Daniel and Jorge Explain the UniverseWhat are fast radio bursts and what causes them?
Learn about the mystery behind fast radio bursts with Daniel and Jorge
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield savings account through Apple Card, apply for Applecard in the wallet app subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch, Member FDIC terms and more at applecard dot Com. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. How is US Dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digesters to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit us dairy dot COM's Last Sustainability to learn more.
As a United Explorer Card, you can earn fifty thousand bonus miles plus look Forward to extraordinary travel rewards, including a free checked bag, two times the miles on United purchases and two times the miles on dining and at hotels. Become an explorer and seek out unforgettable places while enjoying rewards everywhere you travel. Cards issued by JP Morgan Chase Bank NA Member FDIC subject to credit approval offer subject to change.
Terms apply. Hey, Hora, I have a question for you about how you use your microwave.
It's about how I am preparing my dinner on it or not.
No, this is about whether you wait for it to stop and ding, or whether you impatiently yank the door open before it's finished.
Yeah.
I think sometimes I open it without waiting for it to end. Is that bad? Am I going to get irradiated? It's that dangerous.
It's not dangerous to you, Is.
It dangerous for my pets or my dinner?
Everybody in your house is perfectly safe. But you might be ruining the life of some graduate students nearby if they're running a particularly sensitive science experiment.
Well, they're welcome to come share in my popcorn.
Hi.
I'm Hoge. I'm a cartoonist and the creator of PhD Comics.
Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist, and I always wait for the ding.
Well, wait no more, and welcome to our podcast Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe, a production of iHeartRadio.
In which we look around the universe and try to explain it to you. We find crazy, interesting, amazing, mind blowing stuff that scientists hardly understand and try to bring you to that forefront of misunderstanding.
That's right, all the weird and unexplained phenomena out there, and also safety tip for your microwave oven usage.
That's right. We dove into details of how microwaves work on a recent episode, but today we're going to talk about how microwaves might ruin everything for science.
It's one of these physics destroys the universe kind of things like will my microwave collapse the Higgs field somehow?
No?
No, maybe microwaves will save the universe by stymying physics. Right, what if with your microwave of and you could stop the LHC from operating?
Is that a setting? Maybe I missed That setting is like reheat defrost ruined science? You know.
That brings up a good point because microwaves have so many settings that I think probably nobody ever uses, right, only people only ever use them, like the popcorn button and the like add one minute button.
Yeah. I always wondering if there's like a secret code, you know, like video You know how some video games have like a special sequence you can unlock special.
Oh yeah, up, up, down, down, left, right aabb and all of a sudden, you're playing video games on your microwave.
Yeah, there you go.
I'm sure, I'm sure, but no, microwaves don't hold secrets to the universe, but they have been known to stymy the progress of physics, and that's what we're going to be talking about today.
Yeah, and it ties into how sometimes, you know, how sensitive sometimes science is.
That's right. If you want to listen to something which came all the way from the other side of the universe, you have to listen very carefully. And that means you're going to be listening to tiny little signals from space, and also every signal from Earth nearby is going to be trying to drown that out. So scientists have to get really good at figuring out all the other things that could mimic their signal. All the terrestrial sources of noise.
You have to get really good at telling everyone else to turn other cell phones.
Basically, that's right. Scientists are like those grumpy neighbors telling you to turn down your music, except they want you to turn down everything.
So to the under program, we'll be talking about radio burths or fast and mysterious were you burths?
That's right?
What's the official title of these?
I think they're called fast radio burths, but they are definitely mysterious, and a bunch of listeners have written in and said, please explain fast radio verse to us, So here we are.
Are they also furious? That would be pretty pretty good branding Fast and Furious radioburthse.
No, because then they owe money to vin Diesel every single time we mentioned it.
That would be a movie, right, that's what you should do. That'd be like Fast and the Furious seventeen. They go into a radio telescope and drive it around the telescope.
You know, I love those movies because every single one they somehow managed to like one up the previous one. You know, the last one they had a submarine. Here they have like a helicopter with a submarine attached to it, swinging around a rocket ship. It's incredible.
Do your physic senses cringe when you watch these movies?
No? No, they usually get the physics pretty much accurate on those movies. You know, there's no science here. It's mostly just trajectories and explosions. Yeah, it's pretty accurate.
