What is the densest planet?

Published Dec 1, 2022, 6:00 AM

Daniel and Jorge wonder about which planets would float if you dunked them in a cosmic tub.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield savings account through Applecard, apply for Applecard in the wallet app subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch, Member, FDIC terms and more at applecard dot com.

Have you boosted your business with Lenovo Pro yet? Become a Lenovo Pro member for free today and unlock access to Lenovo's exclusive business store for technology expert advisors and essential products and services designed just for you. Visit Lenovo dot com slash Lenovo Pro to sign up for free. That's Lenovo dot Com slash Lenovo Pro Lenovo unlock new AI experiences with Lenovo's think Pad x one Carbon powered by Intel Core ultraprocessors.

This is Janet from Wine Down with Jana Kramer. I had no idea supplements would make that much of a difference in how I feel every single day. That's why I'm so happy I found SymbioticA. SymbioticA is one of the fastest growing health and wellness companies right now. I take their supplements every single day and I can really feel a difference in how I feel. I love how easy it is to take Symbiotica's supplements. Here's my routine. I take SymbioticA every day in the morning before starting my day or even having my morning coffee. I love feeling like I'm doing something good for my body right at the start of the day. Prepping for my wedding, I've been making sure to prioritize my health, which is easy with SymbioticA. My favorite product is a lepisamal vitamin C. Vitamin C is essential for collagen production, glowing skin, and anti aging, and I have really noticed a difference in my skin since I added it to my routine. It also tastes delicious. We all want that glowy, healthy skin for summer, and SymbioticA is the answer. If you're not someone who thrives on routine, SymbioticA makes it super easy to stay on track with a monthly order. Your supplements arrive at your doorstep every month, so you don't have to even think about it. One of the best perks is you get to enjoy exclusive discounts and access to secret sales. Head over to SymbioticA dot com slash Jana for twenty percent off plus free shipping off your subscription order.

When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. How is us dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digestors to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit you as dairy dot COM's Last sustainability to learn more. Hey or hey, are you ready to dig into another controversial topic?

WHOA Oh, did you take some classified physics documents to your house or something?

Oh, they don't let me see any of that stuff. But this is much more important than that. I'm wondering where you land on the debate about bread. Do you prefer it light and fluffy or dark and heavy?

Ooh, I didn't even know there was a debate about bread. Mostly I just eat it.

I mean, if people argue about like chocolate versus vanilla ice cream, you know they're going to argue about French baguettes versus German RYE.

Well, it kind of depends on how hungry you are. If you're hungry, you'll eat any bread. But isn't that more of a cultural topic than a physics topic.

It's a cultural topic, but it's also a physics topic because it's all about density. Do you like bread that floats or sinks when you drop it in the pool.

It sounds like you've done this experiment.

It's a fundamental question about every object in your life. Will it float?

I retired this on your children as well.

Yes, and I can confirm that my children do float and are they dense? Only in the best way possible.

Well, if there's a bread, but I'd rather you don't throw it into a pool. I'm not sure I like my bread soggy.

I'm sure there's someone out there who disagrees with you.

That'll be a very dense debait. I'm sure I'll rise to the occasion. Hi, I am hoorhem made cartoonist and the co author of Frequently Asked Questions about the Universe.

Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist and a professor at UC Irvine, and I really miss Dave Letterman's bit called will It Float?

Oh? Is that the one where he makes things float? Or is that the one where he throws things out of the roof.

I love that he did so many physics experiments, but one of my favorites was will it Float? Where he just brings out a tubble water and random stuff and he asks the audience do you think it's going to float? And then of course he throws it in the pool and they find out it's pure physics, right.

Right, Yeah, what kinds of things would he test?

Well, you know we had bowling balls and chainsaws, but also you know, loaves of bread, pumpkins, all sorts of things that are right on the edge that divided people and tested their intuition.

M I feel like it's also kind of an engineering question, like how watertight something is, because something could be light and float, but eventually you'll think.

Yeah, that's true, Like a paper boat will float initially until it gets water logged.

Yeah, it's all about engineering at the end truly the most important discipline. But anyways, welcome to our podcast Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe, a production of iHeartRadio.

In which we float various ideas about how the universe works, how it all comes together, what is made out of at its smallest bits, and how those bits to and fro and zip back and forth and buzz together to make the universe that we are familiar with, the one that we experience, the one we are so curious to understand. We dig deep into all the questions about the basic nature of reality and how everything behaves and try to explain all of it to you.

It's right because it is a pretty dense universe, pack full of interesting and amazing facts and phenomena to discover and to explore, and we like to make it all light and fluffy for you here on the podcast and dippable.

I guess you know, I was just googling will It Float and discovered that Letterman once released an Xbox version of Will It Float?

What like, will it Xbox float or sink? Or can you play inside the Xbox?

That is a good question, whether an Xbox will float or sink. Probably it'll sink, but No, he had a version of it, which was a game you can play on the Xbox, like you predict whether various things are going to float or sink, and then they dump them in a virtual tub.

I feel like that's a little bit of an overkill for the Xbox's abilities here.

I think maybe he was just playing a joke about merchandising and commercialization of stuff.

How would your son Phil if you threw his Xbox into a tub of water?

He would probably jump in afterwards, and then I would learn whether it floated and whether he floated.

At the same time, What did you throw both in?

You only need to throw in and then he jumps in after it.

So as long as it's not still connected to the plug in the wall, it's not a bad exercise.

But as much as we like to joke about whether things float, it's part of just wondering how things work and what's inside of them. There's a long history of dunking things in water to understand them, all the way back to measuring the volume of things by immersing them in a bathtub.

Yeah, and as you know, whether something floats or doesn't float, it has everything to do with its density. If something is denser than water, then it's going to sink. If it's less dense than water, it's going to float. In the universe has all kinds of densities in its existence.

That's right. And people have all kinds of densities in their bodies and stuff around us has all sorts of densities, which is why people have been building boats out of wood and not out of stone for thousands of years.

You can make a stone boat, right, You.

Could make a stone boat if it had a big air pocket in it, right, that's how those ships are made of steel. Steel obviously much denser than water. But a modern steel ship has a huge pocket of air inside it and like a big steel balloon essentially.

Yeah. And actually, if you study is civil engineering, a big rite of passage and a lot of schools is to make a concrete boat.

Is that right? So that's something people really do. Yeah, that's awesome. Well, I wonder what the densest material you can make a boat out of is?

Can you make a neutron star boat?

Nuclear pasta boat? You can use sheets of nuclear lasagna?

I suppose, Yeah, I guess it would collapse the entire planet. But you know, at least he would test that theory.

You'd win that engineering competition along the way. And for those of you out there confused about why things that are denser than water can float, the key is not the density of the container necessarily, but the overall average density of the object. So if you make a big balloon out of neutron star material, as long as there's enough air inside of it, the average density is less than the density of water, and then it can float.

Yeah, and so the universe has all kinds of dense things. We've talked on this podcast about neutron stars, which are some of the densest things in the universe, and we've also talked about the opposite, which is the emptiest spots in the universe as well.

