Black Hole Questions!

Published Oct 14, 2021, 5:00 AM

Daniel and Jorge answer listener questions about black holes

Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield Savings account through Apple Card, apply for Applecard in the wallet app subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch, Member FDIC terms and more at applecard dot Com. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. How is US Dairy tackling greenhouse gases? Many farms use anaerobic digesters to turn the methane from manure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit us dairy dot COM's Last Sustainability to learn more.

Everyone, It's me Katiekuric. You know, lately, I've been overwhelmed by the whole wellness industry. So much information out there about flaxed pelvic floor serums and anti aging, so I launched a newsletter. It's called Body and Soul to share expert approved advice for your physical and mental health. And guess what, It's free. Just sign up at Katiecuric dot com slash Body and Soul. That's k A T I E c O U r ic dot com slash Body and Soul. I promise it will make you happier and healthier.

Guess what will?

What's that?

Mago?

I've been trying to write a promo for our podcast, Part Time Genius, but even though we've done over two hundred and fifty episodes, we don't really talk about murderers or cults.

I mean, we did just cover the Illuminati of cheese, so I feel like that makes us pretty edgy. We also solve mysteries like how Chinese is your Chinese food? And how do dollar stores make money? And then, of course can you game a dog show? So what you're saying is everyone should be listening. Listen to Part Time Genius on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Hey, it's horehand Daniel here, and we want to tell you about our new book.

It's called Frequently ask Questions about the Universe.

Because you have questions about the universe, and so we decided to write a book all about them.

We talk about your questions, we give some answers, we make a bunch of silly.

Jokes as usual, and we tackle all kinds of questions, including what happens if I fall into a black hole? Or is there another version of you out there that's right?

Like usual, we tackle the deepest, darkest, biggest, craziest questions about this incredible cosmos.

So if you want to support the podcast, please get the book and get a copy of not just for yourself, but you know, for your nieces and nephews, cousins, friends, parents, dogs, hamsters, and.

For the aliens. So get your copy of Frequently Asked Questions about the Universe is available for pre order now, coming out November two. You can find more details at the book's website universe faq dot com.

Thanks for your support, and if you have a hamster that can read, please let us know. We'd love to have them on the podcast.

Hey, Jorgey, why do you think we get so many questions about black holes.

Mm, well, you know it's the mystery. You know, they're so inscrutable.

They're like the reclusive celebrities of the.

Universe exactly right, Like the more they avoid the paparazzi, the more people want to know about them.

That could be true, But I was actually wondering if it might be the exact opposite.

Hmmm, what do you mean?

Well, what if black holes are like the car crash of the universe. They're like a cosmic disaster that you can't drive by without slowing down to check it out.

Arey saying physicists are just rubberneckers, cosmic rubberneckers. That sounds kind of dangerous, like you might cause another accident by not watching where you were driving your spaceship.

Exactly. That's the gravitational runaway effects of the black holes. Slow down to check it out, get sucked in, make a big black hole.

That's how I feel about driving in Los Angeles. It's like an infinite black hole that you will never escape. I am Jorge Made, cartoonist and the creator of PhD comics.

Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist and a professor at UC Irvine. But I almost never go up to Los Angeles.

Really do you avoid it like a black hole.

If it was a black hole, it would suck me in. So yeah, I'm trying to stay in orbit around Los Angeles instead of falling into the singularity.

Yes, where time slows down through plastic surgery apparently. But yeah, I mean you're kind of famous now, Daniel. You don't get calls from Hollywood these days.

I screened my calls, so if they're calling, I'm just not picking them up.

You look for the aera code. If it's your local aer code, it's spam. If it's three and oh, then it's someone from Hollywood, like Jorge, so you just up.

Also, you know, there's famous and then there's Los Angeles famous. You could be like super famous in Orange County and be nobody in Los Angeles.

But anyways, welcome to our podcast, Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe, a production of iHeartRadio, in which.

We ask all the biggest and famous and most time dilated questions of the universe. We ask all of them about it, where it came from, where it's going, what it's made out of, and how it all works. We dive deep into the questions about black holes and neutron stars and galaxies and tiny particles and qoisars and everything in between, because we think it's possible to download all of that into your amazing brain and hold for a moment an understanding of the entire universe.

Yeah, because it is a pretty famous universe. Everyone seems to know about it. Everyone's a fan. I would hope you know, it's everywhere he goes he can get away from this universe, and it's pretty fascinating, even its black sheep. You know, everyone wants to know about the black sheep of the celebrities.

Yes, have you been checking out the universe's reviews on Yelp?

Yes, I think it has about infinite and also infinite thumbs. But you know it's about fifty to fifty up and down, that's.

Right, And you know nobody has any other alternatives. It's not like people like, hey, I was in this other universe the other day and they have better chips. So you know, this is basically all we got learn to love at people.

Maybe you just need to get out more, Daniel. You might find other universes if you just, you know, get out of your Orange County bubble.

La does seem like another universe sometimes not just because it's weird, but because it takes forever to get there.

Definitely an alternate reality for sure. But anyways, Yeah, people are curious not just about the universe but about the things in it, especially the things that are extra mysterious.

And those are the things that dry physics. We look around in the universe and we say, do we understand how this works? Does that bit over there make sense? And if it doesn't, then we focus our brains on and try to understand how could that possibly work? How could that make sense? How could that be consistent with what we know about the nature of space and time and energy, And so the weirdest things are also the best opportunities to learn something about the universe.

Yeah, because when you look around, I guess it's all pretty bright and beautiful and majestic and cosmic. But every once in a while, when you look at into the universe, there is basically a big hole, like a big hole in our knowledge and also literally figuratively and in all the ways there are actual holes in the universe.

