Daniel and Jorge talk about how megaconstellations of satellites might spoil our view of the Universe.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield savings account through Apple Card, apply for Apple Card in the wallet app subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch, Member FDIC terms and more at applecard dot com. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. How is US Dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digesters to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit us dairy dot COM's Last Sustainability to learn more.
Our iHeartRadio Music Festival presented by Capital One coming back to Las Vegas twenty first a weekend full of superstar performances a Sap, Rocky Banks, Sean Came, Meloka, Bail Tojika Zulia When Stefani Holier, Keith Urban, New Kids on the Block, Paramore, Shaboozy, The Black Crows, The Weekend, Thomas Red, Victoria Monette, Coldplay Is, Chris Martin and Moore stream Live Holy on Hulu and get It tigests to be there at AXS dot com.
Hi, I'm David Eagleman from the podcast Inner Cosmos, which recently hit the number one science podcast in America. I mean neuroscientists at Stanford and I've spent my career exploring the three pound universe in our heads.
Join me weekly to explore the relationship.
Between your brain and your life.
Because the more we know about what's running under the hood, bet or we can steer our lives. Listen to Inner Cosmos with David Eagleman on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hi, it's Jorge and Daniel here. And this holiday season, if you're looking for a gift for yourself, for a friend, or for your family, why not get him the gift of answers about the Universe.
So check out our new book frequently ask questions about the Universe. You can find details at universe faq dot com.
Thanks for supporting the podcast.
Happy holidays everyone.
Hey Daniel, what's your favorite thing about going camping?
Oh?
There's so much to love, you know. I really enjoy being out in nature. I like taking a break from our urban routines. But I guess mostly I love being out there under the dark skies. Hmmm.
I thought you would say s'mores, because you know, you're smashing two kinds of candy together and you're a particle physicist.
The confection collider. Yeah, that's also delicious.
No, you're right. I think you know. Being out in the night sky is amazing, right, reminds you of all the amazing stuff that's out there.
Yeah, and it feels like you kind of have to get further and further away from civilization to find those really good dark skies where you can see thousands and thousands of stars.
It's pretty gorgeous.
How about you? What's your favorite thing about camping other than s'mores?
I like sleeping in my own bed.
What you bring your own bed camping?
No, but when I go camping. It really makes me appreciate sleeping in my own bed, so you know, overall improves my quality of life. I guess that puts us to sleep. I am horehand made cartoonist and the creator of PhD comics.
Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist and a professor of physics that you see Irvine, and I can no longer sleep comfortably on the ground.
You cannot, oh, Unlike your other physicists ancestors.
Unlike twenty year old Daniel, who's happy to sleep on a concrete floor or the ground anywhere under the stars. I could get a good night's sleep anywhere these days. I just need my own bed.
What do you do when you go camping?
Then?
I just don't sleep very well.
I don't sleep at all camping. That's why you stay up all night watching the stars. So it all works out.
There's no point going in the tent. We're not getting any sleep anyway, so let's just stay up and eat more s'mores.
It's But then do you walk to your car and sleep in your car?
I just wait and sleep it all back when I get home.
But welcome to our podcast. Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe a production of iHeartRadio.
In which we feed you the delicious combination of knowledge and confusion smushed together into an intellectual s'more. We dive into the squishy heart of everything that humanity doesn't know about this incredible universe. We find ourselves in how big it is, where it ends, when it might end, how it started, what it's all made out of, and what but it all means. We surround that with delicious layers of chocolate and little bits of understanding that we have gleaned in our centuries or millennia of probing this universe and explain all of it to you.
Are you especially hungry today, Daniel, or are you just looking forward to Halloween?
I'm thinking about my next camping trip and how that's moore is really going to get me through the night.
And which one is confusion? Is it marshmallow or chocolate? And which one is knowledge?
I think confusion is definitely marshmallow, because you know, it gets pretty sticky. You can dive into the heart of it and it just sort of covers everything, and once you start asking questions, you feel like, wow, we're maybe confused about everything, the same way that marshmallow never really gets off anything. Once it's sticks to you.
Right, and once it catches fire, it's all over. You might as well throw the whole thing in the trash.
I wish that confusion was as delicious toasted as marshmallows are.
And what's the cracker is the cracker of funding I guess to hold it all together and squeeze things out.
That's right, Thank you funding agencies for being the gramd cracker in this terribly, terribly tortured analogy.
Let's put that analogy to rest. Let's eat it up. But yeah, it is a big and beautiful universe that's out there. There's a lot for us to see and explore and learn from only if we can see it, and that might be changing soon.
That's right. So much about the nature of the universe comes just from information that has arrived here on Earth from the cosmos. Those brave little photons that have been flying through the universe for millions or sometimes billions of years have revealed to us the nature of things out there, the grand scope of it all, the incredible majesty of galaxies and galactic clusters and even the Big Bang. We could learn none of that if we couldn't see out there in the night sky. As we build better and better telescopes and new kinds of ways to observe the night sky, we learn more and more about this information that's washing over us, but only if we can still see it.
Yeah, it's pretty amazing to think that we've learned so much just floating in this little rock in one corner of the galaxy, which is in one corner of the universe. You know, it's sort of like, you know, learning about the whole world by floating on little raft in the middle of the ocean, right, Like, how much would you be able to piece together about how the whole world works?
Yeah, Or if you like lived in a lighthouse and never left, but you had a bunch of powerful telescopes and all you could do was spying people and look out your windows. It's incredible, You're right, how much we have learned about the nature of things without going anywhere. Really. I mean, we've sent a few robots just around our neighborhood, but we have a pretty good sense for the shape of the galaxy and even much much larger objects without ever having been there ourselves, of course, And all of that relies on being able to see the night sky, the fact that the universe is mostly transparent and that information can travel all the way through the cosmos and get to us.