The extremes are really fun places to think about because they show us what the edge cases are, what the rules are, what it's possible to achieve, and they also illuminate how various forces and various factors come together to achieve such densities or such emptinesses. So understanding how things can get really really dense can give us some understanding about how things work.

Yeah, there are all kinds of forces in universe, a lot of them are pushing things together, like gravity or the strong nuclear force, and a lot of things are also pushing things apart, like the electromagnetic force.

Density plays an important role in the heart of our Sun, allowing us to warm our toes on that incredible cosmic fire, even though it's millions and millions of miles away. It's density that creates the conditions necessary for fusion at the heart of our star.

Yeah, and it plays a big role in our solar system. I guessespecially here on Earth. Right Earth was less dense than it was, it would probably what collapse or float away?

Well, I think what's interesting is to ask how dense is Earth and why is it that dense? And then to look around at the other planets and when they're like, hmm, are they more dense? Are they less dense? What's going on? It's part of understanding how our solar system came to be the way that it is, and understanding whether it's unusual, Like is our solar system weird compared to other solar systems? Are other planets out there more massive, more dense? Are they fluffier than a French baguette? Are they denser than German rye?

So today on the podcast, we'll be asking the question what is the densest planet?

Now?

My first question to you, Jorge is do you think this is something to be proud of or something to be embarrassed about?

Which one? What do you mean like asking questions or eating bread?

If we're gonna label one planet as densest, do you think that's something that denizens of that planet should be proud of or embarrassed by.

Mmm.

Yes, I was going to ask you if you thought this was an appropriate question to ask. I guess it depends. First of all, if there are people in other planets, that's amazing, But also I guess if you're talking about their planet, then they wouldn't necessarily be offended.

Yeah, dence has some interesting connotations, right. No person would want to be called dense, because it implies that you're not very.

Smart unless you're dense with awesomeness.

Jam packed with jam packed with.

Wonderfulness, dance with talent.

On the other hand, if you're talking about a planet, maybe it means that you're filled with diamonds and gold and all sorts of valuable heavy metals. Right, A huge blob of platinum is pretty dense and I'd rather take that than a blob of water.

To drink, you mean to drink or to float it.

No, when they're like assigning mineral rights in the Solar system, you know, I'll take the denser asteroid please, thank you very.

Much, mm, because Dan, you can do what with it. You can't live in it if there's no water in it.

No, you can't live in it if there's no water. But there's plenty of water out there in the Solar System. But you know, some of those asteroids are just like huge blobs of platinum or other rare earth metals that we need here on Earth to make batteries for all of our fancy gizmos.

Yeah. So there's a huge range of density in our Solar system. I guess you can go from planets that are made out entirely out of gas, which is gas, and then there are planets that are made out of rock and metals, which are some of the densest things around.

And the range of densities tells us something about how the Solar System was formed and what's under our feet and the incredible balance between gravity and the other forces.

Well as usually we're wondering how many people have thought about the question which is the densest planet, and so Daniel went out there into the internet to find out.

So thanks very much to everyone who participates. If you've been listening to the podcast and you would enjoy speculating about the next topics for future episodes, please don't be shy. Write to me two questions at Danielandthorge dot com and we'll set you right up.

Think about it for a second, which do you think is the densest planet what people had to say, I.

Think it would either be Earth or Mass. But I'm pretty sure there's more waters on Earth than on Mars. So just based on that, I think Mars is the densest planet in the Solar System.

I'm going to say, just to throw it out there, the core of Jupiter or Mercury.

Right now, I'm thinking about all these crazy extra planets discovered recently, but I can onlady refer to our solar system, and from our Solar system the densest planet, it's Earth.

Yes, it's Earth.

I'm going to go out on a limb and say that the densest planet is actually Jupiter, because even though it is the most massive planet in our Solar system, I'm guessing that there's probably a part of it that's super dense to keep it all together.

In our solar system, I'm going to guess one of the gas trends the one with the most gravity.

Yeah, let's go with that.

All right. Some dance answers here. Not a lot of fluff here.

Yeah, a lot of variety in the thinking and in the answers. I love it.

I like the people who argue that maybe we didn't specify enough that we meant planet in our Solar system, because like, are we asking what's the dansest planet in the universe or just in our little local neighborhood.

Yeah, well, the physicist in me wants to know what's the highest density possible in a planet anywhere in the universe, and also what is the most dense planet in our solar sysm I want no answers to all those questions.

You're dense with curiosity. But I guess maybe it depends on what you mean by a planet, Like what's the definition of a planet? Like can a neutron star be a planet? Like if you lived on the surface of a neutron star, it would technically be your planet.

I'm not sure maybe it would be your star, you would be the planet. But let's not get drawn into a forty minute rabbit hole about the definition of a planet. That's a whole we don't want to get thrown into.

Well, what's the one sentence answer from a physicist.

Well, the official definition of a planet is a body that mostly orbits the Sun and has cleared its own path in the.

Solar system, a sun, right, not just our sun?

Yes, that's right, a sun or maybe multiple suns, right, because there are systems out there with binary stars at their hearts.

Well, we have how many plants in our Solar system? Eight planets?

We have officially eight planets in our Solar system and a bunch of dwarf planets.

Also, one of them is the densest and I guess one of them is the lightest planet. Or what's the opposite of dense? Fluffius? Is that the official physics word.

I don't know what the si unit is for fluff, but yeah, it's the opposite of dense.

It's maybe measured in podcast episodes.

It's measured in puns per podcast episode or.

Chuckles, great if we have too many chuckles. It's not a very dense episode. All right, well, let's dig into this, Daniel, and let's maybe start with, just like an average planet, what are planets made out of? In our Solar System?

So planets come in quite a variety of stuff, right. The things that planets are made out of depend on where they were when the planetary system was formed, because it all starts from one big blob of ingredients. But the process of planetary formation and stellar formation pulls different ingredients in different places. So where you are in the Solar System as things are forming determines what you sort of get made out of. So it all comes down to understanding that process of how you go from a huge cloud of gas and dust and bits of rock leftover from other Solar systems that have now died and turn that into a new Solar system.

Right, And maybe just to take us back, we start out in space, right, and there's usually a huge cloud of stuff that came from the Big Bang or maybe the remains of other suns that blew up and slowly gravity brings all of that stuff together, which is what forms the Sun and the planets.

Right, that's exactly right, And mostly it's hydrogen. You know, we've been burning stuff in the hearts of stars for billions of years, turning the hydrogen from the Big Bang into helium and neon and carbon and iron and heavier stuff. But we haven't made that much progress. The universe is still like ninety something percent hydrogen. It's really just mostly hydrogen Differenst approximation. And so even though I'm not made of hydrogen and you're not made of hydrogen, hydrogen is the most common thing out there in the universe. So if you're imagining this cloud that formed the Solar System, it's mostly hydrogen with like a sprinkle of other stuff like the iron and the magnesium. All that stuff is like the spice on top of the meal.