There are holes in the universe, and you know, to answer the question of our intro I think one reason that they're fascinating is because they are so different from what we experience. You know, it's not just like, hey, there's a banana out there in space, like we know bananas, we eat bananas, We're familiar with bananas. You know. It's something out there in space which is so different from our everyday experience, so bizarre that we just sort of like want to see it.

Yeah, so today on the podcast, we'll be tackling unanswered questions about black holes. Now, Daniel, I assume it's not just bananas out there.

We don't know, you know, maybe bananas are the fundamental element of the universe and it is just all bananas all the way down. That's viable theory.

Sounds like a slippery slope there.

We just got to peel back the layers of reality until we reveal the banana inside.

But yeah, black holes. A lot of people have questions about black holes. And you were asking me earlier why they're so mysterious. Like everyone, you get a lot of questions about black holes.

Right, Yeah, I say like a third of all the questions we get are about black holes. What happens if you fall in them? What would they look like if you did this, What would happen if you shoot two black holes at each other? All sorts of questions people love to think about black holes.

Interesting a third of the questions, that's amazing. It's like it's own black hole in your inbox.

It does make my inbox pretty dense. But I love it. I love thinking about black holes just as much as our listeners do for the same reasons, you know. And the cool thing about black holes is that we all understand them about as well. You know. I love that we can bring our listeners to the very forefront of knowledge, because in the case of black holes, it's not that far away. You know. We just don't understand very much about these weird, mysterious objects. I think that's why they're so fascinating to physicists, because they represent such a great opportunity to learn something new and shocking about the universe.

Yeah, So today we're answering questions that we've gotten in about black holes from listen Earth just like you. And we've got three pretty interesting questions, one of them about the mass of a black hole, about mini black holes, and also about whether or not black holes can explain dark matter. So let's jump into our first question right away here and it comes from Levi from the Ukraine.

Hi, Daniel LeVar.

Hey, I'm Levi and nuper Ukraine.

And I had two questions about my favorite topic, which.

Is black holes.

First, how is the mass of a black hole calculated?

And?

Second?

Is there any way to know when an event horizon of a black hole begins? If I were to say, take a rocket shift to the black hole and the cinem our galaxy, is there any way that I could know when I need to turn that thing around for it becomes spaghetti?

Thank you?

Hmmm? Interesting question? Now was he allowed to questions? I feel like he's not an extra question in his question? Inploded into a black hole because of its density, Yeah, it multiplied.

It seems see, you just can't stop asking questions. Once you start thinking about black holes, the questions just proliferate.

What do you think it's captured the imagination of not just our listeners, but it seems like everyone out there has questions about black holes.

I think it's just the opportunity to see something hidden, to learn something new.

You know.

The thing that captivates me about the black hole is knowing that one of the greatest mysteries in modern physics. How to reconcile crazy intense gravity and quantum little particles, how to bring those together into one idea is out there, and it's hidden inside a black hole. So if we could only peek inside, we could learn the very nature of space and time. There's so much we could know about the universe if only we could see inside a black hole. And yet it's hidden from us. So it's sort of like somebody saying, I have the secrets you want, and they're written on this envelope and I'm gonna earn it. I'm gonna throw it in the fire instead of opening it to you.

That would kill you.

Oh man. If it's so frustrating to know the answers are out there and not be able to get them, that's very frustrating.

If you throw a big red button into that envelope, that would drive you doubly crazy. But all right, let's jump into Levi's questions here. The first one is how do you calculate the mass of a black hole? Now, I'm guessing Dan Or there are not gigantic scales we can use to measure the mass of a black hole.

Sort of if we can, Yeah, the scales work my using gravity. Right, If you put something on a scale, you're measuring its weight, and its weight is the force of gravity on it, which is determined by its mass. And so to measure the mass of something you can use the strength of the gravitational pull on it, which depends on the object's mass. Now, out there in space, your arth, there's not some like massive scale we can put it on, but we can see how the black hole tugs on things around it which are visible, and that's one way we can measure its mass.

I so you can see the effects of its mass on the things around it. I guess kind of like our Sun, right, Like if our Sun with a different mass, like if it was bigger or smaller than our orbit around it would be different. Right, Like you could tell what the mass of the Sun is maybe from our orbit.

Yeah, if you measure just the velocity and location of the Earth as it moved around the Sun, you can deduce exactly the mass of the Sun because you could tell what gravitational force is necessary to move the Earth in that path, and that would tell you how much mass you need to provide that gravitational force. So, yeah, the Earth is like a little scale that's measuring the Sun all the time.

But what do you need to know the mass of the Earth too? Pretty accurately?

Yes, absolutely, you need to know the mass of the Earth.

And don't say you just use the sun, because then now we're in a circular argument.

No, you need to use the mass of the Earth. Absolutely. The mass of the Earth you can get using like your knowledge of what it's made out of and its volume. So if you know the radius of the Earth, like its size, and you're understanding roughly what it's made out of, then you can tell its mass, or you can boot strap. You can say, well, I'm going to look at the moon and see how the moon moves around the Earth, and that's going to tell me the mass of the Earth if again you know the mass of the moon.

Yeah, and sell on and so on. I guess at some point, maybe the question is at some point when do you have to guess? Right, Because at some point you have to guess what the moon is made out of or even the Earth you kind of have to guess. I mean, we have some measurements, but we ultimately you're sort of guessing what's inside the Earth.

Yeah, in the end, you do need to know the mass of one of the objects to measure the mass of the other. But there's also some constraints there, Like what you really need to know is the product of the two masses, right, mass one times mass two. So if you make enough measurements of pairs of objects, then you can narrow that down. You get like enough systems of equations that you can constrain it. But yeah, you also do need to say something about what they are made out of to get some information about how much mass one of them has. You can also measure the mass of the Earth by flipping that around and saying, here, I have an object whose mass I know, and that can measure the gravitational effect on it, and from that I can measure the mass of the Earth. Build like a calibration object, like a test object, like a one kilogram pound of platinum or something.