Yeah. So there's something called fast radio waves and they are kind of mysterious, right, nobody knows where they come from.
That's right. Nobody knows where they come from, and there's sort of a recent mystery. They were discovered only twelve years ago by a summer student, like an undergrad. Have you ever had this science experience where you go to do a summer undergraduate project and somebody just says, here, go plow through all this data, maybe as a way to get rid of you, maybe as a way to just keep you busy, and nobody ever expects to accomplish anything. Well, this student did.
Well.
I can't say I've had the experience of being an undergrad scientist, but it's pretty cool to think, yeah, that someone who's that young can discover something nobody else had done before.
Yeah, exactly.
And it's cool to think we've discovered something as recently as two thousand and seven.
Absolutely, And it's just another example of how every time we look out into the universe we find weird stuff. The universe is just chock full of unexplained it's really bizarre phenomena. And each of them, each of them is a clue that there's something going on out there that we don't understand, some new type of objects, some new kind of physics, some new kind of life. Who knows. But each one is the universe sending us a message saying there's something here to learn.
There's something mysterious in your microwave. Open it, open it.
If you've been cooking that popcorn since two thousand and seven, then you're in trouble.
I'm still waiting for it to stop popping. You know, it still pops every once in a while.
Yeah. And the other lesson to be learned here is that while this was discovered by an undergraduate, his advisor got all the credit for it.
The undergrad got no credit.
Well, you know, the professor sent him off and said, hey, spend your SMA looking through this old data. Maybe you'll find something interesting. And then he came back with this saying, like, look at this huge weird pulse. I found what is that, and now it's named after the professor.
Well he did direct the student to look for it, so you know that's like, uh, that's obviously fair.
Yeah right, yeah, like Einstein's supervisor. Right, go be smart? All right, Well, now I get credit for all your discoveries.
Well, I had never heard of these fast radio burths, and much less any fast mysterious radio bursts. But we were wondering how many people out there had maybe maybe something that was in the news or something. Daniel went out and asked people on the street if they knew what a fast radio burse was.
That's right, several of our listeners were curious about it. But I was wondering, is this something that sort of seeped into the common understanding? Is this a mystery that people think about or have even heard about.
Yeah, so I think for a second, if random scruffy physicists approach you on the street and ask you, hey, what's a fast radio burst? How well would you say to your microphone. Here's what people had to say.
I have heard of it, but I don't know what it is.
I've heard of them. I couldn't tell you about them, but yes, I have.
Heard of them.
No, no, I'm not. Oh, all right, Not a lot of people knew about these fast udy births.
Yeah, pretty much zero. I mean some folks claim to have maybe heard of them, but I didn't really quiz them on it. I was being generous, So not a lot of I.
Mean you think that maybe they were lying, like maybe they were they hadn't really heard of it, but they were just trying to sound smart.
Yeah, maybe a little bit. You know, somebody talks about some brand new topic and science to you, you might notlong be like, oh, I think I heard about that. I'm not sure, or maybe just tickles some memory you had in your mind.
Anyway, nobody on this podcast every time Daniels, I'm just nodding along.
Well, you're doing a great job of faking it.
So most people had never heard of a fast ready verse exactly.
And so I hope that those folks out there who have never heard of fast radio urse will be amazed at what they learn today about this crazy, mysterious, amazing signal from the stars.
All right, so let's break it down now. So the name of it doesn't sound very complicated. I mean, it's just fast radio bursts. So I think I know what each of those words mean, but together they formed something mysterious.
Well, you're assuming that physicists have been clear in their naming and that you can sort of, you know, reverse engineer the concept from the name of it. So I'm proud, glad that you have such confidence in our skills.
Well, I'm just wondering how they were able to get this to the trademark office, you know, like it's such a generic name, fast radio bursts, you know. No, you're right, it's like trademarking brown table table cloths. You know.
I'm not sure it's been copyrighted or trademarked, but you know, for our upcoming movie starring Vin Diesel, then we'll definitely want to get on that.
Would you call it the Fast and the burst ty, Yeah.
Exactly, No, you're right, it's pretty straightforward. I mean, these are bursts of emissions in the radio spectrum, right, and remember radio waves are just one kind of electric magnetic radiation. You have radio waves down at the long wavelength part of the spectrum, and you've got visible light, you know, you know, hundreds of nanometers, and then you get up to X rays and GAMER rays. The very high energy is very small frequencies. So remember what you call it just depends on the frequency of the electromagnetic radiation we're talking about, and radio waves are down at the lower.
