“I knew all the right things to say about Jesus, but I was living a completely different life when no one was looking.”

That’s how Andy describes the reality of leading in the Church while quietly unraveling behind the scenes.

Andy wasn’t just a Christian struggling in private—he was a pastor. He was preaching, leading, and helping others follow Jesus, all while hiding a life that didn’t match what people saw. Alcohol had a grip on him, but it didn’t stop there. What began as hidden drinking eventually gave way to deeper compromise, including an affair that would force everything into the light.

In this episode, Andy walks through what it’s like to carry that kind of double life—not just the behaviors, but the weight of knowing the truth, teaching the truth, and still living in contradiction to it. There’s the pressure to maintain an image, the isolation that comes with secrecy, and the slow erosion of self that builds until there’s nowhere left to hide.

He also brings us through the moment everything came to the light. The moment he thought would destroy him that actually became his door to freedom: his confession.

He details what it was like to sit down with his wife and tell her everything—not just the drinking, but the affair. And he’s honest about the fear, the exposure, and the sense that everything he had built was about to collapse.

And yet, he's also open about what happened after. The consequences, yes, but also the reality of how God met him and the freedom he experienced as a result of radical vulnerability. 

Looking for a one-stop recovery resource? Learn more about the Tyndale Life Recovery Bible here.

We explore:

— How you can know the truth about Jesus and still live a completely different life in secret
— Why hidden addiction thrives in environments where image matters most
— The quiet tension of leading spiritually while falling apart privately
— How secrecy and isolation don’t just hide addiction—they feed it
— Why behavior change alone never touches what’s really driving it
— The deeper desires underneath addiction that rarely get addressed
— What actually happens when everything finally comes into the light
— Why confession feels like the end—but becomes the turning point
— The difference between managing sin and being transformed at the root
— How the Gospel confronts both what you do and what you love

Follow Andy's Podcast on YouTube, Spotify, or Apple
Get addiction recovery resources and help: veritasrecovery.org
Follow me: @jonseidl
Order my new book, Confessions of a Christian Alcoholic
Get the Tyndale Life Recovery Bible: https://hubs.la/Q041HjWm0