Yeah, you can see how much it pulls on like a known weight, and then that's how you would estimate the mass of the Earth.

And that's just sort of definitional. You say, like, this is the definition of a kilogram this object, and from that you can measure essentially the ratio of its mass to the mass of the Earth. You can say how massive is the Earth in terms of this object I'm defining to be one kilogram, and then you can boot strap your way up to the Sun and basically everything else in the universe.

Right, you can strap your bood. You can boot your strap. But what about for like a black hole? I mean, they're so far away, we've barely seen one directly. You know, we can see the things flying around it, But how do we know what those things are? I mean, they're just like bright little pinpoints, right.

Yeah, So one way we can see the black holes exist is by seeing their gravitational effect on stuff nearby. Because black holes, of course are black, they don't admit any radiation directly, or if they're emitting hawking radiation, then we can't see it. It's too faint. So you're right, we need to know them mass of the objects nearby. And so, for example, the black hole the center of our galaxy has some stars whizzing very close by to it, and we can measure the mass of those stars by looking at the light they emit. Because we have a pretty good model for how the brightness of a star is related to its mass. So we did a whole episode on how you measure the mass of stars. And that's not perfect, it's not exact, but it's pretty good, right.

It's based on like models and some observations, and so just from the light that you get from those stars around the black hole, you can say, well, that's a stage so and so star weighs about the usually wait about this much, and so therefore, and it's curving around the black hole this much. So therefore that black holes probably this many kilograms exactly.

And those models are pretty good, and we validate them using binary star systems, where we can see two stars, we can measure their brightness, and we can see how they move around each other, and so we can really validate those models pretty well. I mean, there are uncertainties, but we can trust those because remember there are a lot of binary star systems out there in the universe, many more than you might expect. So that lets us measure the mass of the stars and from that deduce the mass of the black hole. Because remember, black holes don't emit any information from their inside except for the total mass of the black hole, which can be deduced by its gravitational effect. That's the only information that comes out other than the black holes spin and charge.

And also do you have to account for like the camera adding ten pounds, like does a telescope at you know, ten million kilograms?

No, the black hole's agent is very particular by the cameras we used to take their pictures.

I see these is doubles when it's taking the naked pictures.

I said, take a profile above the accretion disk. That's when it looks good, all right.

And there's also sort of a different way to measure the mass of a black hole, which is by looking at its size. Like if we ever do get better pictures of a black hole, you might be able to tell how heavy it is by just seeing its size, right, Because the size of the event horizon depends on the mass of the black hole.

Yeah, they're very closely connected. As the black hole eats more and gets more mass than it is gaining in size, the size of the event horizon is growing, and so if you could measure the event horizon, then you could deduce its mass. Measuring the event horizon is tricky though, because you need to see photons like whizzing around it. So you need a direct picture. And we've done that for one maybe two black holes now, but it's much harder, obviously.

And so that brings us to the second question leave I had, which is like, if I'm trying to check out a black hole, like, could I tell where the actual event horizon is? Like, at what point do you want to make sure you turn around before you get sucked in forever?

Well, I would say turn around now, do not take that trip to the black hole. It's not a good idea.

Don't even buy the tickets. That's when you should turn around.

Right, So it is a good idea to think about where a black hole begins, where it's event horizon is, so that if you are a billionaire scientist, entrepreneur and you do take that trip to the center of the Milky Way to study the black hole, you know when to turn around. And one thing you could do, if you know the mass of the black hole is, you could just calculate it. You could say, well, I know how massive it is, so I know the point of no return. I can calculate the event horizon.

So, yeah, there's a point at a distance from the center of the black hole at which not even light can escape, right. I think maybe that's what Levi is asking, Like what's the point where not even light can escape. That's the event horizon, and from a distance you can sort of see it, right, Like, it's sort of where when you look at a black hole, and we've looked at one, it looks like a big black circle, and so that's generally where the event horizon is, although it's not exact right.

That's right, the black circle you see when you look at a black hole is actually bigger than the event horizon because you can't see photons that like fly just above the event horizon from behind the black hole. Those we get curved and fall into the black hole. So there's the event horizon itself, and then there's like a shadow that the black hole makes that's even larger than the event horizon. You can get closer than the shadow, you see it looks bigger than it actually is. And as you get closer and closer to the black hole, that shadow grows and it grows to take over more and more of your view. So if you're very close to the black hole, for example, then it might appear to take up like half of your entire view.

Right. That's kind of the tricky thing about black holes is that there's so much distortion around them that you know from afar they look like a nice clean circle. But as you get closer, everything gets distorted and kind of blown out of proportion, and so it's going to be really hard to tell when you've reached the actual event horizon, right, because, like you're saying, the black hole is going to start taking a bit more and more of your field of view, and you're going to be like, am I in or am I out?

I don't know, yeah exactly, And so this is very dangerous not to be recommended or endorsed. But as you get closer and closer to the black hole, the image of it grows larger and larger, and as you say, what you're seeing is not anymore a good representation of what's actually there. Like when you look around yourself in your room, the stuff you see is the stuff that's there, because the light is moving in a straight line from whatever it is to your eyes, and so you can look around and say, oh, that's over there, and this is over here. But if there are like lenses around you that bend the light, then you get distorted images and you're in a funhouse mirror. What you see is not what's actually there, and that's what's happening with the black hole. Light is no longer following straight lines, so what you see is a distortion. And it's really interesting. As you get closer and closer to the black hole than the shadow of the black hole, this big black image of the event horizon gets larger and larger. Eventually it becomes more than just half of your view. It takes up most of your view, and the rest of the universe is squeezed down into a smaller and smaller circle. And you can get a clue about when you're about to cross the event horizon, because when you cross the event horizon, that circle that is the rest of the universe is now shrinking down to a tiny little dot. And once you fall inside the event horizon, then the rest of the universe is now exactly one tiny little point where light from the universe can still reach you.