End, meaning that they are low frequency relatively speaking.
So these guys have really long wavelengths so have lower frequency. And these kind of radio waves that we're talking about there are like fourteen hundred megahertz.
So fourteen million times a second is the frequency of.
These waves, yeah, exactly. And you know that's the same kind of frequency as the electromagnetic radiation that's used to send you radio into your car, right, which is why we call them radio waves.
All right.
There are lots of sources of radio waves in the universe, right, like black holes make radio waves, the center of galaxies make radio waves, the Sun makes radio wave you know, Jupiter makes.
Radio wave, powers make radio waves exactly.
Vin Diesel, I think has his own radio station now. But there's lots of sources, and there's a huge field of radio astronomy, right and mostly these things are just sort of like pulsing out continuous radiation. But in two thousand and seven they heard for the first time this fast radio burst. So a burst means like it's not continuous. It's just like it's like somebody screaming in space. Right, it's very short lived.
That sounds a little horrific. So it's just so fast. Radio bursts just like a quick pulse, like a quick burst of these low frequency light waves.
Yeah, radio waves exactly. And by burst we mean like order milliseconds, right, It's not like gamma ray bursts that last, you know, two seconds or thirty seconds. These are milliseconds. So they're very very brief, which is why they were originally overlooked. You know, when this underground found them, he didn't like hear them for the first time. He went back into old days. He found this like it had already been recorded. The data was just sitting there. Nobody had looked through it and seen this before. It was very short lived, which I guess why I didn't trigger any alarms or anything. And it was just a once, one time event that he discovered.
You could listen to these on the radios. I mean like if you had the radio tune to the right frequency, you would hear a little every once in a while.
Yeah, you can do radio astronomy using your radio, right, you can listen to that kind of stuff. You can hear some of the static that you hear from radio is radio waves from the Sun or from Jupiter, or from the center of the galaxy. Right, space is filled with this kidding, and some of them get down to Earth. Wow. Yeah, so you can listen to the universe. The sound of the universe is shh. Doesn't have great rhythm.
The universe is telling you to shut up. You know.
This is a burst of energy. And it's not that loud, Like, it's not like this was a huge spike that he noticed. It was a little bit of a blip. You know, it's not a very loud, but it's above the general noise. Right, it was large enough to be seen above the just the sort of radio noise you get from the Sun or Jupiter, from the center of the galaxy. And it was odd. And so he asked this advisor, he said, you know, what's this? What could make this? And the guy had no idea. You know, we had never seen such a short lived pulse of energy.
So this undergrad was combing through some data and he saw these little blips, like all of a sudden, this the signal at that frequency kind of jumped.
Yeah, but just one blip, just one blip. Yeah, exactly, and you got to wonder, like, what is this summer project? You just like gave them a pilot data and said, look through this, see if you find anything.
You've never done that, Daniel, I don't.
Do that to my students. No, I give them like supervision. I tell I set them up, I tell them like, try this, try that. I'm just say like, that's like saying, go to the basement if the library, figure it out, see if you find anything interesting. You know, you got to give them some more direction than that. But this kid actually found something amazing. Yeah, maybe you should try it right next summer. I'm sending all my students to the basement of the library just combed through random particle physic data.
You might find some new phenomenon named after you.
I'm just going to print out all the LEDC data into a huge pile and tell them to comb through it.
No.
So there was this short lived pulse, right, and he didn't understand it. He'd never seen anything like it before. They were very curious about it, but it was the only one anybody'd ever seen. So they started going back and looking through old data to see could they.
Find more and did they.
They did, but then they ran into a bit of a snag. See, a lot of people were wondering, like, where's this come from? How do you know that this actually comes from space? Right, and it doesn't just come from like some other source of noise, Because there's huge numbers of sources of radio waves, right, like all the radio stations on Earth. Right, So before you can conclude that something really is astronomical, you have to rule out everything else, and there.
Aren't like maybe at the local radio station, the DJ accidentally hit the the bun and created these little pulses.