Yeah, you may get sound like science is some kind of stalker, Like we're stalking the universe. Maybe are we going to get arrested by the cosmic police.
I don't know how much intellectual privacy rights the universe has, you know. I think it's signed the terms of use, and so it basically gave away all its.
Rights, right right, sitting out there naked basically, right. I mean it's not our fault that we can't look away.
That's right. We're deep inside of it. I mean it swallowed us, and so what can you expect? You know? Yeah, it's like that movie Inner Space, you know, where they shrink down and they're flying around inside that body.
In this case, I am Dennis Clay.
I guess somebody's got to have a chin.
But yeah, it is a pretty big and wonderful universe, and it all depends on our view of it. Without our view of it, we we would be able to tell very little about the universe, Like if our planet was covered in dense clouds, or if we were in a far off corner of the galaxy with nothing around us, we would be pretty ignorant about what's going on.
Yeah, we are pretty lucky that the universe is mostly transparent, that we're not sitting inside of a huge dust cloud, and that the solar wind, for example, is mostly invisible, that that information mostly gets to us. But you know what if it couldn't. And you know, sometimes when you're standing outside and looking up at the stars, you're excited because you see stars, but sometimes you see something else, like maybe you see a plane go by, or even more excited, you see the space station go by, or some really high up satellite flowed by. That also feels exciting sometimes, Oh yeah, yeah, because you're seeing like a bit of human technology. You're like, wow, look we are out there in space. That's cool. But also there's another side of that.
Yeah, leave it to humans to ruin everything basically as usual. Even the nice sky. We're going to ruin that soon.
That's right, because you know, you look at at a nice sky, you see one satellite go by, No big deal, right, Well, what if there are two satellites, or ten satellites, or tens of thousands of satellites? It might interfere with your ability to see what's out there past our neighborhood, deep deep in the universe to answer some of our basic questions.
Yeah, be bad for science, but good for some fun nighttime viewing. Then you make it sound pretty exciting to see a whole bunch of shooting stars going on at the same time.
Sometimes when I'm out with my kids, they're more excited to see satellites than to see stars, because you know, the stars just sort of sit there and the satellite so look that one's moving or blinking or doing something. So I get it why they're more exciting. But you know, the real deep mysteries in the universe, of course, are contained in the light from stars and other crazy things.
And secretly you're hoping maybe that is the UFO that we've been waiting for.
That's right, I've been signaling them desperately with my campfire. Why can't anybody see that?
Yeah, what are you doing sending smoke signals to the aliens? But yeah, it does seem to be an increasing problem, this idea that there are more and more space man made space objects out in the night sky. And so today on the program, we'll be asking the question, how will starlink affect astronomy? Wow, it seems like astronomy can be spoiled.
It can be spoiled. It's sort of delicate, and this is something we went through years ago when we had this invention of LED lights, which made lighting much brighter and more efficient and cheaper. And then people started installing LED lights everywhere, and all of a sudden there was a lot more light pollution than there was before. And you know, if there's lights nearby, then it makes it harder to observe the night sky. And astronomers spoke up and they were like, hey, could we get some like shielding on those lights or could we limit them to one frequency? And we were able to adjust and to redesign those lights so they mostly pointed down and they were mostly yellow instead of being broad pant and white, and we were able to sort of save astronomy. But this isn't the first time that, you know, consumer technology has sort of stumbled into the otherwise pristine night sky and almost munged it up.
Wow, I didn't know that. So as humans, our civilization has gone brighter and brighter at night.
Oh yes, if you went back to the fifteen hundreds, for example, it wouldn't be that hard to find a dark night sky, Like our cities are much much brighter than they were hundreds of years ago or even one hundred years ago or fifty years ago, and that just has to do with access to power and the cheapness and the brightness of our light sources.
So this idea that starlink might affect astronomy. Starlink is some sort of satellite plan.
Right when you think of a satellite, you probably think of like a single object, you know, a big piece of technology floating in space. But there's this new idea to launch constellations of satellites that have hundreds, sometimes even thousands of little parts that are floating out there in space. And so this is sort of a brand new idea and people are excited about for all sorts of applications, but it has downsides, and astronomers are very concerned that the night sky might just be filled with satellites in the future, making it maybe impossible to learn secrets of the universe.
Oh man, it's like you're blocking the view. Get out of the way.
Yeah, exactly. This is something that's for all humanity, that all humans have enjoyed looking up at the night sky, and as we develop our technology, we need to make sure that we're approaching this in a sensible way, that we have like regulations and rules in place so that individuals can't spoil it for the whole species humans.
This is why we can't have nice things or no nice things either. But yeah, we were one drying how many people out there a new this idea of giant mega satellite constellations otherwise known as starlink is one name for it, and so we were wondering how many people knew about them and how they might affect astronomy. So Daniel went out there into the internet to ask people this question.
So thanks to everybody who's willing to participate. For those of you who've been listening to the podcast for years but never phoned in, please feel welcome. No pressure, of course, but we'd like to hear your voice on the podcast, so please write me to questions at Danielanjorge dot com.
Think about it for a second, what do you think putting thousands of satellites up into the sky will do to astronomy? Here's what people have to say.
Most likely, if they will pass in the field of view of a telescope. People will have to affect with something.
I believe that the Starlink project will affect astronomy by completely changing our visual perspective on space.
It's gonna add man.
Made light, and we're going to need to remap what we can visually see from Earth into outer space.
Starlink is a program from SpaceX to launch a.
Lot of Internet satellites, which I think we already know that it's going to make it a lot hirer to study stars and.
Stuff very poorly.