Right.

Although something interesting to think about is how much hydrogen we actually are, right, I mean, we're mostly made out of water, which is h two oz, right, and even our molecules they are you know, hydrocarbons are called hydrocarbon because they have hydrogen.

Yeah, that's true, and there's different ways of thinking about it. Also, hydrogen by number or hydrogen by mass, because even if you have a lot of hydrogen, it's not very heavy. And so the universe, for example, is like ninety two percent hydrogen by number of molecules, but it's only seventy something percent hydrogen by mass. Because the other stuff is so much more massive, even though there's less of it, it counts for a bigger proportion of the mass of the universe.

So like in our bodies, where the maybe hydrogen is the most popular atom, but maybe not the most in terms of weight exactly. So, and if you eat a lot of bread, then yeah, you're mostly carbs.

And for example, the Sun today is like ninety five percent hydrogen, but the Earth is much less. The Earth has a huge fraction of oxygen and magnesium and iron, and so the Earth and the Sun and Jupiter, they're not all like representative samples of the stuff that started the Solar System. It differentiated itself. It's separated. The process of that gravitational collapse led things to accumulate in different ways, which led to different sort of scoops of each material in different places.

Right, And because you were saying it sort of depends on where you are in the initial kind of cloud that eventually became the Solar System, because I think what happened was that most of the hydrogen that cloud kind of rushed to the center and that's why we're the sun form.

Right, Yeah, exactly. There's sort of three zones to think about. There's the center, which forms the star, and you're right, that gathers most of the gas, at least in the inner Solar system. Then there's the inner part of it, which is who you say. It doesn't have much gas for two reasons. One is that the Sun steals a lot of it, and the other is that the Sun blows away some of the gas. Once the Sun gets going and starts emitting photons in solar wind, it will strip the inner planets of any gas they had. Remember that the Earth when it was first formed, it had a primordial atmosphere of hydrogen and helium, but most of that was lost because of the incredible radiation from the Sun. So the inner planets don't really keep much gas. That's why they're mostly rock. They're iron and silica and that kind of stuff, because the gas either falls into the Sun or gets blown out into the outer Solar system by the radiation from the Sun.

Right, And I guess where did the rocks in the rocky planets come from.

They came from the hearts of other stars.

Right.

Those rocks are made of heavier elements. And remember astronomers think of everything it's not hydrogen or helium as a metal. And so these metals came from fusion inside the hearts of other now dead stars. They started as hydrogen from the Big Bang, or maybe a tiny little bit of helium. They were fused into heavier stuff and lived for millions or billions of years inside another star which then died. And when it died, it blew out a lot of that stuff out into the galaxy. And that's where these raw materials come from. They float out there in these big clouds until eventually they collapsed back again, triggered maybe by a shockwave from a nearby supernova or just by a gravitational over density that gradually pulls this stuff back together.

Right, So, initially we had this cloud of hydrogen and some helium and a little bit, tiny little bit of some rocky and metal and solid stuff. And then I think what happened was that the gas, because it's lighter, kind of rushed to the middle, right, leaving some of the heavier stuff just around the Sun. That's where the rocky planets came from.

Yeah, So the processes you have the stars forming and at the same time, you get what's called a pro to a planetary disc. At this disc of material, it's sort of like the star has a ring system. All the material which you will eventually form the planets is now flattened into a disc. Gravity is doing its job of pulling it together, but it's hard to pull it all into the Sun because if it's spinning around, it has a lot of angular momentum, and so it sort of stays in orbit rather than collapse in so gravity collapses it into that disc and places where you have enough density, where you have like heavy stuff like iron and magnesium and rock that's able to compete with the gravity of the Sun and pull some more stuff together. So it's sort of like a race, you know, who can get enough stuff to survive. If you don't pull enough stuff in to get massive enough, then you just get drawn into somebody else's gravity well. And so in our Solar system, we had a huge planet, Jupiter start to form, and it must have started from a gravitational over density and then it got bigger and bigger and bigger, because the more massive it is, the more gravity it has, the more it pulls stuff in. And so each of the planets sort of start from a spot in that protoplanetary disk where you already had a little bit of a xra blob of stuff, and the mass of the planets tells you something about the initial size of that over density. The bigger it is, the faster it's able to gather mass, and the bigger the planet ends up.

Being kind of like maybe like a game of musical chairs, kind of like everyone's trying to grab as much stuff as possible before somebody else grabs it.

Right, Yeah, it's sort of like gravitational hungry, hungry hippos. Right, Everybody just grab in more and more, And the bigger you are, the more hippos you get, and the easier it is to grab stuff. And in the inner Solar System you end up with planets of rock and silica and iron because those are the dense materials that can hold themselves together and resist being pulled into the Sun. And then the gas, of course is blown out. Further out in the Solar System, the Sun's radiation is weaker and the Sun's gravity is weaker, and so gas giants can form. Jupiter and Saturn have huge contributions from helium and from hydrogen because they were far enough away from the Sun and grew fast enough that they were able to compete with the Sun's gravity, and their own gravity could protect their gas from the Sun's radiation, which is also weaker that far out in the Solar System.

And while that's how we got the planets, and some of them are denser than others, and some of them is going to win the title of densest planet, and I guess another one is going to win the fluffiest planet, which is the one where I want to go. And so let's get into those details. But first let's take a quick break.

With big wireless providers, what you see is never what you get. Somewhere between the store and your first month's bill, the price you thought you were paying magically skyrockets. With mint Mobile, You'll never have to worry about gotcha's ever again. When mint Mobile says fifteen dollars a month for a three month plan, they really mean it. I've used mint Mobile and the call quality is always so crisp and so clear I can recommend it to you. So say bye bye to your overpriced wireless plans, jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages. You can use your own phone with any mint Mobile plan and bring your phone number along with your existing contacts. So did your overpriced wireless with mint Mobiles deal and get three months a pre smium wireless service for fifteen bucks a month. To get this new customer offer in your new three month premium wireless plan for just fifteen bucks a month, go to mintmobile dot com slash universe. That's mintmobile dot com slash universe. Cut your wireless build a fifteen bucks a month at mintmobile dot com slash universe. Forty five dollars upfront payment required equivalent to fifteen dollars per month new customers on first three month plan only speeds slower about forty gigabytes On unlimited plan. Additional taxi speeds and restrictions apply. See mint mobile for details.

AI might be the most important new computer technology ever. It's storming every industry and literally billions of dollars are being invested, so buckle up. The problem is that AI needs a lot of speed and processing power, So how do you compete without cost spiraling out of control. It's time to upgrade to the next generation of the cloud, Oracle Cloud Infrastructure or OCI OCI is a single platform for your infrastructure, database, application development, and AI needs. OCI has four to eight times the bandwidth of other clouds, offers one consistent price and stead of variable regional pricing, and of course nobody does data better than Oracle, So now you can train your AI models at twice the speed and less than half the cost of other clouds. If you want to do more and spend less, like Uber eight by eight and Data Bricks Mosaic, take a free test drive of OCI at Oracle dot com slash strategic. That's Oracle dot com slash Strategic Oracle dot com slash Strategic.

