Is Rafael Flores Jr. the Pirates' starting catcher next year?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key discuss whether Rafael Flores Jr. should be the starting catcher in 2027 and how his breakout impacts the Pirates offseason plans. Then Josh Harrison highlights Pirates 3B coach Tony Beasley taking accountability in front of the media in this week's…

Is it worth celebrating if the Pirates finally finish above .500?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key discuss whether it is worth celebrating if the Pirates finish above .500 for only the 8 times in the last 32 years, discussing both the positives and shortcomings. Finally, we round out today's episode with a discussion on Roberto Clemente Day. To …

Should the Pirates bring back Don Kelly?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key debate whether the Pirates should bring back Don Kelly as manager in 2027, discuss some of their favorite moments from PNC Park before the final homestand of the year, and Platinum Key highlights the need to finish strong at home in this week's Key …

Would the Pirates be a playoff team if Griffin and Cruz stayed healthy?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key dig into the impact of losing Konnor Griffin and Oneil Cruz to extended injuries this season, and debate how much of an impact it had on the Pirates playoff chances. Then we wrap up this week's episode with our weekly J Hay Now! segment, where J Hay…

Pirates Position Grades since the Trade Deadline

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key hand out grades since the trade deadline for Starting Pitchers, Bullpen, Catcher, Infield, Outfield, DH, and coaching. Shop now at Fabletics.com/Foul and get 70 to 80% off everything when you sign up as a new VIP Go to Quince.com/foul for free shi…

Another series win, but Postseason hopes remain slim

Hosts Josh Harrison and Platinum Key recap the Pirates winning their 4th series in a row, preview their upcoming series against the White Sox, and Platinum Key highlights Oneil Cruz's defense in this week's Key of the Week segment. Shop now at Fabletics.com/Foul and get 70 to 80% off everything wh…

Who deserves blame for the Pirates' lack of fundamentals?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key dig into potential explanations for why the Pirates continue to struggle with fundamentals and mental mistakes this season, and J Hay highlights Konnor Griffin returning from injury in this week's J Hay Now! segment. Subscribe to the YouTube! YouTu…

Mailbag: What's J Hay's favorite memory as a Pirate?

Hosts Josh Harrison and Platinum Key answer listener questions in this week's Mailbag episode! Shop now at Fabletics.com/Foul and get 70 to 80% off everything when you sign up as a new VIP Subscribe to the YouTube! www.YouTube.com/@BuccoTerritory  Follow our social media channels for more conten…

Should the Pirates clean house right now?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key discuss whether it's time for the Pirates to hold the front office accountable for failing to build a playoff contender, highlight potential upcoming September call-ups, and Platinum Key focuses on continuing to win series in this week's Key of the …

Is Paul Skenes back?

Hosts Noah Hiles, Josh Harrison, and Platinum Key breakdown Paul Skenes' recent shutout performance against the Padres, discuss the impact of Endy Rodriguez having surgery on his hip, and J Hay rounds out the show highlighting Bubba Chandler in this week's J Hay Now! segment. Use our code for 10% …