I saw a train of twenty nine Starlink satellites the other night, and I can't imagine if my telescope were aimed directly in that line.
I think there's a lott of worry about how many satellites they want to put up and how it totally tips the scales in terms of space to breed, maybe a point we can never come back from.
Starlink has thousands of small satellites, all giving off radio waves, so they might interfere with ground based observations, perhaps creating the need for more space telescopes.
All right, not a good outlooking for a.
Star, that's right, But this is something people are definitely aware of right, this is not a situation where people have no idea what we're talking about. This has definitely been in the public conversation.
Yeah. Interesting, Yeah, nobody here said what is starlink? Which is honestly what my answer would have been. It's kind of a new idea, and I know it's been in the data a lot because people like Elon Musk are into it or are are applying for it in Amazon as well. So maybe step us through this, Daniel, what is starlink and what is a mega constellation of satellites?
Starlink is an example of mega constellations where instead of having one or two or maybe even ten, like a small number of very specialized, very expensive satellites, instead you mass produce a bunch of smaller satellites so that it's cheaper, so you take advantage of the economy of scale, and instead of having just a few up there, you launch thousands or tens of thousands. And one application of this is, for example, to provide internet coverage. There are lots of places in the world, especially poor areas and rural areas, where it's just not economically feasible or commercially attractive to run fiber optics or even copper cables to all the homes, and so to get Internet coverage to those folks, it's attractive to build a satellite Internet system where the information gets beamed to space and then down to a dish on your house.
Wow, so you would be signing up for space Internet, not just Internet, but like space Internet.
Yeah, space Internet exactly, and just like you get satellite TV. But that's one directional, right, you were getting information beamed down to you from a satellite. This is too directional. You download a picture on Facebook and it goes to a satellite and down to your house and you're at a comment on that picture. It goes back up to the satellite and then back down to your internet service provider, and so this is two way communication with a satellite in order to get Internet.
Well, so your selfie would go out into space and back and maybe back again. Right, it would bounce down on Earth and space.
That's right, And it doesn't only just hit the satellite, right. Your beam is sort of broad, so the satellite picks it up, but it also goes past the satellite out into deep space. So any selfie you said via satellite internet is also going to the aliens. So think about that, and next time you send a you know, racy photo to your friends via satellite internet, you're speaking for the whole human race there people.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, please make it look good. But I guess one question is, like, you know, we have cell phone towers. Are you saying like we don't have cell phone coverage everywhere? It sort of seems like we have a lot of cell phone coverage.
That's true, we do have pretty good coverage at least in the US and a lot of the Western world for cell phone towers. This is sort of an alternative approach. I think there are lots of places where we don't have coverage, and so this would give you, you know, internet access rather than just cellular service.
All right, So then and you said there are small satellites. How small are we talking about? Is it like LaunchBox size, like a palm size? How big are these satellites.
I think they're about the size of a bed, for example, like a mattress. But they're pretty small, you know, they're like five hundred pounds or two hundred and fifty kilos each. And the idea is not just that you could mass produce them, but that they could fly in low Earth orbit. You know, one issue with satellite internet is the latency. Most of the satellite internet systems that we have right now are in geosynchronous orbit, so single satellite is really far up there, but it sort of floats over the same patch of Earth all the time, and so it's sort of like always there in the sky above you, but they're far away. Like geosynchronous orbit means you're like thirty five thousand kilometers up there, and it takes a little while for the light to go all the way up to the satellite and back. If instead you had satellites in low Earth orbit, like five hundred kilometers, it'd be much faster. But the problem is that it's very complicated to have them be geosynchronous, and so essentially what you need instead of having a few satellites that are fixed, you need like a big constellation of satellites so they can pass the signals back and forth to each other. You have like a whole network of satellites up there in space.
So geosynchronous means like it's always above the same spot on Earth all the time. But with these, because there's lower in orbit, they would be basically flying around all the time.
That's right, a single one would be passing over the Earth. They do an orbiting around ninety minutes, and so if you have like a ninety minute Internet session, you're not always talking to the same satellite. You're getting passed from satellite to satellite, and so to have full coverage you need a lot of these satellites. Also, each one, because it's lower down, can't see as much of the Earth as like a smaller patch that it covers, so you need more of them in order to cover the whole Earth.
And didn't know they were so big, as big as a mattress. Does that mean that you would have a mattress ready when you go space camping.
I don't know how comfortable they are, but yeah.
The good thing in space is they don't need to be that comfortable. So this is like a real thing, right, Like people are planning to make these mattress sized and thousands of these satellites and launch them into space soon.
Right, Oh, it's a real thing. It's already up there. They launched the first ones in twenty nineteen, and so currently they have sixteen hundred of these satellites already up there fl delivering satellite Internet. The beta service is available in a bunch of countries, but you know, there are plans for a lot more, and we've already seen some of the sort of negative effects of them, and people are worried about what happens if this goes big, Like we have sixteen hundred satellites now, but Starlink has approved to have twelve thousand satellites up there, and they plan to go for thirty thousand satellites.
And that's just one company, right or like one conglomerate that's doing it. Other companies have other plants.
That's right as usual. Jeff Bezos has his own plan for an Amazon based one called one Web. And so you know, people project that we could have like one hundred thousand of these micro satellites up in low Earth orbit by the end of the decade. And people are wondering, like, what will the night sky look like if it's filled with these satellites?
Whoa, it could look like a basically like a like a disco, like you're in a nightclub with all these lights moving, flashing around everywhere.
Exactly, And if you want to see out past low Earth orbit and deep into the cosmos to learn the secrets of nature. That could be a problem.
Yike might actually block astronomy and our search for answers in the universe. So let's get into that. But first let's take a quick break.