If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield savings account through Applecard, apply for Applecard in the wallet app, subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Applecard owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City Branch Member FDIC terms and more at applecard dot com. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, or enjoy a rich spoonful of Greek yogurt. You're probably not thinking about the environment impact of each and every bite, but the people in the dairy industry are. US Dairy has set themselves some ambitious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times the same water cools the milk, cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US Dairy tackling greenhouse gases. Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneuver into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit usdairy dot com slash sustainability to learn more.

All right, we're talking about the densest planet in the Solar System. Daniel, where would you put your money? I guess you know the end.

I know the answer, But I do like thinking about it in terms of floating. Like imagine some giant cosmic tub of water on some you know, cosmic version of the David Letterman show, and you're putting the planets in it, Like will Saturn float? Or if you drop Mercury into a huge tube of water, will it sink? That's just sort of a fun experiment to do.

Yeah, let's do it. How much would it cost?

I don't know. That's an engineering problem.

It's called David Letterman. He did pretty well right with the show.

He's sitting on some money. Yeah, this would be like a great way out of retirement for him.

He's got some of that Netflix money now. But it is an interesting question, which is the densest planet? And maybe you know, I feel like as we learn about the planets, we learn about their size. Like you sort of learned that Jupiter is the biggest one and that Mercury is the smallest one, right, but you maybe never think about the density of them.

Yeah, we do focus on the size because that's what we can see. You look through your telescope, you can see Jupiter is big. You can see Saturn is huge with these big rings. So we know something about the size. And it's fun to think about, right, It's fun to try to wrap your mind around the incredible variety of sizes, right, Like, Jupiter is enormous compared to the Earth. So it's really fun to just like try to imagine filling Jupiter with earths and then doing the same thing for the Sun, like filling the Sun with Jupiter's and imagining how many earths would fit inside the Sun, which is like a million. And would Earth float in Jupiter if you like liquefied Jupiter and put it in a.

Tub, I don't know. Or if you like through Earth at Jupiter, would it float?

Would Earth float in Jupiter? Actually would not? Right? Earth is much denser than Jupiter, it turns out, so Earth would sink like a stone in the ocean of Jupiter.

But I guess how far right? Also, the definition of floating kind of like, are we technically floating around the Sun?

I don't think there's any buoyancy, right, It's only gravity. I think in order to be floating, you need to have some sort of forces of buoyancy, you know, the displacement, and I think that's happening in our Solar System.

You need the stuff from the thing that you're floating on to be pushing you up, that's what you're saying.

Yeah, exactly, to be balancing gravity.

All right, Well, we're trying to get to the answer of this question what is the densest planet. And we've talked about how planets are formed, because what you're made out of sort of depends on where you are in the Solar System when things started to form.

Yeah, and there's sort of four different categories of stuff that planets can be made out of. There's like very heavy metals like iron. You're going to find that the inner planets are mostly made out of stuff like that. And then there's rock and that's also what be found mostly in the inner planets. And then there's gas, which of course the Sun and Jupiter and Saturn have huge servings of. And then there's water. There is a lot of water in the Solar System. And there's this very interesting point where you're far enough away from the Sun. It's called the frost line or the snow line past which water is ice instead of vapor, and beyond that line, water is a solid, and so if you have a bunch of water, it's frozen and it sort of contributes to the mass of the planet and it helps planets grow faster. So planets like Urinous and Neptune, these are ice giants because they have huge amounts of ice in them. Even without accumulating a lot of hydrogen helium, they still were able to grow really large. So the proportion of what you get in the Solar System as you form really does depend on where you.

Are, right, although if you put water out in space, even near Earth, it's going to freeze too, right.

It's a really good question, and it's sort of tricky. If it's close enough to the Sun, then it will vaporize, right because it's very low pressure out there in space, and the phase of a material depends not just on the temperature but also on the pressure, and so water will vaporize in space unless you're really far out.

So you mean, like it's really the difference between vapor and solid, Like you'll jump straight from a vapor to at some point if you put some water out there, it'll turn into an ice cube.

Exactly, which is why I think if you go out into space, parts of you will boil in distantly right where boiling doesn't mean you're getting really hot. It just means it's sublimating, it's going directly to gas. And so you can boil at a very low temperature if the pressure is very very low, Like you know how if you're at high altitude, you can boil your water at lower temperatures. It's like harder to cook pasta at the top of Mount Everest than it is in Death Valley because the water boils at a lower temperature because of the lower pressure. Out in deep space, water boils at very very low temperature, and so it turns into vapor even if it's very cold.

So I think. So you were saying that the inner planets are mostly med out of rocks because of where they are, and the outer planets are mostly mid out of gas because of where they were. But that doesn't mean that there aren't rocks and metals out there in the outer Solar System. There still are, right, There's still a lot of metal and earth, maybe the same amount as there is in the inner Solar System. It's just that the inner planets don't have gas because it was all blown.

Away, exactly. And there is definitely metal and rock out there in the outer Solar system. You know, Pluto, for example, is a lump of rock, and we suspect that at the core of Jupiter and Saturn there is metal, There is rock, absolutely, It's just that they also have a lot of gas that accumulated all this hydrogen and this helium as.

Well, because right, because the Sun didn't get to suck up that gas before Jupiter could take it all by for itself.

Exactly, And Jupiter probably did begin as just metallic or rocky blob and then it gathered all that gas up with it. And the same thing for the ice giants. They also definitely have some rock and some metals inside of them. They just also gathered a bunch of water as well. So that helps you understand the mass the density is this combination of size and mass, right, And so you might imagine that the densest things would then be the in your Solar system, because that's like where you have almost only the denser materials, right.

But that's kind of interesting to think about, Like if you took Jupiter and any of those giant planets out there and you strip them a while their gas, or you got rid of all the gas in the Solar system, like all the planets would maybe be kind of the same kind of right, small dense, rocky tiny balls.

That's right. If you like gas blasted Jupiter so you blew away all of its helium and its hydrogen, then you would be left with a core, which we think we don't know. We're not sure because of course we've never probed it the way we probed the Earth. We think that probably there is a rocky core there.

Well, I read that Jupiter's core is actually more fluffy. It's not like a rocky core. It's more like a kind of like a fuzzy rocky core.

Yeah, well, we're not exactly sure. There's definitely some rock and some ice. It's also really interesting other chemical effects like surrounding the rock and the ice. There is hydrogen, but it's not hydrogen in the form that you're familiar with it. It's called metallic hydrogen. Hydrogen that's under such intense pressure and temperature that has formed this really strange phase. It's like liquid hydrogen.

But I think the point is that you know, if it wasn't for gas, the gas and that the outer planets have and maybe some of the water. Then all the planets would be sort of the same. It would be small and rocky and peop wouldn't be talking about the dens is one. But because those planets have a lot of gas than their density changes.