Yeah, although you know in this frequency range, radio stations don't emit, and you know, radio stations have a certain frequency range that they're allowed to transmit on, and this one in particular was reserved for radio astronomy, right, so the night the sky is supposed to be quiet in this frequency so that we can listen to the universe. But you know, there are known sources and interference here and there, and nobody'd ever seen this kind of thing, so they had to try to sort of track it down. And when they were looking through the old data, they found a bunch of them from this one observatory in Australia the park's observatory.
So what do you mean, like everybody started looking through their old data, or this was done in Australia.
Everybody started looking through their old data. But the folks in Australia looked through theirs and they found a whole bunch of these little blips, and they thought, well, there's no way that these are all astronomical. And because of the way the antenna was pointed, they got a clue that some of these blips might actually be from something nearby. Cast a huge shadow on the initial discovery. People thought, well, if these blips they're seeing in Australia are just something here on Earth, then one of the chances that this two thousand and seven discovery is actually some weird signal from space.
Yeah, let's talk about that a little bit more. But first quick break.
With big wireless providers, what you see is never what you get. Somewhere between the store and your first month's bill, the price you thought you were paying magically skyrockets. With mint Mobile, you'll never have to worry about gotcha's ever again. When mint Mobile says fifteen dollars a month for a three month plan, they really mean it. I've used mint Mobile and the call quality is always so crisp and so clear. I can recommend it to you. So say bye bye to your overpriced wireless plans, jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages. You can use your own phone with any mint Mobile plan and bring your phone number along with your existing contacts. So did your overpriced wireless with mint mobiles deal and get three months a premium wireless service for fifteen bucks a month. To get this new customer offer in your new three month premium wireless plan for just fifteen bucks a month, go to mintmobile dot com slash universe. That's mintmobile dot com slash universe. Cut your wireless build a fifteen bucks a month at mintmobile dot com slash universe. Forty five dollars upfront payment required equivalent to fifteen dollars per month new customers on first three month plan only speeds slower about forty gigabytes. On unlimited plan. Additional taxi speeds and restrictions apply. See mint mobile for details.
AI might be the most important new computer technology ever. It's storming every industry and literally billions of dollars are being invested. So buckle up. The problem is that AI needs a lot of speed and processing power, So how do you compete without cost spiraling out of control. It's time to upgrade to the next generation of the cloud. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure or OCI. OCI is a single platform for your infrastructure, database, application development, and AI needs. OCI has four to eight times the bandwidth of other clouds, offers one consistent price instead of variable regional pricing, and of course nobody does data better than Oracle. So now you can train your AI models at twice the speed and less than half the cost of other clouds. If you want to do more and spend less, like Uber eight by eight and Data Bricks Mosaic, take a free test drive of OCI at Oracle dot com slash Strategic. That's Oracle dot com slash Strategic Oracle dot com slash Strategic.
If you love iPhone, you'll love Applecard. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield savings account through Applecard, apply for Applecard in the wallet app. Subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Applecard owners subject to eligibility Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch Member FDIC, terms and more at applecard dot com.
So what do you mean the way the antenna was pointed like it was pointing downwards or you know, to my house or somebody's house, or what do you mean?
The biggest clue to understanding where something comes from is when do you see it? Right? Do you see it when you're pointing at the sky. Do you see it when you're pointing always the same direction on Earth? Or do you see it when you're like always pointing at the same thing in the sky. Like if you point your antenna at the same star and then you always see a signal, you wonder or maybe it comes from that star. But if you're antenna is if you always see the signal when you're pointed at, like you know, some nearby building, then you wonder if it comes from that building. And so in this case, the head clues from when they saw these signals that it might be coming from something nearby instead of from something in space because it didn't correlate to any particular direction in space.
Oh, I see, so it looks like if you hear voices in your head, no matter which way you're standing or who you're surrounded by, then maybe the voices are not coming from outside of your head.
No, that's a perfect analogy. That's a perfect analogy. So they started to worry that maybe some of these things were coming from something nearby. I mean, the guys are not insane, they're not coming from actually inside their head. But they had to try to track this down, and it took them years and years and years, but they finally figured out that one of the sources of these things was not actually astronomical crazy stuff happening out there in space, but it was the staff at the observatory going on break.
They correlated the times. But here we're just talking about that one observatory in Australia, right, not the one found by the undergrad That's right.
