Best Friends Jennifer Duey, 20,  and Michelle Xavier, 18, attended a birthday dinner for a family member and are last seen together around 10:15 p.m Saturday, February 1, 1986, at a convenience store.  Just over two hours later Jennifer and Michelle are found dead on the side of the road, nude, their clothing hung on a barbed wire fence.  Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack discuss the crime scene and how DNA was used to get a conviction after 40 years as a cold case. In a shocking turn, after being convicted of the double homicide, David Misch sings "99 bottles of beer" during victim impact statements and sentencing

Transcript Highlights

00:00.71 Introduction

01:29.45 Last Photo taken of victims

04:48.63 Joe Shares personal story of recent health issue

08:06.47 February 2, 1986, Jennifer and Michelle go to dinner party

10:50.46 Discussion of how victims came in contact with suspect

15:22.11 Jennifer and Michelle bodies found by person on motorcycle

20:06.70 Victims were nude, clothing hung on barbed wire fence

24:56.80 Jennifer killed by gunshot wounds

30:01.86 In rape cases, searching for forced sexual trauma

35:15.81 In 1986 DNA was known, but it wasn't until 2016 it was used to find suspect in this case

40:00.58 Convicted individuals acting out in court

46:01.90 Conclusion