Yeah, And there's really interesting connection between the mass of a planet and its density because remember this's more than just one thing going on. It's not just like how much stuff do you have and what element is it? Right, you might think it's not just how much iron do you have or versus how much gas do you have? But how massive are you Because the larger the planet gets, the stronger it's gravity and the stronger its ability to compress itself to make it more dense. So it's not like as you add mass to a planet, it just gets bigger and stays the same density. As you add mass to a planet, it actually also gets more dense, so its size doesn't grow as quickly as it's mass.

Right.

But it maybe it also depends on what you put into it, what you're feeding it, right, Like if you're feeding it a gas, then that's going to be maybe a little harder to compress than the metal.

Actually, the gas is easier to compress than the metal, right. It has to do with how compressible these materials are, and things like iron and rock are harder to compress than things like hydrogen and helium. So if you look, for example, that planets made out of ice or silicon or iron, then there tends to be a bit more of a spread between their mass and their density. It's not as closely connected. But if you look at giant planets, and not just in our Solar system, but in other solar systems, you see a much tighter connection between the mass and the density. As you add more mass, the density increases pretty quickly for gas giants. It's a not as tight relationship for the lower mass planets made of metals and rocks.

But in general, the planets closer to the Sun are made mostly out of rocky stuff. For example, let's talk about Mercury.

Yeah, so Mercury, you might imagine, which should be the densest thing. Right, it's closest to the Sun. It's had all the low density stuff blown off of it, and in fact it is a really crazy planet. It's got like a metallic core that's eighty five percent of its interior, So this thing is mostly metal. It's really just like a huge scoop of heavy metals surrounded by a thin layer of silicon within layer of rock. So to compare, Earth's core is like fifty five percent of its interior is this metal, whereas mercury it's eighty five percent. So mercury is really a very dense blob of stuff out there in the universe.

Yeah, it's really into heavy metal. But I think we hear you mean actually actually like metal metals, right, Like if for Earth it's mostly iron, right, Like our core is mostly made out of molten iron and as opposed to rock.

Yeah, that's exactly right. We're talking about iron and there's also some nickel in there. And you know, there's a lot of uncertainty here. We know a lot about the Earth's core because we can do things like study earthquakes, and as those earthquakes reverberate around the surface, they bounce across those layers in the Earth's core and they tell us something about the density. It's like ringing the earth like a bell and then studying those sound waves. We can't do that as well on mercury because we don't have Mercury quake sensors. We do have those kind of sensors on Mars now and on the Moon, so we can take direct measurements. But the other ones we're guessing a little bit more. They come from planetary models and from our understanding the mass and the radius of these things.

All right, So Mercury is basically like a solid ball of metal, right, like a baby almost like a little ball of metal, And so you would think maybe it's the densest planet in the Solar System.

You would think so, And it's pretty dense. It comes out about five point four grams per cubic centimeter, and so you know to orient yourself. Water is one gram per cubic centimeter, so Mercury would definitely not float. It's more than five times denser than water.

All right, So it's not Mercury the densest planet. I guess. Maybe a question is what exactly makes something dense or not?

Well, density here is really connected to size. As you add more stuff to the planet, it doesn't just get bigger, right if you put a whole nother load of mass on Mercury, if you like, double Mercury's mass, it wouldn't double its volume and then have the same density because the gravity would get stronger. And so because the gravity gets stronger, it would squeeze those atoms more tightly. So the way to increase Mercury's density would be to increase its mass. But Mercury is a pretty small planet. It's not nearly the mass of the Earth or a venus for example.

I see what you're saying, Like, if maybe I added more stuff to Mercury, even if it was light stuff like gas, then it would increase the gravity and maybe squeeze that metal core even more and make it more dense.

Exactly because the metal core of mercury right now is denser than like if you just took that metal and had it floating out into space, if it was very cold and there was no pressure on it, it would be much less dense. You take that same amount of metal and you put it inside Mercury's core, it's going to get squeezed down. It's going to be more dense than it otherwise would. So you add a bunch more stuff to Mercury, it's going to increase its density.

But maybe only up to a point. Right like this, is there a maximum size for a rocky planet.

Actually, it's really interesting. We think that there's no maximum density to a planet, but there is a maximum size to a rocky planet. As a rocky planet gets larger and larger, it also gets denser and denser. Adding more stuff that increases the gravity and that makes it denser, and there's sort of this asymptotic size. You can't really make a rocky planet bigger than about ten thousand kilometers in radius. When you get to that radius, it's so dense inside that if you add more stuff, it doesn't actually increase the size at all. It just increases the density. Like the gravity on that planet pulls that new blob of stuff in and it just makes it more dense. So for rocky planets, there's no maximum density unless you think about black hole levels, but there is probably a maximum size.

Well, I think what you mean is that when you're adding more rocks to it, right, Like, if you make a you have a rocky planet, and you add more rocks to it, it's not going to increase in size. It's just going to get denser. But if you add other kinds of stuff to it, it is going to increase in size, right.

We're talking about rocky planets having a maximum size. So if you're going to only make it out of rocks and metal, then there is a maximum size. But you see sort of the same kind of effect happening in our Solar system with Jupiter and Saturn. For example, Jupiter is only a little bit bigger than Saturn in terms of size, like its radius is seventy thousand kilometers, whereas saturns is about sixty thousand. But Jupiter is more than three times more massive than Saturn, right, And that's because as you add gas to Saturn, for example, try to turn it into Jupiter, it doesn't just grow in volume. That gas gets compressed, and gas is easier to compress than iron and metals. And so that's why adding a lot more mass to Jupiter also wouldn't make it much bigger. It would make it denser faster than it would make it bigger.

Right. But it does get bigger though, right.

It does get bigger. Absolutely, So you can have really really huge gas planets. They can get much bigger than rocky planets, absolutely, right.

But I guess so you're saying, like Jupiter is maybe like maybe started off like a mercury but then you added a bunch of gas, and if you had added rocks, it wouldn't have grown in size. But because you're adding gas, it does increase in size, although it also increases in density because that gas gets compressed exactly.

And there's also a maximum size to a gas planet because if you add enough gas to Jupiter, or what happens it turns into a star. The pressure in the interior ignites fusion, and then fusion creates a lot of outwards pressure. So then as you add more mass, the density goes down, like bigger stars are less dense than smaller stars. Once you cross that threshold from gas giant into star, then as you add mass, the density actually goes down because the fusion increases and it fluffs up the star.

Interesting, and so I guess maybe in the case of Jupiter, I would think that maybe that's a good candidate for being the densest object. Then even though it's made out of a lot of gas, there's a lot of gas that's there and a lot of sauce stuff in the middle. Maybe it's compressing all that gas enough to make it super dense.

It's a good idea, and one of our listeners might be right that the core of Jupiter is probably very very dense, but Jupiter has so much hydrogen and hydrogen it is just not very dense that it's actually not very dense at all. Jupiter is like one point, I mean, three to three grams per centimeter. Jupiter would not float, but it almost would, right.