The one in Australia had a bunch of these and so people thought, well, you know, maybe none of these things are real. Then they figured out that they would see a very similar kind of pulse when the staff at this observatory in Australia would heat up their food on break and open the door to the microwave before it stopped cooking, and there was this brief moment of interference like you know when you open the door of the microwave. Of course the microwave shuts off, but this is like a little blip, little blip of radiation that comes at it's not dangerous levels, but it is enough to interfere with the operation of a super sensitive ear. Right, that's what a telescope is, it's a super sensitive ear. And so they correlated this to when those guys were going on break and they verified it, like went over the microwave and tried it, and they could tell that that's what was creating some of those signatures.
So it was picking up the actual microwaves coming from the oven or just like the act of shutting down the microwave emitter in their oven when you open the door, that somehow creates you know, emidst radiation in this weird frequency.
No, it's a little bit of microwave energy that actually escaped. Yeah, and if you waited for the to ding and the microwave turned off before you opened it, then none of it escaped. But if you just yanked the door opened before it was finished, and this little blip would sneak out and that's what would cause some of these fake astronomical signals.
So my microwave operates at the same time frequency, says radio.
It's enough to interfere. Yeah, exactly. The frequency spectrums overlap a little bit. And it was hard to pin down because you know, sometimes the staff would let the microwave ding and other times they were a little more impatient and they would yank it open. So it wasn't like every single day at six pm.
It was like that one guy or the one woman just you know, Bob or Sally, that just the impatient, impatient one in the staff that just was making all this fuzz for everybody.
Yeah, exactly. I remember when this paper came out. It was like twenty fifteen. The paper came out when they identified the source of these things as literally like microwave background. And you know, because we have this other thing in physics called the cosmic microwave background, there were a lot of jokes about Australian microwave background versus cosmic microwave background, like this is literally a background due to microwaves in Australia.
So they actually polished this. They said, we had a bunch of signals, but it turned out to be Bob with the micro exactly.
No, it's a hilarious paper, and you know, it's a nice piece of work. You know, you under you got to really dig into your your signal sometime and understand where they come from. And the folks, for example Ligo, the ones looking for gravitational waves, they do similar sort of stuff. They have to understand like traffic.
Paths, microwave too early.
Yeah, well, everything affects them. They're looking for tiny little shakes, so they have to understand like, oh, at this time of day, big trucks tend to roll by, and that shakes it in this certain way and blah blah slams the door nearby two miles away. They're super sensitive, so they have to catalog all the sources of noise before they can identify something as a signal. So in the same way you see a weird signal on your data, you got to try to rule out, you know, prosaic explanations, and this was one. And so until they did that, people didn't really believe that fast radio bursts might actually be an astronomical thing because of this explanation. But once they isolated this explanation, they are able to remove those. They could tell which ones came microwave ovens and which ones didn't. Then people started to believe, Okay, maybe these other ones you know from other observatories actually are something astronomical.
You mean the ones that were found by the undergrad or did people find other ones?
The one found by the undergrad people now think is believable. And people have been combing through data and they found just under a hundred other examples.
Of mysterious fast radiobursts.
Yeah, exactly. And now that we've removed you know, Bob's microwave usage is an explanation for some of them, we can start to believe that these really do come from space.
All right, So Bob did something good.
Bob delayed the understanding of radio bursts for at least five years, So I'm not sure you can give them any positive points for that.
By creating an artifice, it kind of sharpened scientist's ears. So now they can sort of tell when something is artificial or not. And so now maybe you have more confidence that the ones you've seen are actually mysteriou is radio burs from space?
Yeah, I'm amazed at your ability to spin that into a positive story. Yes, nicely done.
Well, Bob slit me a hundred, So put in a good word for her.
Bob or Bob's sister. Whoever did this needs a serious reputation rehabilitation program. No, but since then, we've identified something on the order of one hundred or just less of these examples in data from around the world.
All right, well, let's get into what could be making these mysterious radio burths and whether or not you should wait for the ding in your microwave. But first, let's take a quick break.
When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth or enjoy a rich spoonful of greeky yogurt, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact of each and every bite. But the people in the dairy industry are US. Dairy has set themselves some ambitious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times the same water cools the milk cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneuver into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit us dairy dot com slash sustainability to learn more.
There are children, friends, and families walking, riding on passing the roads every day. Remember they're real people with loved ones who need them to get home safely. Protect our cyclists and pedestrians because they're people too, Go safely California From the California Office of Traffic Safety and Caltrans.