With big wireless providers, what you see is never what you get. Somewhere between the store and your first month's bill, the price, your thoughts you were paying magically skyrockets. With mint Mobile, You'll never have to worry about gotcha's ever again. When Mint Mobile says fifteen dollars a month for a three month plan, they really mean it. I've used mint Mobile and the call quality is always so crisp and so clear. I can recommend it to you, So say bye bye to your overpriced wireless plans, jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages. You can use your own phone with any Mint Mobile plan and bring your phone number along with your existing contacts. So dit your overpriced wireless with mint Mobiles deal and get three months a premium wireless service for fifteen bucks a month. To get this new customer offer and your new three month premium wireless plan for just fifteen bucks a month month, go to mintmobile dot com slash universe that's mintmobile dot com slash universe. Cut your wireless build to fifteen bucks a month. At mintmobile dot com slash Universe, forty five dollars upfront payment required equivalent to fifteen dollars per month new customers on first three month plan only speeds slower about forty gigabytes on unlimited plan. Additional taxi speeds and restrictions apply. See mint mobile for details.
AI might be the most important new computer technology ever. It's storming every industry and literally billions of dollars are being invested, so buckle up. The problem is that AI needs a lot of speed and processing power, So how do you compete without cost spiraling out of control. It's time to upgrade to the next generation of the cloud. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure or OCI. OCI is a single platform for your infrastructure, database, application development, and AI needs. OCI has forty eight times the bandwidth of other clouds, offers one consistent price instead of variable regional pricing, and of course nobody does data better than Oracle. So now you can train your AI models at twice the speed and less than half the cost of other clouds. If you want to do more and spend less, like Uber eight by eight and Data Bricks Mosaic. Take a free test drive of OCI at Oracle dot com slash strategic. That's Oracle dot com slash Strategic Oracle dot com slash Strategic.
If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high yield savings account through Applecard, apply for Applecard in the wallet app, subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Applecard owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch, Member FDIC terms and more at applecard dot com. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth or enjoy a rich spoonful of Greek yogurt, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact of each and every bite. But the people in the dairy industry are US. Dairy has set themselves some m vicious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste conserve natural resources and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times the same water cools the milk, cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit us dairy dot com slash sustainability to learn more.
All right, we're talking about mega constellations of satellites. So humans as always have to ruin everything. So we're going to ruin the night sky now, and we're going to put up all these thousands and thousands of satellites out in low earth orbit to give people better access to the Internet. I guess it's sort of a trade off here, right, That's.
Right, you know, there are definitely positives, and with every technology there are unintended consequences. But it is important to bring Internet access to everybody. You know, there are lots of folks out there that just cannot get reliable Internet, and it's important. It's a part of being part of the modern world. And you know, for safety issues if you're in the wilderness, to get internet for rescue. So there's a lot of advantages to having accessible Internet.
Like if you're in the middle of the ocean, that would be hard to have a zoom.
Call that's right, or you know, order your Amazon Prime. You know, I need some fresh water? Can you deliver it? Peace?
And then it gets deployed from a drone in space? Is that the idea? Is that the ultimate goal?
I'm sure there's a committee at Amazon working on that exact thing.
Yeah, So it's a big equity issues to give every human sort of access to all of the knowledge and all of the data and all of the news that's happening in the world right now, so that nobody gets left behind. But unfortunately it might have some negative consequences for science. It's specifically astronomy, because astronomy we depends on looking at the night sky, and so if there's a bunch of satellites flying in front of you, it's going to be hard to do that.
Yeah, and we've already seen this happen astronomers CD satellites crossing the path of their telescopes. We've always had satellites up there. But if we're going to rapidly increase the number of satellites, then it's going to become a bigger and bigger problem. And so you see all these examples on the Internet of beautiful satellite pictures of deep space, and then there's just these like streaks of satellites in a streetline going across it, spoiling the view. It's like photo bombing exactly, satellite bombing the pictures. And these things can be much more reflective than the other satellites because they're in lower Earth orbit, right, so they're much closer.
Does that make them brighter or just you know, just more annoying.
Yeah, it makes them brighter, But mostly it's an issue of number. These things are eventually going to outsign all the stars in the sky.
Yeah, because I guess these satellites they don't actually glow. It's not like they have a flashlight pointed at the Earth. It's just that they don't have any sort of like becon or anything, but you can see them because they're reflecting the light from the sun.
Things out in space. It's a little counterintuitive struggle to stay cool right in space, it's very important that you don't overheat, and like Fryer electronics, and you might think, oh, well, space is super cold, right, that's true, but also space is a vacuum, and vacuum is an insulator. So it's actually harder sometimes to get rid of your heat in space because you're not surrounded by air that can suck that heat away. Right, There's no like wind in space to steal your heat, and so you need to stay cold. And one way to stay cold, so your electronics work is to be reflective rather than absorptive. So they design these things to reflect sunlight rather than absorb it, and so basically they act almost like mirrors. You know, there's parts of these satellites that are very reflective, and when the sun shines on them, they light up just like the moon does.
Interesting, is that why you always see satellites and spacecraft sort of like wrap them in aluminum foil. Is that the reason.
That's one reason. Yeah, there's lots of reasons. You want to protect it also from other kinds of radiation that can be stopped by foil. But in general, you want your stuff to be reflective in order to stay cool, except for the solar panels. The solar panels are black because you want them to absorb all the light. But even like the other side of the solar panels tend to be bright so that they can reflect away in the unwonted heat.
I thought maybe just Toperworth technology hadn't made it to satellites yet, but yeah, So the main mom is that they have to be reflecting, and they reflect light, and that's going to pollute our view of the universe.
