Cassidy loved Sam's "dad bod" and the fact that he got her a cake when it wasn't her birthday. But what about her personality made Sam head for the hills? Find out in the podcast!
Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update
1,996 clip(s)
Awkward Tuesday: The Prank That Went Too Far
#3 Second Date Update of 2025: Couch Crush
Second Date Update Classics: High School Holiday Hangout + Trial By Separation