I think that's what I meant earlier, is that you know, gas is sort of easy to compress, but ultimately it is something like Jupiter. The gas doesn't compress to something denser than rock.

Yeah, exactly. The gas is very low mass, right, so it doesn't contribute as much gravity as well. And Saturn is even less dense than Jupiter. Saturn is actually zero point seven grams per cubic meter, which means Saturn would float. If Letterman could build a huge tub of water, Saturn would actually float in it.

Well, I guess maybe a question is why doesn't gas compress as much as rocks?

It just doesn't have as much mass, right, It's not inherently as dense. You don't have as many protons inside there, so the compression is just due to gravity.

Why can't I squeeze him heart closer together than I can with the metal.

It's not about squeezing the atoms closer together. It's about the nucleus of the atom having more mass already. Right, there's all those extra protons in the nucleus of iron and in silicon and in carbon and in oxygen. That makes it more massive and therefore having more gravity.

But couldn't I then squeeze the hydrogen atoms closer together.

The reason it's hard to compress hydrogen, of course, is because the electrons repel each other, And if you squeeze even further, then the protons in the nuclei will reject each other as well, will repel each other. So the atoms don't like to be compressed beyond a certain point. But if you have the same sort of number density of hydrogen and number density of iron, like you have a million iron atoms in a cubic meter versus a million hydrogen atoms, you're going to get a lot more gravity from the iron atoms. You're gonna get a lot more density.

All right. Well, Mercury apparently is not the densest planet, even though it's the smallest, and the rockis and Jupiter is the largest planet. But it's also not the densest, and so let's get into which planet is the densest planet in our solar system. But first, let's take another quick break.

When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth or enjoy a rich spoonful of Greek yogurt, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact of each and every bite, But the people in the dairy industry are. US Dairy has set themselves some ambitious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times. The same water cools the milk, cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneuver into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit usdairy dot com slash sustainability to learn more.

Imagine relying on a dozen different software programs to run your business, none of which are connected, and each one more expensive and.

More complicated than the last.

It can be pretty Stressfulve now imagine o do Odo has all the programs you'll ever need, and they're all connected on one platform.

Does an odo sound amazing?

Let odo harmonize your business with simple, efficient software that can handle everything for a fraction of the price. Sign up today at odu dot com. That's odoo dot com.

All State wants to remind fans that mayhem is everywhere. Like when your fantasy league meets up at your house. Everything's great until the hot plate gets too hot for the tablecloth. Now your kitchen's up in smoke, and if you don't have the right home insurance coverage, the cost to fix this is anything but a fantasy. So switch to All States, save money and get protected from mayhem like this not available in every state. Terms apply savings vary. All State vehicle and property insurance Company and Affiliates, Northbrook, Illinois.

Ryan Seacrest here. When you have a busy schedule, it's important to maximize your downtime. One of the best ways to do that is by going to Chumbuckcasino dot com. Chumbuck Casino has all your favorite social casino games like spin, slots, bingo, and Solitaire that you can play for free for a chance to redeem some serious prizes. So hop on to Chumbucasino dot com now and live the Chumba life sponsored by Chumpa Casino. No purchase necessary VGW group void. We're prohibited by Law eighteen plus. Terms and conditions apply.

All right.

We are giving out an award for the dansest planet in the Solar System, Daniel, what is our planet going to win for being the dnsest planet.

It's going to win a huge blue ribbon and we're gonna give it a nice pat of butter after we toast it for lunch.

M I thought you were going to get in a bouquet of breads or a nice day at the spot where they can float in a tub all day or not float, I guess, or think into a tub.

They're gonna have to float in like a tub of molten lead or something like that.

Well, yeah, I mean that could be relaxing, I guess, if not totally poisonous.

Yeah, you do, you man treat yourself all right.

Well, the densest planet, apparently is not Mercury, which is the smallest and rockiest one that is mostly made out of metal. And it's not Jupiter, which is the biggest planet and most massive planet in our solar system, Daniel, which one is the densest planet. It's not Pluto, is it?

It's not Pluto. No, it's actually the Earth. Earth is the densest planet in the Solar System. We win this.

One, what surprise plot twist? It was us all along?

It was us all along. The answer was the planet we loved along the way.

But not by much, right, Like the Earth is like five and a half grass cubic centimeter and Mercury is like five point four to three, which is pretty close.

Yeah, And the reason the Earth wins is just because it's more massive, Like whatever happened in the very early Solar system, Earth started forming before Mercury, or it formed from a larger initial blob either one, and so it was able to like hungry, hungry, hippo. It's way to just more stuff. And so because we have more stuff, we don't just get bigger again, we get more compressed. Right, more stuff means more gravity, which means more gravitational pressure, which means that the stuff we're made out of is squeezed more than the stuff mercury is made out of, just because there's more of it. And so that's why Earth is able to eke out above mercury like you would naively expect. And if all the planets had the same mass, you would expect that the ones closer to the Sun would be denser for the reasons we've discussed several times, and as you went out there would be less and less dense. But there's another factor there, which is a total mass. More mass means more density for these planets.

But we're also bigger than mercury, right, Like, we're both larger in size and also denser.

Exactly, we're larger, we're more massive, and we're only a little bit denser than mercury. We're like just barely eke out. It's like five point five to one versus five point four to three grams per cubic centimeter. So neither of us would float in, right.

But it's again, it's not just because we have more mass, because Jupiter definitely has thousands of times more mass than Earth, but it's not as dense as Earth because gas doesn't get compressed as much.

Yeah, Jupiter's areund three hundred times in the mass of the Earth, but you're right, it's much less dense. So the reason that we're denser is because we are made out of rocks and metals instead of gas. And we also have a bigger scoop of stuff than mercury. So we're denser than Jupiter because we're made of denser stuff, and we're denser than mercury because we're made of more dense stuff.

All right, So the Earth is about five point five grams per cubic centimeters and mercury is five point four grams per cubic centimeters. What were some of the other close runner ups.

Venus, which is right between us, is five point two grams per cubic centimeters, So it's like we're right around there. You know, these three inner planets are all very similar in mass.

Super close, right, Like if you were to round to the nearest single digit, they're about the same.

Yeah, and except for the Earth, it sort of follows the trend you expect, you know. So Earth is the most massive, but then it's Mercury, then Venus, then Mars, which is almost four grams per cubic centimeter. So the Earth is sort of an outlier there, right, It's sort of like the weird one. Other than that, it follows the rule of the inner planets being the densest and then it's falling as you get further from the Sun. So the Earth just sort of like happened to be a big boy or a big girl or big thing.

It just happened to get more stuff, right, because Mars is further out, but it's smaller.

Yeah, Mars is further out, and it's also smaller, and so it can't really compete, right.

And then at some point in the Solar System, the planets become gas planets, right, which is where Jupiter and Saturn come in.

And those guys are about roughly the density of water, you know. Jupiter is just a little bit more dense than water at one point three grams per centimeter cubed, and Saturn is a little bit less dense than water at point seven grams per centimeters cubed.