Yeah, and it's especially bad it's sort of sunrise and sunset because of the angle of the satellites. When the sun goes down and the satellites are sort of just over the horizon, then the sun hits them and goes right towards your eyes. And so in the deep, deep part of the night, when our part of the Earth is in shadow, it's not as bad a problem. They'rel sort of fewer of these satellites can sort of see the sun and see where you are. But it's very bad at twilight and also at dawn, which is where a lot of really important observing happens.
Hmm.
Interesting, But couldn't they like, aren't solar panels dark. Couldn't they just wrap them in solar panels and that would make them both dark and you know, get getting more more energy for their operation.
Solar panels are dark, absolutely, but you can't have the whole thing wrapped in solar panels. You need part of it have antennas, right, You need to be able to communicate with it. And it's actually those antennas that are the brightest parts of them that are really the most reflective, that have these antenna arrays to communicate with ground stations on Earth. That's the point of the satellite. And then have these other little parabolic antennas so they can talk to each other. And so they're just sort of functional parts of the satellite. You know, we'll talk later about things they can do to mitigate the reflectivity of these satellites. But you can't just have all be one big solar panel.
Well, it sounds pretty serious. I mean, you said soon there will be as many satellites are there are visible stars in the night sky. It's like when you look out, most of the things you'll see are satellites.
Yeah, And I think people will also be surprised to realize how few stars you can see in the night sky. When you look up in the night sky, even in the darkest, darkest nights, in the depths of the woods, you only really see like five thousand, maybe ten thousand stars. It seems like an overwhelming number. It's really not that big. And then when you go into the cities, really it's just down to a few hundreds or even dozens. If you're in a bright city.
Or one in Los Angeles.
Yes, yeah, you can see any at all. And so at some point, if we have thousands of satellites up there, then they really are going to arrival the number of stars that you can see. And it's bad for people who enjoy seeing the sky. It's bad for you know, cultures for whom stars are an important part of their storytelling or their history. But it's also really bad for astronomers who are very, very sensitive to small amounts of light. We have, for example, surveys that are scanning the sky constantly looking for changes. What's changing in the night sky, our stars getting brighter and dimmer, are scars disappearing. These are very important for understanding the dynamics of the universe, and it's much harder to do if things are changing because satellites are whizzing in front of you all the time.
I guess is that mostly the problem is the photo bombing. It's like seeing things that you think is the star but does not actually a star. Is that the main problem or does it actually sort of affect the measurement of regular stars.
It's both, and in one hand it blocks things, right if there's a satellite there, you can't see behind it, but also it affects the rest of the image. Satellite imaging is very sensitive and it's adaptive, and so if you have a very bright source, it can sort of saturate it. It changes the whole range. It's like when you take a picture with your camera. If something is back lit, if the sun is behind you, then you really can't see the person. And that's because your camera is adjusted because it wants to get all the different range, the brightest and the darkest, and so then the darkest things don't come out very well. So it's sort of like if somebody's shining a flashlight in your face, right, you can't see the night sky at all. And so that's a difficulty for astronomical technology. And also astronomical images don't use seems technology like in your phone. They use something else called a CCD, which is much more sensitive to very small amounts of light. But it also has a disadvantage in that, you know, all the pixels in a row are sort of linked together. CCD stands or charge couple device, and it reads it out by passing the information down the line. The short version of the story is, if you overwhelm a single pixel, it can cause blooming, which lights up an entire strip of pixels. And so it doesn't just overwhelm the part of the image you're in, it can also ruin the rest of the image.
Yeah, because you know, I was thinking, like, if we know where all the satellites are, even if there are in the thousands, you could still have them in a database so you can maybe account for them when you're doing astronomy. But you're saying, it's just like it just causes general light pollution and it oversaturates all of our sensors.
Yeah, and they've done some studies. You know, they're not just whining about it. The astronomy community has gotten together a couple of times and put out these careful reports analyzing the impact of these mega constellations, both the ones we have now and the ones that are planned in the future, and they anticipate that it could ruin like thirty to forty percent of all astronomical exposures. That's like a huge amount.
Oh my god, that's huge. That's a lot of science.
That's a lot of science. Imagine that you're some young astronomer and you've just gotten time on a very important ground based telescope and it's ruined. You know, you already have to gamble with the clouds, and now you have to gamble with the clouds and Elon Musk's space.
Toys and Jeff Bezos space mattresses. Yeah, it's not just signs that's been affected. I mean more concerning is that it might like affect the safety of the human race.
Yeah, we're talking about putting a lot of objects up there in orbit, and we already have kind of a lot of stuff out there. I mean, there are already like four thousand or so satellites in Low Earth orbit, and many more and other orbits, and not all of these things are operationally anymore, right, not like everything we build works forever. So we have a whole episode about this. It's called space junk, just like bits of rocket or broken satellites that are just sort of floating out there in space, cluttering things up. And it's a real danger that if you get too many of these things, they could just like crash into each other and fill space with debris, making it like unpassable.
Right, And it's like debris going at thirty thousand miles per hour, right.
Yeah, it's very fast moving stuff. And because it's very fast moving, it can lead to this sort of cascade effect, like two things collide and they create like thousands or even tens of thousands of high speed bits of debris which collide with other things, and then pretty soon all of space is just filled with garbage. It's like if one person slams on their brakes on the freeway very high speed, that causes an accident and then you can get like a thousand car pile up right.
Wow. Yeah, So if you put like tens of thousands of satellites up there and they all crashing to each other in a chain reaction, then we could basically cover the whole Earth in like junk.