Yeah, it's a pretty trippy experience and pretty extreme. And actually, if you want to know more about this, it's conveniently a question we answer in our new book. Right Daniel frequently ask questions about the universe.

That's right, This is a frequently asked question. What would it be like to fall into a black hole, And the book is a lot of fun. It's out on November two, twenty twenty one. You can check it out at universe faq dot com. It's filled with answers and a bunch of really awesome cartoons that Wore drew. They give you a sense for what it would look like to fall into a black hole.

Yeah, order a copy for yourself, for your nieces and nephews, uncles and best friends. But we do sort of go into a lot of details because there are a lot of details about going into the black hole, and I'm not sure we can cover all of them. So please check out the book if you are actually that curious, because there are a lot of complications, like not only does the black hole take up your whole field of view, but also like it's possible for you to get inside a black hole without getting stretched into spaghetti. It sort of all depends on these details about the mass of the black hole.

Right, That's right, So if you're interested in that, dig into that copy of that book and let us know if you have any follow up questions.

All right, So, the basic answers for Levi is you can calculate the mass of a black hole by how the things around it are moving. And also when do you need to turn around when you visit a black hole? Before you visit a black hole, when you need to turn.

Around right exactly before you start searching Airbnb for black hole opportunities.

Yeah, don't believe those pictures. They distort the space inside of the airbnbs. All right, let's get into our two other listener questions about black holes. One of them is about mini black holes and the other one is about dark matter. But first, let's take a quick break.

With big wireless providers, what you see is never what you get. Somewhere between the store and your first month's bill, the price you thought you were paying magically skyrockets. With mint Mobile, you'll never have to worry about gotcha's ever again. When mint Mobile says fifteen dollars a month for a three month plan, they really mean it. I've used mint Mobile and the call quality is always so crisp and so clear. I can recommend it to you, So say bye bye to your overpriced wireless plans, jaw dropping monthly bills and unexpected overages. You can use your own phone with any mint Mobile plan and bring your phone number along with your existing contacts. So dit your overpriced wireless with Mint Mobiles deal and get three months a premium wireless service for fifteen bucks a month. To get this new customer offer and your new three month premium wireless plan for just fifteen bucks a month, go to mintmobile dot com slash universe. That's mintmobile dot com slash universe. Cut your wireless build a fifteen bucks a month at mintmobile dot com slash universe. Forty five dollars upfront payment required equivalent to fifteen dollars per month new customers on first three month plan only speeds slower about forty gigabytes. On unlimited plan. Additional taxi spees and restrictions apply. See mint mobile for details.

AI might be the most important new computer technology ever. It's storming every industry and literally billions of dollars are being invested, so buckle up. The problem is that AI needs a lot of speed and processing power. So how do you compete without cost spiraling out of control. It's time to upgrade to the next generation of the cloud. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure or OCI. OCI is a single platform for your infrastructure, database, application development, and AI needs. OCI has four to eight times the bandwidth of other clouds, offers one consistent price instead of variable regional pricing, and of course nobody does data better than Oracle, So now you can train your AI models at twice the speed and less than half the cost of other clouds. If you want to do more and spend less, like Uber eight by eight and Data Bricks Mosaic, take a free test drive of OCI at Oracle dot com slash strategic. That's Oracle dot com slash Strategic Oracle dot com slash Strategic.

If you love iPhone, you'll love Apple Card. It's the credit card designed for iPhone. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn four point four zero percent annual percentage yield. When you open a high Yield savings account through Applecard, apply for Applecard in the wallet app subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Applecard owners subject to eligibility. Apple Card and Savings by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City Branch Member, FDIC terms and more at app dot com. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth or enjoy a rich spoonful of Greek yogurt, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact of each and every bite. But the people in the dairy industry are US Dairy has set themselves some ambitious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times the same water cools the milk, cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US Dairy tackling greenhouse gases. Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit usdairy dot com slash sustainability to learn more.

All right, we're answering questions about black holes from listeners and you get a lot of questions about black holes.

I do. I have a lot of questions about black holes. I read a lot about black holes, and we get lots of questions from listeners about black holes because everybody wants to know what's going on.

I see. And what proportion of the questions you get do you actually know the answer?

Well, I have a wonderful backup, which is if I don't know the answer, I just send them a link to our book we have no idea and say that's the answer. Go buy a copy of the book.

Oh boy, you're plugging away today.

I'm plugging away. But also, I think people like to hear that the question they've asked is not one that has an answer. Of course, people would like to know the answer, but it's also satisfying to feel like, oh, I'm at the forefront of human knowledge. I have questions, just like Kip Thorn has questions, or just like Barry Barrish has questions. These Nobel Prize winners who also don't understand what's going on inside a black hole, welcome to the club.

They're curious about black holes club. All right. So our second question is from Tim and he has a question about mini black holes.

Hello, Daniel, Jay, and Katie. I've got a question about mini black holes. If you were to have some super large hadron collider and create miniature black holes that immediately disappear with Hawking radiation, how would you detect that Hawking radiation? And what would you learn since all the information other than the mass of the black hole is essentially destroyed?

Curious about the answer?

Juets all right, awesome question here. There's a lot in this question. There's the idea of mini black holes, there's the idea of Hawking radiation, and he asked about quantum information.

I know so many good questions and so many fun opportunities to learn about black holes by creating them particle colliders.

All right, so let's dig into it. Daniel, what is a Meni black hole? I guess it's just a small black hole. Are those possible? How do you make them?