So it's interesting because then if you had a cup of water, it would sink in Jupiter technically, but it would float. Now it would sink in Saturn, but it would float in Jupiter.

Yeah, exactly. If you spill your beverage and Jupiter, don't worry. You can just you know, bend down with your straw and slurp it up. It's going to be floating over the surface of Jupiter.

Right, well, technically also maybe in Saturn, right because we're talking about average densities.

Yeah, exactly, And it's a little bit fuzzy there, right, Like, because the edge of Jupiter is fuzzy. It's easy to say where we think the Earth ends right at the surface, but it's harder to say, like where to draw the line for Jupiter because it doesn't have a hard surface the way Earth does. So they sort of arbitrarily defined some drop off in the density as the edge of Jupiter. But that changes the number. You know, if you push further out to include Jupiter's full atmosphere and exosphere, then the density would drop even further. The density at the core of these planets is much higher than the density near the edges.

Right, Like you said, Jupiter has metallic hydrogen at its core, and Saturn I think it rains diamonds too, right, Like things, they are pretty intense inside of these fluffy planets.

Yeah, and that's one reason that it's hard to study. We have dropped probes into some of these things, but they don't last very long because the pressure gets very intense pretty quickly.

Right. So then after these gassy and gassy planets, then you have the icy planets, right, Uranus and Neptune, and those are actually denser than the gassy planets.

Yeah, Urinus is about the same as Jupiter, but Neptune is even denser. It's one point six grams per centimeters cubed. And that's just because it has more water, more ice. It's out past the frost line and so it can get a little bit more solid. It's a little bit more like the rocky planets than like the gas planets. I mean, it's still more like a gas planet, but sort of in the rocky your direction, because it has more ice in it.

Right. It kind of seems to depend on what your most of your mass comes from, right, Like if most of your mask comes from rocks, then you're going to be more dense. If its mostly comes from gas, you're going to be the least dense, And if it mostly comes from water, then you're sort of in the middle.

Yeah, and it's a really cool way to sort of indicate what you're made out of, which tells you where you were formed in the Solar System and something about the whole history of the Solar System's formation. There's so much rep information wrapped up in these few numbers, you know, the mass, the radius, the density. That tells you a lot about the history of each planet.

All right, so Earth, we are the densest planet in our Solar system. That's I guess that's a good distinction, right, Like dense is good. It means more is happening.

We're not to be taken lightly, that's for sure.

Yeah, it's a pretty heavy topic, but.

You know, on cosmic scales, these are not very impressive densities. You were talking earlier about neutron stars. Remember that if water is one gram per cubic centimeter, a neutron star is ten to the eleven kilograms per cubic centimeter. Right, it's just like way off the scale. You know, orders and orders of magnitude. Remember that a t spoon of neutron star material is like seven hundred thousand Eiffel towers all squeezed into a tiny spot. So the universe is capable of creating stuff at much much higher densities than we see in our solar system.

Right, I guess it depends on how much mass you get to accumulate into a small spot. So basically anything would float in a neutron star, even six hundred thousand Eiffel towers.

I don't know if you'd call it floating. Neutron stars actually have a crust, right, So you could build Eiffel towers on the surface of a neutron star if you made them strong enough, because nothing can be higher than about a millimeter above the surface of a neutron star because the gravity is so intense that it just gets flattened. So, yeah, if you spill your drink on a neutron star, it's going to be a very thin puddle on.

The surface, right Yeah, Well, well, well it would be a puddle, but you'd still be floating. Well, those are the planets in our solar system. What about out there into the cosmos? One of our listeners here was asking whether we meant the Solar System or the exoplanets out there in other parts of the galaxy and other galaxies.

Yeah.

One of the really fun things about modern astronomy is that we are now able to use our telescopes to study planets around other stars, which gives us this amazing window into the question of whether our Solar system is weird or typical. In the end, it's sort of a statistics question. We're like one example out of many, many stars, and we want to know are we usual? Are we weird? You know, how could we be different? Is the fact that there's life on this Solar system mean that our Solar system has to be different? Or if our Solar system is normal and usual, does that mean there's life everywhere in the Solar System. It's a really big and fun question, and it's actually not that hard to think about the densities of these planets because to measure the density you only need to know their mass and their size.

Right, Because it's an interesting question because it could be then maybe other solar systems out there in the universe are totally different than ours, Right, It could be that ours is like, you know, a weird one where we form planets, but it could be maybe that in other Solar systems, maybe you don't even form planets, or you form like one giant planet, or you only form two planets or something like that, right.

Yeah, Or they're all gas giants. Maybe rocky planets are super rare in the universe, or maybe they're all rocky planets. Right until we started looking at other solar systems and we didn't know the answer to this. Now we actually know that there are a lot of gas giants out there. We call them hot jupiters. A lot of them are really big gas giants close to their sun. We also have identified a lot of rocky planets, so we know that there's rocky planets out there, and there are gassy planets out there, and there's a huge variety also in the density of these planets.

Right. It's interesting because, like you say, these things are really hard to see, Like we barely even seen like or have photos of one planet out there beyond the Solar System. We kind of have to backtrack what these planets look like or how density are from what we can see of how their stars wiggle or how much light they block from the star when they pass in front of it. Right, it's kind of a tricky problem.

It's a very tricky problem, and it's amazing what we can figure out. You want to know what is this planet made out of? Well, you can't go visit it, you can't land a probe on it, you can't even really measure the light that comes from it very well. So how do you figure out what it's made out of? Well, its density is a huge clue. Right. If you are an astronomer in a faraway solar system studying ours, and you could measure the density of Earth and the density of Jupiter, that would tell you, oh, one of those is probably a gas planet, in one of those is a rocky planet, because one of them is much denser than the others. So just getting a measure of the density of planets and other solar systems tells you immediately what kind of things they might be made out of. And you're right, it's very tricky, but we can measure the mass of those planets and the radius of those planets. The mass comes from understanding the orbital dynamics, like how long does it take to go around the star? How far away from the star is it. We can just solve the Newton's equations, you know, use Kepler's loss to understand what is the forces of gravity, how fast it is going, and therefore how massive is it. Just by understanding its orbit, we can tell what the mass of a planet is.

Like Jupiter, if Jupiter was denser or less dense, it would still have the same trajectory around the Sun.

Exactly, its mass and its radius determine the orbital velocity.

Or like the Earth, if the Earth was fluffier or more hardcore, a year would still be a year on Earth.

Yeah, exactly because gravity. Exactly, because when you're dealing with Newtonian gravity, you can always like replace an object with a point particle of the same mass and you get to effect the same gravity as long as you're on the outside of the object. So replace the Earth with a particle the mass of the Earth and it would move the same way the Earth does. Right, And so by observing the motion of those exoplanets, we can tell what their mass is regardless of what their size is, right, it's an independent thing. But then figure out what their density is. We do need to know what is the size of that planet, and that we can do by watching them eclipse their sun. As you're saying, one way that we can detect those planets are there is that they pass in front of their star, and so they block the light from that star a tiny little bit. But our telescopes are sensitive enough to see that. It's called the transit method. So as that distant planet passes in front of the star, it decreases the light and decreases the light more if it's a bigger planet, unless if it's a smaller planet. So by seeing how much it decreases the light, we can measure the radius of that planet, the size of it, separately from its mass.