Yeah, and not just cover the Earth Like it's not such a problem. If they fall out of orbit, that's actually okay because when they go into the atmosphere, they tend to burn up and they don't hit the surface, so it's not really a danger to humanity. But if they're still floating up there, that's the real problem, because if low earth orbit is filled with junk, it makes it impossible to send a rocket up there because it's just going to get pelted. Right, It's like we have a force field that's the opposite direction that prevents us from leaving. It's like we built a prison and trapped ourselves inside of it.
Wow, that would be so tragic and ironic for the human.
Race, it would be, And so you need to be really careful. And currently there's a whole office where people monitor satellite near missus and try to get them to avoid each other, and they like fire their rockets to move higher or lower out of each other's way. But that gets exponentially more complicated as you get more satellites, and so now we're talking about like a hundred thousand and more satellites up there. It just seems almost inevitable that something's going to go wrong.
Yeah. Well, obviously the solution is to make them out of mattresses, and not just the size of mattresses, and so then they'll just bounce off each other.
Well, let's just make them out of marshmallows, right, because then they get toasted.
Then the sun is gonna yeah, it's gonna start making them catch on fire.
Sun toasted space marshmallows. I mean, who doesn't want one of those. Then you're on a camping trip. You just hold out your cracker and marshmallows land right on it.
Yeah, there you go. Well, if they make it through the atmosphere.
And you know, I was joking about how they burn up when they enter the atmosphere, and that's good because we don't want them to like hit buildings or smash on people. But there's another factor there, which is that these satellites have a bunch of heavy metals in them, and so if you have a lot of them and they're burning up when they enter the atmosphere, you're sort of polluting the upper atmosphere with a bunch of heavy metals, and we don't really know what that means. Like, if you inject a huge amount of aluminum, even in vapor form, into the upper atmosphere, what happens. It's like a geoengineering experiment.
WHOA, it's like wrapping the Earth in aluminum foil, yeah, or.
Something else, right, Like there's this project where they injected the upper atmosphere with all of these copper needles to see if it would change the weather. And you know that didn't go very well, and so who knows what would happen Even if you managed to get like the broken satellites to deorbit, to sort of fall into the atmosphere and burn up. Then who knows what would happen if you pollute the upper atmosphere with all this aluminum and other heavy metals.
It is the final frontier space for human pollution. It might not just a better our ability to travel into space safely, but it might actually like affect our ability to see things coming at us that might kill us.
One of the fields of astronomy that would be most dramatically affected are the people who look for near Earth objects. So if you are on the lookout for a rock that's heading towards the Earth that might, for example, kill us all. Then you can only spot it when it reflects sunlight. Right, these rocks are not glowing like stars, and so we look for these things and we look for the right moment when they shine their light at us. And sometimes these things, if they're near the sun or coming from the direction of the sun, they can be very hard to spot because of the sun. And so just after the sun dips over the horizon it's the best time to see these things. But if space is filled with a bunch of reflective stuff which is also shining back at you at the same moment, these twilight and dawn moments, then we're basically blind in those directions, and it might be impossible to see something coming at us.
Wow, it'd be like a lot of noise, right, like false nine when one calls or something like everyone called nine to one to prank them. Then you might miss the really important calls.
Right, yeah, exactly. Or it's like in top Gun, you know, when every fighter jet is looking to like come out of the sun because it's a blind spot for the other pilots. That's our blind spot. And so if we can no longer look near the sun. Then it becomes an even bigger blind spot, and that's pretty dangerous.
Like super danger right. It might mean the end of the human race if we don't catch that asteroid.
And I don't know how you feel about it, but I think that's kind of a big deal.
It's a bigger deal than it'smores, for sure.
And it's not just astronomers enjoying the night sky, and you know, other cultures who use it for storytelling and avoiding all of this pollution of the upper atmosphere. It's in general just sort of brightening the night sky. Even if you're not like training a telescope on one particular spot to see a galaxy. In general, it's just going to sort of like brighten everything, so like the overall brightness of the sky will go up, and that'll make it harder to see anything. You know. The reason that you see stars at night and not during the day, they're there during the day, you just don't see them because the sky is so bright. So imagine making the whole night sky a little bit brighter, stars and galaxies will literally disappear.
I thought you were going to say it's going to make it harder to sleep at night.
Let's mostly just stress and anxiety.
Yeah, we do need satellites for that exactly.
We got that covered already.
Yeah, and it's not just Elon Musk, you said. Amazon also has one called one Web as well.
And there are other folks. And one real problem is that there are very few laws, Like, there are no regulations limiting the reflectivity of satellites, So there's nothing preventing anybody from launching a bunch of these satellites and having them up there and being super dup or bright.
Doesn't the Space Force get involved at that point?
You mean the Netflix show or the actual New Branch.
I mean like the actual Space Force people.
Yeah, I think they're too busy making the uniforms look less like Nazis.
All right, well, let's get into what we could do about this light pollution. This maya constellation satellite crowding in the night sky. Is there anything we can do about it to prevent it affecting astronomy and our ability to see asteroids and our our ability to really enjoy the beautiful universe that's out there for us to see. So let's get into that. But first, let's take another quick break.
When you pop up piece of cheese into your mouth, or enjoy a rich spoonful of Greek yogurt. You're probably not thinking about the environmental impact of each and every bite, but the people in the dairy industry are. US Dairy has set themselves some ambitious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times the same water cools the milk, cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US dairy tackling greenhouse gases. Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneuver into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit US Dairy dot com Slash Sustainability to learn more.
Our iHeartRadio Muse Success presented by Capitol One coming back to Las Vegas two nights and twenty first on one stage, stream live only on a weekend full of superstar performances, never seen before, collaborations, and once in a lifetime artist moments you'll have to see to believe. Tickets are on sale now at axcess dot com. Don't miss Asap Rocky Big Sean, Camilakabli Dualipa, When Stefani Palsy, Hosiery Thurban, New Kids on the Block, Paramore, The Chaboozie, The Black Crows.