Yeah? Black holes can come in almost any size. There is an absolute minimum size to a black hole, but it's pretty small. You can make a black hole that's the size and the galaxy. You can make a black hole that's like, you know, the size of a particle. Almost The crucial thing is not the mass, it's the density. If you compact enough stuff into a small enough space, then you can create a black hole. It's this combination of mass and radius. You know, for example, if you took the Earth, you could compact it into a peanut and that would be a black hole. So the mass of the Earth is enough to make a black hole, it's just not dense enough. And so you can make many black holes by pouring enough energy or enough mass into a small enough space.

And that's what you do at the large Hadron collider. Right, you think you're making mini black holes, or you know you're making mini black holes.

We hope we're making mini black holes. We haven't yet seen any, but that is exactly what we do at the Hadron collider and at ery collider, is that we pour a lot of energy into a very small space and we let the universe decide what comes out. We take advantage of the quantum canical nature, the probabilistic nature of the rules of physics that say, if you have a little ball of energy there, it can basically turn into anything. It might turn into some new particle you haven't seen before. It might turn into a black hole.

Right, And so you sometimes you get enough energy packed into such a small space that you make a many tiny black hole about the size of like a particle. And so those are actually black holes, just like the ones at the center of the galaxies. They're just really, really small, and something special happens to them, right. They don't last very long.

That's right. And so to be clear, we have not, to our knowledge made any of these black holes. We have not seen any. It's a hypothetical. It's a theoretical idea that perhaps it's possible to make these black holes by colliding particles together, and so we are looking for them. And the thing you have to understand about many black holes is that they don't last very long. Like big black holes can last for billions of years as they keep eating stuff. But all black holes emit radiation. They don't actually keep all their information inside. They leak a little bit of mass all the time. It's called hawking radiation. And this happens faster if you're a small black hole. So a big black hole hardly emits any hawking radiation. It can last for a long time. A little black hole will very rapidly evaporate by giving away all of its mass. In terms of hawking radiation. So the smaller the black hole is, the quicker it disappears, which is actually good because you want your black holes to evaporate rather than growing and gobbling up the earth.

All right, So then the tiny black holes evaporate quickly. And the question I guess is can you detect that hawking radiation? And what would you learn from it?

Yeah, so these black holes, if you made them, they would basically explode almost instantaneously. The kind we're talking about making it the large Hadron collider would last from like ten to the minus twenty seven seconds, and they would just emit a bunch of hawking radiation. But what is that hawking radiation? And how would you see it? The cool thing about black holes is that they couple gravitationally, right, They're connected to everything that has mass. They don't care about things electric charge or strong charge or weak charge, so they're sort of democratic. They turn into like all kinds of particles with basically equal probability, And so that means that what you would see is just a huge spray of a bunch of different particles, like a huge explosion at the center of your detector with a lot more energy than you would typically see.

I see, but you're eagerly like to see like an electron or a proton or a muon kind of right. I mean, depending on how much energy they have, they might be more probable, but there's no constraint about what particular particles you'll see, that's what you're saying.

Yeah, And because the particles that feel the strong force, like quarks and gluons, have so many more varieties because for example, for the upcork, there's the red upcork, the green upcork, and the blue upcork, whereas the electron doesn't feel that and so it only has one version. That means there are more versions of quarks and gluons. So you're more likely get to get quarks and gluons than electrons and muons, just because there are more of those. And black holes are democratic, so most likely what you're going to see is a big spray of quarks and gluons that fly out, and quarks and gluons we don't see those directly because quarks and gluons can't be by themselves, so instead each one turns into its own stream of particles. So what does a black hole look like in our detector at CERN, it looks like seven or ten streams of particles all coming out of the center of the collision.

Well, I think the question that Tim had was like, could you learn or would you learn anything from that stream of particles, And it sort of seems like you wouldn't write because it'd just be a random spray of particles, right.

Yeah, And this is a subtle point here because you can't look at an individual collision that has like ten of these sprays of particles and say that's a smoking gun signature of a black hole, because there are other ways for that to happen. Sometimes two protons collide and you do get ten quarks flying out, which make ten of these streams of particles, So that does happen. So we can't specifically say this was a black hole, that was a black hole. All we can do is say, look, we see more of these collisions that lead to ten or twelve sprays of particles than we expected from non black hole sources. So we can like statistically say we think we're making black holes because we see more of these weird kind of events than we can explain otherwise. And this weird kind of event is just what we expected to see from black holes. So we can't definitively say a black holes created on Tuesday at four pm, but we can't say over the last year, we think we made ten of them.

Well, I see, you can't study like a particular mini black hole. You can study kind of like a statistically what's going on in your collider. But I think Tim was sort of making the connection to this idea that we've talked about before, which is that inside of a black hole, quantum information is destroyed. So does that mean that when a mini black hole evaporates, there's no information in the hawking radiation.

Yeah, this is not something that we understand because we think that quantum information can't be destroyed, and so we wonder if somehow that hawking information does have encoded in it the quantum information that went into the black hole. And we had recently a fun podcast episode where we talked about people who recently made a breakthrough about how this might work as super fascinating, but it's not something we understand very well. But the information's being destroyed in a black hole is just about the particles that went into it, which is like the two protons you smashed together, So you don't really care that much about that quantum information. It's not like useful or interesting. But if you do make black holes, you can learn something much more interesting about the universe. You can gain like contextual information because you can learn something about quantum gravity. If we make black holes with a large Hadron collider, it means that gravity is much stronger at very short distances than it is at long distances. Something weird and different is going on when two particles get really close together, their gravity gets different, And that's a clue about maybe the whole nature of space, about how many dimensions there are to space itself.

Well, what do you mean, Like you would shoot things together create mini black holes, and then you would see how it interacts with the things around it. Like, can you actually get a sense of, you know, what happens as you get that close to mini black holes or is it maybe hidden in the fact that you do or do not get mini black holes.

