John MacDonald: Why not old school pen-and-paper exams?

 

Let me tell you why I think NZQA should turn off its online exam system and go back to pen-and-paper.

There’s a couple of weeks left to run and, over the past week, there have been two glitches which have had some students in a real pickle.

Yesterday, there was what NZQA is describing as a “system slowdown”.

Which meant the Level 1 English exam was disrupted for around 20 minutes. More than 32,000 students were sitting it at the time.

The good thing about yesterday’s system slowdown is that it wasn’t as bad as last week’s major outage, which saw some students lose work, including entire essays.

Now, I’m not saying that going back to pen-and-paper is the ideal solution. And I should point out that students who have still got exams to sit are going to have an option to choose whether they do them online or on paper.

But exams are stressful enough. Imagine what it’s going to be like for those students over the next two weeks, wondering whether the online system is going to throw another wobble.

He told The Mike Hosking Breakfast this morning that these glitches happened during English exams, which are the biggest exams in terms of the number of students.

So there’s a chance, isn’t there, that with the biggest exams out of the way, the system will cope as it should.

But why continue with this lottery?

That’s why I think NZQA should use pen-and-paper only, at least for the rest of the current exam period.

Which I know some students would hate, because they do everything on their laptops these days.

But I also think making NCEA exams pen-and-paper only on an ongoing basis would be a good thing too.

Not just with these exams, but with other major disruptions recently as well, especially the big global Microsoft crash on Friday, we’ve seen the limitations of technology.

But you hand out an exam paper to a student, they’ve got a pen and maybe a calculator or whatever else they’re allowed to take into exams, and that’s it. What could possibly go wrong?

Their pen might run out of ink. They might forget stuff. But they’re not going to have an online system tell them that something’s gone haywire and they’ve lost all their work.

Many Asian and European countries still prioritise paper-based exams. So why can’t we?

LISTEN ABOVE

Loading transcript