The Weekend, Thomas Rhett, Victoria Monet, a special performance by Coldplay's Chris Martin, and more.
Okay, your tickets to be there now.
At axcess dot com.
Guess what, Mango?
What's that?
Will?
So?
iHeart is giving us a whole minute to promote our podcast, Part time Genius.
I know.
That's why I spent my whole week composing a haikup for the occasion. It's about my emotional journey in podcasting over the last seven years, and it's called Earthquake House.
Mega Mango, I'm going to cut you off right there, Why don't we just tell people about our show instead?
Yeah, that's a better idea. So every week on Part Time Genius, we feed our curiosity by answering the world's most important questions, things like when did America start dialing nine to one?
One?
Is William Shatner's best acting work in Esperanto?
Also?
What happened to Esperanto? Plus we cover questions like how Chinese is your Chinese food? How do dollar stores stay in business? And of course is there an Illuminati of cheese?
There absolutely is, and we are risking our lives by talking about it. But if you love mind blowing facts, incredible history, and really bad jokes, make your brains happy and tune into Part Time Genius.
Listen to Part Time Genius on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcast.
Hi everyone, it's me Katie Kuric. If you follow me on social media, you know I love to cook, or at least try, especially alongside some of my favorite chefs and foodies like Benny Blanco, Jake Cohen, Lighty Hoyke, Alison Roman, and of course Ina Garten and Martha Stewart. So I started a free newsletter called Good Taste that comes out every Thursday, and it's serving up recipes that will make your mouth water. Think a candied bacon, bloody mary tacos with cabbage slaw, curry cauliflower with almonds and mit, and cherry slab pie with vanilla ice cream to top it all off. I mean, young, I'm getting hungry. But if you're not sold yet, we also have kitchen tips like a fool proof way to grill the perfect burger and must have products like the best cast iron skillet. To feel like a chef in your own kitchen. All you need to do is sign up at Katiecuric dot com slash good Taste. That's k A t I E c o U r ic dot com slash good Taste. I promise your taste buds will be happy you did.
All right, we are putting all the Laman billionaires today, Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk. They have plans to fill the sky with thousands and thousands and thousands of mini satellites, which might affect our ability to look out into the universe and learn from it and also appreciate its beauty.
That's right, and astronomers have come together and reached out to these companies and tried to describe to them the impact and the importance of astronomy and preserving our dark skies. So there's been a lot of discussions, and it's not like these tech entrepreneurs are totally ignoring it. They understand, they get it. Elon Musk said, quote, I am confident that we will not cause any impact whatsoever in astronomical discoveries zero and will take corrective action if it's above zero.
That's not super comforting. First of all, I don't know if I take Elon Musk at this word. And second, well, what if it's too late to take corrective action? You know, like what if we fill space with junk and then we can't do anything about it. Is he going to personally go up there with a little.
Broom and clean up his own mess? Yeah?
Yeah, clean up his own debris.
I don't know, But at least it's better than if he just shrugged it up and ignored them. You know, making the right noises is better than making the wrong noises, I guess, but you're right. It's something we need to discuss now before space gets very, very filled with these constellations.
Do you think it's in his budget, like, you know, oops, I was wrong. Let's paint it, clean this up.
As long as it costs less than two hundred billion, then yeah, he can afford it.
You know.
There you go.
But they have done some things. I mean, they have been already responsive and they are working to reduce the impact of all their satellites on astronomy. The first thing they did was similar to your idea, which is they just tried to make these things darker. They're like, well, let's try to make each satellite less reflective. They introduced a new version of their satellite called dark Sat, where they basically painted it with this anti reflective coating. So these phased antenna arraysed and the parts that communicate with the ground, instead of being very reflective, they made them dark and very absorptive.
Does that help?
It helps a bit. I mean it makes them about half as bright, which is good. The problem is that then then the satellite doesn't really work because it absorbs too much heat, and then it can't really function as intended, and so it only half solves the problem, but it sort of breaks the satellite from the commercial aspect, so it wasn't really a workable solution.
What else can they do?
Well, then they have another idea, which is instead of painting it directly with an anti reflective coating, they're putting like a visor on it, like a shade, and so this has the same effect. It's like a black shade, but it deploys and it's a little bit distant from the antenna, so it's not actually like heating up the antenna itself, and it just blocks the sunlight at the right moment so it doesn't reflect back onto the Earth parasol. Yeah, like a little parasol, or like that flap in your car. You know that you can pull down to block the sun and you put it back up when you don't need it. So this is something that can deploy just the right moment to avoid those reflections at dawn and at dusk.
Interesting, but would you point it at the sun like to block the sun or would you point it at the Earth so it doesn't you know, the light doesn't go onto Earth.
You position it between the sun and the most reflective parts of the satellite, and then at such an angle that any sunlight that does hit it goes off into space rather than down to Earth. So it basically redirects the sunlight so it doesn't bounce off the satellite and down to Earth. It goes out into space instead.
But I imagined that's kind of expensive, right, because then the satellite has to be actively like moving this visor, this blocker all the time, and that cause energy.
Yeah, it costs energy, and it costs more money, but that seems to be something they're willing to do. They're also playing lots of games with the positioning of the satellite. Like one of the most reflective parts of the satellite is the solar array. So the satellite itself is like you know, the size of a bed, it's like one meter by two meters, But then it has this solar power array which is like ten meters long, and it's very reflective. And so if that solar array is positioned in such a way that reflects back down to the Earth, it's like incredibly bright. And so they've rearranged the sort of the direction of the solar array so that it's behind the satellite. It catches sun, but it's shielded from the Earth by the satellite chassis itself, so that also improves the reflectivity.