Yeah, it's the fact that you make black holes, and also their typical energy tells you something about how they are made. You can't study an individual black hole or like put things near it or anything like that. But one thing we are really curious about is why gravity seems to be so weak. You know, gravity is so much weaker than all of the other forces. Like we say, often you can defeat the entire gravity of the Earth by using a simple kitchen magnet to pull on a screw, for example. So why is gravity so weak? It's not something we understand. One possible explanation is that maybe gravity is so weak because it's leaking out. It's like getting diluted. Because there are other ways that you can move through space other than the three we're familiar with. So these are called extra dimensions. Like maybe space doesn't have just three dimensions, maybe it has eleven or twenty six. But only gravity can feel those, And so when you're far away from something, you're not really feeling it's true gravity because most of it's leaked out into these other dimensions. But these other dimensions might be really really small and compact, so if you get really close to something, you might feel it's like true strength of its gravity. So the idea is if you smash two protons together and you bring the really close together with enough energy, then then might feel that strong gravity enough to make a black hole. So the fact that you made the black hole would tape you off that gravity is getting strong at short distances and maybe reveal something about the existence of those other dimensions of space and time.

So you're saying that if you do make black holes at the Large Hydron Collider, then maybe that points to the existence of extra dimensions.

Yes, exactly, so we can't learn that much from one black hole, but if we can prove that we have been making them, then that suggests that there must be extra dimensions space and time. And the pattern in which they appear, like the energy that they come with, and how often we make them can give us a clue as to how many dimensions are there and what radius do they have, Because these aren't dimensions like the ones we're familiar with, like x, y, and z that we move around in. These are like little looped dimensions. They're like move in a little circle, or they are only like a centimeter wide. They're really weird and strange dimensions. But lots of theories of physics actually insist on having more dimensions, like string theory.

Yeah, and conveniently that's another topic we cover in our books. But it sort of sounds like the answer for team here is that we haven't detected any mini black holes and you're in the colliders. But if you do create them, A, you would see this big shower of sort of random particles, maybe mostly quarks, and b would point to the existence of extra dimensions.

That's right. That's one explanation. There are other theories that also predict the creation of black holes, and so if we did see them, the theorist would go crazy coming up with new ideas to explain our data. It would be very, very exciting. And for those of you nervous about the safety aspect of this, don't worry. We've done all the calculations and we're confident we can't make black holes big enough to eat the.

Correct That's good to know, always reassuring that you've done the calculations and that you never make mistakes. Right, that's right.

We've never ever made a mistake that destroyed the earth. Right, that's a pretty good track record.

Yeah, yeah, so far zero for zero. All right, Well, let's get into our last question about black holes from a listener, and this one has to do with dark matter. But first, let's take another quick break.

When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth or enjoy a rich spoonful of Greek yogurt. You're probably not thinking about the environmental impact of each and every bite, but the people in the dairy industry are. US Dairy has set themselves some ambitious sustainability goals, including being greenhouse gas neutral by twenty to fifty. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. Take water, for example, most dairy farms reuse water up to four times the same water cools the milk, cleans equipment, washes the barn, and irrigates the crops. How is US Dairy tackling greenhouse gases. Many farms use anaerobic digestors that turn the methane from maneure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. So the next time you grab a slice of pizza or lick an ice cream cone, know that dairy farmers and processors around the country are using the latest practices and innovations to provide the nutrient dense dairy products we love with less of an impact. Visit US dairy dot com slash sustainability to learn more.

Now's the time to start your next adventure behind the wheel of an exciting new Toyota Hybrid. With the largest lineup of hybrid, plug in hybrid and electrified vehicles to choose from, Toyota has the one for you. Every new Toyota Hybrid comes with Toyota Care, two year complimentary scheduled maintenance, an exclusive hybrid battery warranty, and Toyota's legendary quality and reliability. Visit your local Toyota dealer today, Toyota let's go places. See your local Toyota dealer for hybrid battery warranty details.

Guess what, Mango, what's that? Well, so iHeart is giving us a whole minute to promote our podcast, part Time Genius.

I know. That's why I spent my whole week composing a high coup for the occasion. It's about my emotional journey in podcasting over the last seven years, and it's called Earthquake House.

Mega Mango, I'm going to cut you off right there.

Why don't we just tell people about.

Our show instead?

Yeah, that's a better idea. So every week on Fartime Genius, we feed our curiosity by answering the world's most important questions, things like when did America start dialing nine to one?

One?

Is William Shatner's best acting work in Esperanto? Also what happened to Esperanto? Plus we cover questions like how Chinese is your Chinese food? How do dollar stores stay in business? And of course is there an Illuminati of cheese? There absolutely is, and we are risking our lives by talking about it. But if you love mind blowing facts, incredible history, and really bad jokes, make your brains happy and tune into Part Time Genius.

Listen to Part Time Genius on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Hi, I'm David Eagleman from the podcast Inner Cosmos, which recently hit the number one science podcast in America. I mean neuroscientists at Stanford, and I've spent my career exploring the three pound universe in our heads. We're looking at a whole new series of episodes this season to understand why and how our lives look the way they do. Why does your memory drift so much? Why is it so hard to keep this secret? When should you not trust your intuition? Why do brains so easily fall for magic? Tricks and why do they love conspiracy theories. I'm hitting these questions and hundreds more because the more we know about what's running under the hood, the better we can steer our lives. Join me weekly to explore the relationship between your brain and your life by digging into unexpected questions. Listen to Inner Cosmos with David Eagleman on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.

All right, we're answering questions from listeners about black holes because they're so cool and mysterious and dark. And our last question comes from one who has a question about whether black holes can explain a little bit of missing mass.

If there is missing gravity in the galaxy, why can't we attribute it to the black hole in the center of it since we don't know it's mass.

Hmm, interesting question. First of all, we're missing mass, Like, do we misplace some mass in the galaxy?

Oops? I thought you were going to bring it home? Where is it?

Did the galaxy going a quick diet or something a go keto?