Stay Farming, DJ damos from Life as a Gringo No Making smarter financial moves today, Secures of financial freedom for successful tomorrow.
Tackle these situations in stride and y. Of course, be annoyed when planned expense comes up, but not let it be something that slows me down, right, And also as I did with repairing my credit, you know, hiring somebody to do credit repair for me. You know, that was a gift that I gave myself that allowed me to then you know, get my first apartment, get you know, my first car under my name, then eventually buy my own home. Like, these are all things that.
Are possible for all of us.
We just have to educate ourselves and put in some of the hard work that it takes to unlearn bad practices we might have, you know, inherited from our family, and then also educate ourselves on the things that we don't know, you know, the information that wasn't passed down to us because our parents weren't educating on these things, like.
A good neighbor.
State farm?
Is there?
State Farm?
Proud sponsor of Michutura podcast Network, right, I know. So what can make these mysterious fast radioburths? We were hearing them from space. We're pretty sure it's not Bob with the microwave accidentally causing this noise. So something must have caused these one hundred weird signals that we.
See something or someone right, that's always the question, dum, you know what you do in astronomy, I guess not being an astronomer. Is you like you see some new weird signal and then you look through your category, you look through your catalog of stuff in the universe and ask could this make that noise? Could this make that noise? And there's nothing out there that we know of, And there's a lot of crazy stuff out there making all sorts of strange signals, but none of the things that we are aware of can make this kind of pulse.
What do you mean nothing you're aware of? Like doesn't the sun make radiation and radio ways? Or you know what I mean, Like, how do you know that the Sun isn't making these birds?
Yeah, well they're not coming from the direction of the sun, right, and they come from all over the sky. And if you ask, like where do they come from in general, they don't even come in general from the direction of the Milky Way. Like, if there was something from our galaxy, then need to expect it to come from something sort of in the plane of the Milky Way. You know that band of stars you see like dribbled across the sky. If it's something from our galaxy, some like weird kind of star in our galaxy, you'd expect to see it more in the direction in the Milky Way, but we don't. We see it in all sorts of directions, which means it's most likely coming from outside our galaxy. They're definitely not all coming from the Sun. Let's be easy to figure out.
You know, they're not coming from our galaxy. So it must be something super far away, which means at the origin it must be like a super powerful burst.
To be able to hear something. To be able to see a signal from so far away means that it has to be incredibly intense at its source. Remember these other galaxies. I mean, our galaxy is huge, right, it's one hundred thousand light years across, But these other galaxies millions of light years away. And you know, if we send a signals to those galaxies, even if we directed it, you would be pretty pretty hard for anybody to hear it, because these signals drop by one over the distance squared, So you go twice as far, the signal is four times as quiet. You go a thousand times as far right, and the signals this million times quieter. So to be able to hear it from so far away exactly means that at the source it has to be crazy intense, and we also just don't know anything intense, crazy intense and very brief sort of sad trombone sounds.
What do you mean as a sad trombone.
Well, if you look at the frequencies, the frequency sort of shift. It's not like a single frequency. It starts off at a higher frequency and then it drops quickly to a lower frequency. So it sort of sounds like a sad trombone, you know, like a wom oh. I see.
So maybe it's just the universe of providing a soundtrack to my to my comedy.
Every time you make a bad joke, we hear a fast radio burst. We'd be hearing a lot more of them, that's all I got to say.
That's right, every time I say a bad joke, you know, got up there, it hits the button and the audience gets a little yeah. So how powerful are these then.
Well, we're not exactly sure. Some of them we've located, like a few of them have repeated, so we've been able to like spot exactly where they're coming from because it came because we've heard them more than once but estimates are that they have as much energy in just one of these pulses as our sun puts out in eighty years of burning. Right, So it's frying you, it's causing summer, it's you know, toasting mercury. All that energy put out by the Sun over eighty years. Concentrate that into a few milliseconds. That's the amount of energy we're talking about.
If what we're hearing is coming from another galaxy, then that's how powerful it must be when it happens. It must be like some kind of explosion or some big event.
