, I ay went to a scientology school, like very very insulated. I didn't know anyone else until I happened to get a job working at a grocery store, you know, so that was my first exposure to non scientologists.

So that was your attachment those are that was that. As I was saying earlier, we were talking about what made me susceptible was attachment, which is something I've realized recently. I was always saying it was a need for family. But I had a great conversation with doctor Romney Derivstula. I don't know if you know who she is, but she's a great person to follow for you, dtr Romeny, and she was she really clarified it was it was attachment. That's what I was looking for, and that was it sounds like that was what you're attached was too, And it's a I think it's a really natural thing for us to override the things that we feel gutturally because of a deeply felt, very human neat We all need attachment. We're built for community, even from like caveman days, like they are built for community. So that need is really really valuable and really hard to push away. When your little red flags are going off, it's like your gut or your heart, what do you listen to?

Yeah, I mean, especially when you're like eight, it's like yeah, or in your case, you were raised Christian and so now you have this other Christian mindset that is being double reinforced because you learned about Christianity and childhood.

Yeah, but I mean think about your situation. You were born into this, this is all you were ever taught, and you had sense enough to extricate yourself from it once you got educated.

Like that is so brave and bold and baldy, Like you.

Have a huge, bright future ahead of you, and I want you to just start to lean into that.

You can't skip past grief.

You have to experience the loss, and it's a huge loss.

But you're not wrong, You're right.

You know you did the right thing, and you can't control what your mom's going to do, but you can go out there and live a life in honor of your good sense and in honor of what your mother's life.

Could have been.

Yeah, that's beautiful.

I think a lot about what my mom's life could have been because she joined up with Scientology when she was like nineteen or twenty or something, and it's such a vulnerable time in people's lives, and they got her and she married a guy. And you know, I got this dog the day after my mom called me and yeah, I heard you say, Chelsea, it's gonna have a dog. Yeah, that was exactly what I was like, you know what I've always wanted to that, let's get on.

You got that dog.

And they always know what's your guy's name?

His name is Poe.

Yeah, cutie. But yeah, I've been like kind of numb this last year. I really didn't This timing of this was actually quite crazy because I didn't process and even cry about this until last week because I was I was just so numbed out. You know, it felt like surreal too, but it just kind of hit me, like, you know the way that everyone when you realize how everyone on the outside has seen you this whole time, and how everyone who you thought like was judging you for being weird, was like just really concerned and scared for you, And that almost made me feel more emotional than anything else, Like whoa. And then also just realizing my dad, how like my dad is actually and like as opposed to the story I was told of who he is. I was told he's like this wonderful person and everyone looks up to him, and I was told constantly how lucky I was to have him as a dad. But meanwhile, like I would get his you know, wrath at home and stuff like that. So start of processing all of this as far as like, oh, my reality is now different, Like I went from one reality and I'm now in a different one. And it's really just been like a week And like the day after I cried about it for the first time was when I got an email from Captine. So it's quite crazy timing is that I just got a chill. This was only a week ago that I like first cried about it. Yeah, it was a year ago that my mom called me. Yeah.

The analogy Chelsea that you just gave about addiction, actually I think is so brilliant because that is so similar to the behavior of somebody that just checks out because they it's almost like a disease in your mind. You're just that's all you know how to do, and that's what they're seeking attachment in a certain way, and they don't know how to overcome it. I actually found going to alan On to be very helpful in my cult recovery stuff, like I have addiction in my family lineage that manifested in codependence and all different kinds of things in my life. But I was really surprised how going to alan On was was really really helpful because so much of the behavior is similar.

So yeah, I think there's a lot of online ex scientificogy support groups. Oh yeah, I think you should definitely look and try and find one of those if you want, I can ask Lea Remenee, she's a good friend of mine, because I think what you're experiencing is just so unique that you want other people who have also been through the same thing specific to scientology, and I think you'll find a lot of comfort there and a lot of like mindedness and that will make you feel a little bit less isolated and alone during this time. So definitely do that and also keep crying, like that's how you get this anguish and grief out. So I understand that you didn't cry for a year and now you are crying, and you're going to be crying. But it doesn't mean you're going to be crying all day every day. It means when you feel it coming on, let it out, let it move through you, and then you know an hour later you'll be doing something and you'll find yourself laughing or having a good time doing something.

But don't be scared of grieving. It's part of the process.

And Maria, will you check back in with us in a few months, Yeah, check.

Back in with us.

I'm going to get that info from Leah if she knows of any like support groups personally, and then yeah, keep in touch with us, Okay, because you know, I just want you to remember you're very lovable.

Thanks. Yeah, you're really awesome.

You're lovable. So start you're gonna write. Start writing those ten things down every morning too when you wake up. Okay, Okay, Okay, Mariah.

Big hugs, Thank you so much.

Thank You're amazing.

Maria, you are amazing.

You guys too, Thank you so much. And Chelsea like to be a public figure willing to say anything negative about scientology is so cool of you.

Oh, no problem.

Cool, Thanks guys, Bye bye bye.

Okay, we're gonna take a break and we're gonna come back and wrap up with Beth and a joy Lens.

And we're back. Wow.

That was a heavy episode, you guys, that was deep. Thank you for writing this book. This must have been really hard for you to write, was it?

No, it was it was. It felt good. It felt good to get it out, to be able to it felt good for me to be able to see it all out in a straight line, so to speak, like it wasn't all just floating around in my head and memories in my body that I couldn't attach. I didn't know how to attach one memory to the next one, and there were blanks that I had to fill in by calling former members of the group who had also gotten out and say what happened? Because I remember this? But then how did we get from point A to point D? And the amount of love and support that we were able to re engage with each other in this was a really it felt very powerful to me to be able to write this story and see it put out in a straight line, as I say, And I really hope that it can be helpful. I mean, yeah, there were moments, there were a couple of hard days, but overall, I'm just really glad to be able to have gotten it out of my body.

Yeah, I know.

Well, it's a powerful move to write a book like this, and it means you know, I think that is a perfect way to celebrate the ending of that and commemorate the fact that you I mean, it's going to help so many people, I really hope, so people who are ever come across a situation like that where you can easily get duped into believing that some random group of people has a better interest in you than your own family, and they own the people that you know and the people that you love, and and what happens there. So, yeah, thank you for your book. And it's called Dinner Vampire.

What is it? Vampire Dinners for a vampire? Sorry I don't have it right from.

The dinner Dinner for Vampires.

Called Dinner for Vampires by Bethany Joy Lenz.

Okay, Bethany, will let you go. Thank you so much.

That was lovely and really actually just I just want to tell you hearing you encourage her was really encouraging for me and inspiring and made me want to be able to I'm such a problem solver. I'm sort of like that's my ADHD right, Like I'm always I don't it's hard for me to listen. I just want to like solve the problem. So hearing you just hold that space and then just speak encouragement, encouragement, encouragement is so I was like, I want to be more like that. So thank you for giving me that today.

I needed that absolutely my pleasure.

All right, it was great talking with you both. Thank you for having me. Thank you, Bye bye bye.

Okay, guys, stand up shows that I have coming up December twenty eighth, I'm coming in New Orleans right before New Year's and then I'll be in Atlanta, Georgia on December twenty ninth.

And those are the rest of my stand up dates for this year. It's over new Tour New Year.

If you'd like advice from Chelsea, shoot us an email at Dear Chelsea podcast at gmail dot com and be sure to include your phone number. Dear Chelsea is edited and engineered by Brad Dickert executive producer Catherine Law and be sure to check out our merch at Chelseahandler dot com