Right And once we know their mass and their size eyes, then you can tell their density and that maybe tells you like, hey, this is a rocky planet or an icy planet or a gas planet right exactly.

Or it's like, what, this is a really weird planet. What's going on? This planet seems to be super fluffy or super dense.

This was made out of bread. That's so weird.

It's a bad gat planet. Maybe the French have been colonizing before we even knew it, but you know, it's definitely going to be testing our assumptions. We have these ideas these models for how big a rocky planet can be. I'm sure we're going to find one that breaks that rule if we look far enough, and that's going to tell us something we didn't understand about how planets form. So it's very exciting to look for the extremes of these planets.

All right. Well, that means density is an important thing to know about a planet because it tells you a lot about what it's made out of and where in the Solar system, wherever that Solar system might be it came from.

Yeah, And so we have been looking and there are a few really fun candidates. One of them is called Kepler one thirty one C, which just means that the Kepler telescope discovered it. And it's one hundred and thirty First it's spotted, and this is very uncertain, but this is the planet out there with the highest estimated density. It's more than eight times the mass of the Earth, but it's actually smaller than the Earth in radius. And so the current estimate of this thing's density is seventy seven grams per cubic centimeter. Remember the Earth is like five grams per cubic centimeter, So this thing is like fifteen times the density of the Earth if these numbers.

Are correct, right, But is that weird or is that pretty much what you'd expect if the Earth was you know, if you give it eight times the mass and rocks, would the Earth also be that size.

Yeah, if you took a bunch of earths and you squeeze them together, you would get something very dense. Right, But we think that it's possible to get larger than the Earth. Remember, the upper limit for the radius of a rocky planet is like ten thousand kilometers and the Earth is six thousand kilometers, So it's possible to get bigger than the Earth. If you plopped a bunch of earths together, you would expect them to be larger than the Earth by a little bit. So this to be that dense, it has to also be made of denser stuff than the Earth. So maybe it's just like a huge blob of lead or like has a lot of magnesium or osmium in it. It's not a crazy number, but it's definitely out there on the extreme edge.

Whoa like the whole planet gist of a single metal or something? Yeah, I know there's fluffy rock that makes us less dense.

Maybe it's like an alien engineering project, you know, it's some alien university, like make a planet out of concrete, or make a planet out of osmium or something.

Yeah, and see if it floats. Maybe there's a David Letterman in that planet with a very big budget for the his or her show exactly.

So I hope somebody got an a for that project.

And then there's another interesting planet that we found out there.

Right, So number two on the exoplanet density top ten is fifty five can create e This one is sixty percent larger than the Earth, so it's a bigger radius, but also about eight times the mass of the Earth, so about twice the density of the Earth, which gives it the density of about lead. You know, that's the average density, which means that probably near the surface it's less dense, and in the core it's much much more dense. And it's really fun to think about like how these planets came to be. Was there a huge blob of metal that formed a planet or are there other processes that we don't understand that contribute to planetary formation. You know, we're also able to image protoplanetary discs, like we look far enough back in time, which means looking at things far away, you can see planets forming. We can see stars with disks around them, not just planets. Those are actually easier to spot than planets because the discs are much bigger.

Well, this one's interesting because it's also eight times the mass of the Earth, but it's only twice the density as opposed to like ten times the density.

Yeah, and so it might be made out of less dense stuff. You know, it might have a lot of water in it. We just don't know.

Interesting, and we can use some of these facts sometimes to figure out which are maybe habitable planets, right, Like, we don't want to land in a Jupiter or Saturn because that would be probably not livable for us. And we don't want to live in a maybe like a Mercury, right, We want to live in a planet maybe that's similar to Earth in density exactly.

If you're planning an interstellar road trip, then you probably want to target a rocky planet. It's more likely to have water on the surface of it, for example, to be in what we call the habitable zone. If you're just wondering about what's possible for planets, you want, if you're a scientist, and you want to visit the craziest planets out there, then yeah, you want to find stuff with really low density or really high density to help like inform your models of the universe. But it's amazing how much you can learn about a planet just by understanding its density.

Right, but then using information that we know from our solar system to kind of extrapolate and say, hey, that one's probably ice or rocky or gassing.

Yeah, exactly ready, and our knowledge of how these elements work, and our models for planetary formation, which come of course from what we've learned in our solar system.

So SCIGN is good.

But you know, I'm sure we're wrong about a lot of how this works. And if we ever do get to visit these solar systems in detail, we will find planets that make us go, what, how is that even possible?

We were totally wrong? All right, Well that's kind of a pretty good lesson, I think, as you say, of why it's important even to study our backyard, or why it's important to have curiosity about these things, because you know, the more you learn about how solar systems form and how planets form and what the terms density, the more you can learn about the rest of the universe with limited information, right.

Mm hmm, And it tells you something about our own history, which is fascinating in its own right. Something happened early in our solar system to make Earth bigger and more massive than Venus and mercury, and that's why it wins the crown today.

All right, Well, that was a pretty dense episode. I guess you can make it denser by playing it twice as fast or increasing the playback speed. You have control over the density of your podcast experience.

You know, we often talk about people playing the podcast at higher speeds. I wonder if there are people out there who play us at like ho speed.

To make us more fluffy.

Yeah, like spread it out like butter on toast, you.

Know, right right, But that would also spread out your chuckles, so it'd be more sinister, be more like.

I try to make my chuckles pure and innocent.

Well, we hope you enjoyed that. Thanks for joining us, See you next time.

Thanks for listening, and remember that. Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe is a production of iHeart Radio. For more podcasts from iHeart Radio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.

Have you boosted your business with Lenovo Pro yet? Become a Lenovo Pro member for free today and unlock access to Lenovo's exclusive business store for technology expert advisors and essential products and services designed just for you. Visit Lenovo dot com slash Lenovo Pro to sign up for free. That's Lenovo dot com slash Lenovo Pro. Lenovo unlock new AI experiences with Lenovo's think Pad x one carbon powered by Intel Core ultraprocessors.

When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. How is us dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digestors to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit you as dairy dot COM's Last sustainability to learn more. Beverly Hills Emergency, somebody kill my pa.

I don't know.

I came home and I found.

Them from the creators of Dahmer.

Okay, here's the shoot first, so that you don't back out.

Okay, based on the horrific true events.

I'm never gonna do this.

Yeah, The Monsters.

The Lyel and Eric Menendez Story coming September nineteenth, only on Netflix.

Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe

A fun-filled discussion of the big, mind-blowing, unanswered questions about the Universe. In each e 
Social links
Follow podcast
Recent clips
Browse 636 clip(s)