Interesting, and it couldn't be also like maybe angle the satellite in certain times in certain ways so that it's less reflective, or would that interfere with like pointing the intent and stuff.
That's a great idea, and that's what they're doing. They're sort of trying to angle the satellite so the sun comes on the knife's edge rather than on the flat part of it, sort of like on the narrow edge of the mattress, and that will also reduce the reflectivity, you know, and so they're doing what they can. One issue is that all this so far is voluntary, you know, like regulations and laws don't really keep up with technology, which you can move very very fast, especially when musk is involved. And so the kind of thing that never really was a problem, that never really needed to be handled with legislation and regulation, all of a sudden we're like at the mercy of these billionaires because we don't have sort of rules in place.
WHOA, Well, it's sort of like the open seas, right like nobody owns it, so nobody is regulating it.
I don't actually know how that works. I think there are laws about what happens on the international oceans, but I'm definitely not an expert. But you're right, it's a new frontier of technology, and so our existing laws, you know, even if they do cover it, they didn't anticipate this, and so they weren't really written for this. In mind, people have built in assumptions. Surely nobody's going to launch one hundred thousand satellites when they wrote these laws decades ago.
Well, obviously we need space rangers or you know, space cowboys to put some order back into town up there.
Yeah, and order is important. Another thing we can do is just know where these things are. If you're an astronomer and you know where the satellites are and when they're coming, you can try to plan your observations around it, and you can remove them. You can subtract them from your images. You don't have to play guessing games like well was that a star that did this crazy thing? Or was that star Link's satellite number of four hundred and forty two. Right, If you can know these things very precisely.
Like you could program it into your telescope to take pictures when it's when there aren't any satellites passing in that little patches skuy you're looking at.
Yeah, and then also afterwards to subtract anything that happens to get in the way. But this needs some coordination. You know, somebody has to like write the software and have a database and maintain it and update it and have it be accurate, very precise. And who's going to pay for that, right, So is that starlink is going to do that or the astronomer is going to have to force their grad students to write this software. It just needs some sort of organization. And we're at this moment where like we've dipped our toes in the Mega constellation and we're about to dump thousands and thousands more. It's the kind of thing we need to figure out before we make a big mistake.
Yeah, I think there should also be like a space tax maybe, you know, like tax all those billionaires for the satellites and then use that money to fund space telescopes, you know, because it seems like that's what astronomy is going towards, which is, you know, as we get more and more light pollution. First we went up to the top of mountains to put telescopes, and now we're putting telescopes up in space to get away from human light. And so maybe we should just haven't paid for more space telescopes.
That sounds good to me. I'm always going to vote for more taxes on billionaires to fund more science. Sign me up. But you know, space telescopes are not always the answer. Like there are advantages to space telescopes you're above the atmosphere, light pollution, this kind of stuff. But there are also a lot of advantages to ground based telescopes, Like you can't build a thirty meter telescope in space because you can't launch something that big, and it's harder to repair and to swap out instruments. So there's always going to be an important role for ground based astronomy, and we should make sure that we don't mungge that up.
I guess it's all just another sort of reminder of how things change in the universe. You know, it's not just sort of changing at a cosmic scale, but we can very easily change our view of it and our access to all that knowledge in the universe. Like, you know, we have to be careful right when we do these things.
We do, and as humans, we tend to assume that things are static or infinite, you know, the way we treat the ocean. We used to think of the ocean as like an infinite source of water and you could just dump stuff in it and would just sort of like float away and dilute forever. But now we know that obviously it's not infinite, and you know, we filled it with microplastics and garbage and it's a real problem.
Or like the air, we thought there was plenty of air or you know, atmosphere, and now we're slowly clogging it up.
Yeah, and forests, you know, we have very little like pristine wild nature left for that reason, so we have to be careful not to do the same things to space. While I'm a big believer in technology and space based technology and all that cool stuff, we have to be very careful and do this in a thoughtful way.
Save the night sky. Should we start that movement? Daniel here on the podcast, Are you going to be the spearhead for that?
Yeah? Keep dark skies dark, keep the stars bright, right, keep space weird, keep camping fun, but somehow make it a little more comfortable. Please.
Yeah. Put some of those mattress size satellites, you know, sprinkle them in the forest and then Daniel will always have a place to lay down on.
All thosemores. Do make me tired after a long day of camping.
All right, Well, the next time you look up at the night sky, appreciate the view because maybe someday soon what you'll be seeing are fake stars basically not real, actual exploding stars out there in the universe.
And let's hope that we can learn as much as we can about the nature of the universe before we do change the night sky forever.
Well, we hope you enjoyed that. Thanks for joining us, See you next time.
Thanks for listening, and remember that Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeart Radio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. How is us dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digesters to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit us dairy dot COM's Last Sustainability to learn more.
Our iHeartRadio Music Festival for a sentate bike Capital One Coming Back to Las Vegas twenty first, A weekend full of superstar performances A Sap, Rocky Shun, Camila Kavel, When's the Funny, Keith Urban, New Kids on the Plot, Terrible Shabouzi, The Black Crows, The Weekend, Thomas Red, Victoria, Monette Hold Plays, Chris Martin, hand More, stream Live Polly on Hulu and get it it gets to be there at AXS dot com.
Hi everyone, it's me Katie Couric. You know, if you've been following me on social media, you know I love to cook, or at least try, especially alongside some of my favorite chefs and foodies like Benny Blanco, Jake Cohen, Lighty Hoyke, Alison Roman and Inagarten. So I started a free newsletter called Good Taste to share recipes, tips and kitchen mustaves. Just sign up at Katiecuric dot com slash good Taste. That's k A T I E C O U R I C dot com slash good Taste. I promise your taste buds will be happy you did