You look in great these days. Milky Way, Maybe it's like only two percent milky way or like little fat.

Milky Way, skim Milky Way. All right, so there is a missing mass in the galaxy, right, I know this one. It's like, if you measure how the stars in the galaxy are spinning around, they are spinning around faster than they would be if there was only stars and planets in the galaxy. Right, there's something else missing from the mass of how we see the galaxy spinning.

Exactly, just like we were talking about. You can deduce the mass that the Sun has to be to explain the Earth's motion. You can do the same thing with the whole galaxy. Measure the motion of the stars and from that deduce the mass of all the stuff that has to be pulling on those stars to keep moving in a circle. It's exactly the same strategy, right.

And this is kind of how people first started thinking about dark matter, which is that they saw that the galaxies were spinning faster than they would be if the stars were to stay in the galaxy, and so they hypothesized, like, hey, maybe there's some invisible mass. We'll call it dark matter, and that's what's keeping all the stars in the galaxy.

I usually think about it the other direction. They measure the velocity of the stars and they ask how much gravity do you need to explain that motion to keep the stars from flying out? And then they couldn't find that much mass. They looked at all the stars and all the dust and all the things they could see, and it just didn't add up. It wasn't even close. So that was a big puzzle.

For decades, right, And so the idea of a lot of invisible mass out there in the unarse is kind of crazy. So a lot of people are like, are you sure that sounds crazy? How do you know that maybe the black hole at the center of the galaxy isn't just heavier than you think it is. Maybe that would explain why the stars are not flying off into space.

Yeah, it's a great question because it points to like our uncertainty, like how do you know how massive those stars are? And how do you know the other things in the galaxy? Well do you know their mass? And so it's just like pointing at you know, other places we could be making mistakes, which is a great scientific exercise, like to go back and think, maybe we just misestimated the number of stars, or maybe we misestimated their mass, or maybe it's all hiding at the center of the galaxy inside that black hole.

Yeah, so the question is like, could a bigger black hole at the center of the galaxy explain how all the stars are moving around the galaxy or does it have to be something like dark matter.

So there's sort of three answers, two knows, and then maybe yes. So the first no is that we actually kind of do know the mass of the black hole. It's the center of the galaxy. It's not just some huge cosmic knob that we can turn up and down and say nobody knows, So we can just set it to anything. As we talked about just a few minutes ago, we can measure the mass of black holes by looking at the movement of stars near it. And the one near the center of our milky Way is actually super awesome because there's a star that gets really really close to it, it whizes right by, it ends up going super fast and allows us to make a pretty precise measurement of the mass of the black holes the center of the milky Way.

I see, So there isn't like a mysterious black hole at the center of the galaxy. There's one that we can measure.

Yeah, we've measured its mass pretty well and there's a bunch of stars moving around it. And this really awesome video you should watch. It took like decades to make of them observing the black hole and seeing the motion of the stars around it, and you can watch it in time laps. You know, it took them twenty years, but you can watch the whole thing in twenty seconds, and you can see these stars moving around some obvious, invisible object, like they're bending their path around what seems to be nothing and therefore must be something.

Right, And it's pretty massive, I imagine, right, it's a pretty massive black hole at the center of our galaxy.

Yeah, it's pretty heavy. It has four point one million times the mass of our star, so it's pretty hefty. And I just want to make a plug for UCLA that the Nobel Prize for these observations very recently. So go check out that video. It's pretty cool, but it's a pretty massive black hole. But it can't explain all of the dark matter number one, because we know it's mass. But number two also, it's in the wrong place to explain the dark matter.

Right, Like, even if we didn't know the mass of the black hole at the center of the galaxy, like even if we were wrong, one giant mass at the center of the galaxy wouldn't explain how all the stars are moving.

That's exactly right, because even if you increase the mass of the black hole to account for all the missing stuff, it wouldn't give you stars moving the way our stars are moving. And that's because we can look at the velocity of stars very close to the center of the galaxy and the velocity stars further away from the center of the galaxy. So what we need is dark matter to explain all of those different velocities stars closer to the center and stars further from the center, and every star its motion tells you about how much mass is sort of in a sphere that's closer to the center of the galaxy than it like, stars are not affected by stuff that further away from them, only by stuff that's closer to them. So as you look at stars as a function of their distance, you notice that you need a distribution of mass that sort of spread out through the galaxy. If you only put a huge blob of mass at the very center, it would make the stars near the core of the galaxy move way too fast, for.

Example, right right, Because that's kind of an interesting property of mass. It's like, you know, if you're really far away from it, you might as spoiled treat it as a like a dot. But if you're really close to it, then it does matter whether or not it's like diffused in a little tiny ball in the middle or in a giant cloud that this actually sort of engulfs you.

Right, Yeah, if you are inside of it, then you're only sensitive to the parts of it that are that closer to the Center's just like if you drill the hole inside the Earth and jumped inside, the force of gravity on you would decrease as you got closer and closer because a lot of the stuff would now be outside of your shell. You could ignore it, and when you get to the very center there would be no force of gravity, so you can no longer treat the Earth is like just a point particle was the mass of the Earth. So it's the same thing with the galaxy. In order to explain the velocity of stars, we have to distribute the mass in just the right way to make these stars go fast and these stars go a little slower. So the cool thing about this velocity measurement is that we're not only sensitive to the overall amount of missing mass, but also how it's distributed through the galaxy.

Right. I like that analogy about the Earth because like, if you fall to the center of the Earth, and you're at the center of the Earth, basically the Earth is all around you and it's pulling you in every direction, so you're basically weightless right in the middle of the Earth.

Yeah, there's no force of gravity at the center of the Earth.

Yeah, And so the same would be with a galaxy. Like if you're at the center of the galaxy and you would feel the dark matter pulling all around you, so you wouldn't feel this mass, But if you were out on the edge of the galaxy, you would feel the mass of the dark matter like it was a point in the middle.