It's definitely some kind of big event. And you know, we don't have a whole lot of data because we only have, like, you know, less than one hundred examples, and each one is really brief. You don't have a lot of information on each one. It's not like you have a long, extended tale you can study. But we can do really clever tricks. We can like ask, like, you know, what's the arrival time in this frequency versus the other frequency, and we can use that to think about like how it propagates through the universe, because different kinds of stuff in the universe allow different frequency signals to propagate at different speeds or block them or whatever. So we have these things. It's called the dispersion measure that tells us like how spread out is the signal? And all these things are totally consistent with the really small source, really really really far away. What do you mean a small source, meaning that the thing that makes these can't be really big. It's not like an entire galaxy is emitting this thing. It's something that's like a few hundred kilometers across.
Wait, how do we know this?
Because of the way that's sort of the shape of a pulse. Right of all, it's really really short, right, So if you have some huge object that's creating a signal and it's really enormous, then you're going to hear a longer signal just because if it comes from the back of it, it'll take longer to get to you, right, But if it comes from a tiny little source like a point or something like a meter across, then it's possible to create a really really tight signal. And so because this thing only lasts a millisecond, then it can give us a sense like a rough an order magnitude estimate for the size of the object that's.
Making it something really big makes a really big pulse. Then you know, just the physics of it wouldn't allow it to create something so sharp.
Yeah, exactly, you need something really small to create a really sharp signature. And you know, this is the kind of thing we do in physics. We're like, let's squeeze as much information as we can out of this tiny little bit of data. And so that's what we know. It's something super far away, kind of small and really intense, and there's just nothing in our catalog of knowledge that's capable of producing that.
Let's jump right into what could it be? Aliens?
You know, aliens are on the top of my list for sure.
A Zeus. I think you always put aliens at the top of your list. Daniels.
So, no, astrophysicist a very creative bunch. And so what they do when they're sitting in front of this kind of mystery is they try to get creative and they say, well, what if we take something which is capable of creating radio waves and is really intensely powerful, like a magnetar. You remember what a magnetar is. It's a super category of neutron star, right, a neutron star that's.
Spins different than a minotaur, right.
That's right, it's a it's at the center of the maze. No, it's a pulsar that's super duper powerful and has a crazy magnetic field. And they're looking at things that have a lot of magnetic fields because this is em radiation. So they're thinking maybe it's some like weird twist and magnetic field that's the magnetic field buckles and shocks or whatever, and that creates these pulses. And so one category of ideas is like, maybe it's like an earthquake on the surface of a magnetar that creates like a little burst of energy, a little shock wave of energy.
What.
Yeah, And even.
That's not a quake on the surface of a star.
Yeah, starquakes, right, that sounds like an awesome science fiction novel starquake.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And so they call these things hyper flares when a magnetar just like bursts out a big explosion of energy. But even those hypers get.
Cracks somehow, yeah, you know, like a yeah, like it cracks or like it it shifts.
Yeah, we'll think about what happens in an earthquake exactly. These the plates rub up against each other and you get a release of energy. So it's not an exact analogy to what's happening on the surface of this magnetar and another galaxy, but it's it's similar. And even that the calculations suggest is not enough to power these things. So now they're thinking about like one happens, and then maybe another one follows it, and the two interfere in this way that gives this first one a boost. I mean, they're having to really really reach to the bottom of the barrel here to come up with explanations for what might explain these things. And there are other models as models, like maybe it's some strange thing that happens when a black hole eats a neutron star, although by now we've seen a few of those with our gravitational wave detectors, and they don't always come with fast radio bursts, so I think that explanation is not as popular.
But the signals from the gravitational waves are sort of similar, aren't they aren't They also like a sad trombone and also really short.
Yeah, but they have a sort of a ring down effect. They're like a woh woh woh, woh, woh woh woh, and I think they're longer than just a few milliseconds, but actually I don't remember the details. Another explanation, which I love only because the name is awesome, is people think it might be this kind of star called a blitzar blitz. Yeah, a blitzer is.
The name named after a wolf Blitzer.
Yeah, of course. You know, you're in the situation room and you got to come up with an explanation, and so you reach the blitzer.
And your beard just radiates energy and they called it the blitzer.
That's right, And that's going to be the plot for the next movie with Vin Diesel and Wolf Blitzer.
Right there, you go, fasten. The blitzy.
Blitzer is a special kind of pulsar that sometimes collapses and turns into a black hole. And I don't know why they call it a blitzer, but they think that maybe when that happens, perhaps it releases this kind of energy. But you know, people are really stretching.
When it's becoming a black hole. It cries out one less blitz.
Yeah, exactly, it's like it maybe that's where it comes from. It's the death rattle of a pulsar.
Perhaps, all right, but that's just one possibility, another possibility, and what else could it be.
Well, there are other crazy ideas, like maybe it's some strange quantum mechanical effect. You know, there are really weird quantu me canic things that happen in every star, Like you know, how does light get from the inside of a star out into the universe? Right? That requires quantum mechanical things like tunneling, which we talked about in another podcast episode. And so some people have come up with this strange quant mechanical entanglement effect called super radiance, when a big blob of the star sort of gets entangled. And this could happen like if you're really close to the center of a galaxy, and when a big blob of stuff becomes sort of quantum mechanical on a macroscopic scale, that can do things that the individual blobs not can't necessarily. And one of the ideas is this super radiance that they could emit huge pulse of energy all at once. But this is really one of the more fringe theories.
Wait, the idea is that the whole sun, the whole star sort of becomes quantum synchronized or something.
The idea not the whole star, that would be cool, but sort of a large blob of it, you know, and a large blob is one hundred kilometers or something, so that would be pretty awesome. We do sort of similar experiments on Earth. It's related Bose Einstein condensates our materials, where a bunch of stuff has the same quantum state, and so this has a macroscopic properties.
But those are usually super tiny, aren't they aren't they like the size of a of a few atoms or something.
Yeah, we've never succeeded in building one that's you know, that's really macroscopic. That's like, you know, meters wide for sure. I know we never never achieved that. But there is a relationship between that kind of thing and these sort of super radiance effects. But all this is all just speculation. And the thing I love about this is we have the data, right, This is not just people sitting around thinking, maybe this happens inside of stars. Maybe this thing, let's difficult, give this thing this funny name. Here, we're trying to explain something real, right. The universe is telling us there's this new weird thing out there you do not know about. And it's a clue, right, It's a clue that we have to unravel in decades to come, somebody will understand what causes these things, and it could be something new and amazing and crazy, or it could just be like, you know, some new phase of the life of a neutron.
Star, and you're pretty sure it's not Bob with the microwave down in the kitchen.
Look, Bob's been fired, okay, so he's not creating any problem for me.
He went to work somewhere else, or she went to work somewhere else.
No, they're much more careful now with the microwaves at radio astronomy facilities. But though that is one of the funnest papers I've ever read. No, they've ruled out.
But it could be. It could be an alien, an alien Bob somewhere else in the universe opening its giant super radiant Blitzer star early too early before the ding causing these things.
You know, I've never heard that explanation. I think you might have solved this right here live on the podcast.
Or good Nobel prize please please.
Yeah, the Nobel Prize for that one is just a bag of popcorn.
Actually, it was my undergrad who came up with that expanence. But I am taking all the credit.
At least share the popcorn with him, will you?
All right? So that yet another incredible mystery out there in the universe that we are pretty sure is there, but we can't explain what is causing it.
That's right. The universe is telling us here's a clue, there's something weird, you don't understand, figure it out, and it's We're only a decade in and we still basically have no idea what this thing is.
So the next time you reheat something in your microwave, for the love of science, please wait for it to ding.
All of science. Thanks you for your patience. If you still have a question after listening to all these explanations, please drop us a line. We'd love to hear from you. You can find us at Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram at Daniel and Jorge That's one word, or email us at Feedback at Danielandhorge dot com. Thanks for listening, and remember that Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth. You're probably not thinking about the environmental impact, but the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. House US dairy tackling greenhouse gases. Many farms use anaerobic digestors to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit you as dairy dot COM's Last Sustainability to learn more.
There are children, friends, and families walking, riding on passing the roads every day. Remember they're real people with loved ones who need them to get home safely. Tact our cyclists and pedestrians because they're people too, Go safely. California from the California Office of Traffic Safety and Caltrans.
We're Paint Care and we're all about keeping it simple.
We make recycling leftover paint easy with convenient locations like your local paint store.
We have three simple rules for painting smarter and reducing waste. One buy only what you need. Two use up what you already have, and three recycle the rest.
Visit paintcare dot org slash three simple rules to learn more or find a paint drop off site near you,