Yeah, exactly. So imagine now a star that's very close to the center of the galaxy. If you took all the dark matter and you put it inside the block, that would mean that that star is feeling all of that gravity, would be moving really really fast. If instead, you took that dark matter and you spread it out through the galaxy, then most of it wouldn't affect that star near the core, because, as you say, it would all be balanced out, it would all be on the outside of it, it would be null. And so you can tell how it's distributed by looking at the velocity of stars that are close to the center and then a little further away and a little further away. A distributed mass of dark matter makes a very different prediction than dark matter concentrated all at the core of the galaxy.

All right, So then that's the answer. The answer is that a black hole cannot explain the missing mass in the galaxies and the trajectory of stars. You kind of need something large and diffuse, like how we think dark matter is.

But there's also a possible yes maybe to his answer, which is that we don't think that all of the dark matter is in the black hole the center of our galaxy. But remember that we don't know what dark matter is, and there's a possibility that dark matter, though it's spread out through the galaxy, might be a bunch of smaller black.

Holes, right like primordial black holes.

Right, Yes, black holes made in the very first few moments before there was even stuff and matter in the universe. They could still be around and they could account for the dark matter. It's one of the theories that are out there. It's maybe not the most common or highly voted theory of dark matter, but it's still possible. It's still plausible, and we haven't figured out what dark matter is, so it could just be a bunch of black holes spread out through the galaxy.

Well, that sounds a little horrifying to know, then, Like if you were flying through space, it's like riddled with minds kind of Right. You might be flying through space and there's a hole. You're flying through a cloud of little tiny black holes. That wouldn't be good for your spaceship, right.

That would not be good for your spaceship. But you know it's eaten zero Earth's so far, so it must be pretty safe.

So far, zero out to zero.

No, we've been flying through the galaxy for billions of years, right, and we have not yet run into a black hole. On the other hand, we don't know if there are other planets out there that have fallen into primordial black holes, because if it had, we wouldn't see them. It's not really a great argument.

All right, Well, then the answer is that a black hole at the center of the galaxy wouldn't explain dark matter, but maybe dark matter is explained by little, tiny black holes everywhere.

But it's great thinking one to try to come up with some other explanation for dark matter in terms of like the things we do know and our uncertainties about them. It's a great way to exercise your brain and do physics and think about different hypotheses. So great idea.

Cool. So those are three awesome questions about black holes. Dan, you do think we've done our job here to fill the black hole of questions about black holes a little bit?

Yeah. The problem is that the black hole questions just grow the more you feed them. The bigger it gets, the stronger it's pulled, the more we want to know. It's just kind of like science that way. The more we ask questions and get answers, the more questions we have.

Yeah, and hopefully we won't get stuck in them forever. At some point we'll get out of.

Them or maybe Inside the black Hole is a really wonderful book filled with the secrets of the universe and a cozy reading nook to enjoy it in.

Yeah, who doesn't love a good book about the universe? Titled Frequently Asked Questions about.

The You That's right, Hypothetically, at universe faq dot com.

You'll have to run an experiment to see if it's in real website universe faq dot com. You might find a black hole, or you might find a lot of interesting knowledge.

That's right and funny cartoon. So go check it out.

Go be a scientist.

Those of you who write in asking how can we support the podcast, this is how you can support the podcast. Please go out there and check out our book. We put a lot of energy and a lot of fun and a lot of love into it, and we hope that you all enjoy it.

Yeah, and more importantly, it's also those of you wondering, like how can I tell my friends or my cousin or my uncle or my mom, Like how cool all of this stuff is this book? I think it's a great way into these topics.

You think it's going to convert the physics skeptics out there?

Aren't all physicists skeptics. I thought that was your thing, like that was your identifier.

Yeah, but some people are skeptics about physicists.

Their skeptic about skepticism, meta skeptics. All right, Well, please go check it out and please send us more of your questions. There is really fun to get and really fun to answer on the podcast.

That's right. Please don't hesitate right to us any questions you have about physics, except of course, homework problems. To questions at Daniel Andjorge dot com.

Hope you enjoyed that. Thanks for joining us, See you next time.

Thanks for listening, and remember that Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. When you pop a piece of cheese into your mouth, you're probably not thinking about the environmental impact. But the people in the dairy industry are. That's why they're working hard every day to find new ways to reduce waste, conserve natural resources, and drive down greenhouse gas emissions. House us dare tackling greenhouse gasses. Many farms use anaerobic digestors to turn the methane from maneure into renewable energy that can power farms, towns, and electric cars. Visit you as dairy dot COM's Last sustainability to learn more.

Hi everyone, it's me Katie Couric. You know if you've been following me on social media. You know, I love to cook, or at least try, especially alongside some of my favorite chefs and foodies like Benny Blanco, Jake Cohen, Lighty Hoyke, Alison Roman, and Ininagarten. So I started a free newsletter called good Taste to share recipes, tips and kitchen mustaves. Just sign up at Katiecurk dot com slash good Taste. That's k A T I E C O U r C dot com slash good Taste. I promise your taste buds will be happy you did.

Guess what will?

What's that mago?

I've been trying to write a promo for our podcast, Part Time Genius, but even though we've done over two hundred and fifty episodes, we don't really talk about murderers or cults.

I mean, we did just cover the Illuminati of cheese, so I feel like that makes us pretty edgy. We also solve mysteries like how Chinese is your Chinese food? And how do dollar stores make money? And then of course can you game a dog show? So what you're saying is everyone should be listening. Listen to Part Time Genius on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts,

Daniel and Jorge Explain the Universe

A fun-filled discussion of the big, mind-blowing, unanswered questions about the Universe. In each e 
Social links
Follow podcast
Recent clips
Browse 636 clip(s)