This week, Jamie takes a look at it where Cathy falls in the history of American feminism — and take a look at how the feminist movement has progressed, regressed, and gatekept. Why are feminists frustrated with Cathy?
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
Counthy guys. White gave the commencement speech at her alma mater at the University of Michigan, talking about what she talks about best, the insecurities of working American women. The world expects so much of you right now. You'll be expected to be a dynamic businessperson, financial wizard, nurturing homemaker, enlightened, involved parent, environmental activist, physical fitness expert, as sexy and alluring yet responsible partner, champion of human rights, independent thinker, community activists. And if you're a woman a size five, all at once. Today, when the message is that anyone can do anything, it's going to be very hard for you not to feel that everyone else is doing something and that you personally are stuck in your same old ruts. And just in case normal humans insecurity doesn't nail you, you'll be bombarded by images that will try Look at how women are bombarded. Look at the commercials. Look at how they picture men and women in the commercials. Men and commercials are always doing one thing. The women are doing six things at once. Now the man in the commercial will be mowing the lawn one job. The woman in the commercial is giving herself a beauty treatment for her hands while she does the dishes. The man in the commercial is grilling a steak one job. The woman in the commercial is simultaneously cleaning the oven, disinfecting the floor, popping a five course meal in the microwave, and faxing the office while explaining the miracle of feminine hygiene products to her daughter. And if you think that doesn't translate into real life expectations, head for Detroit during rush hour some morning and look around you on the anyway, if you've been listening to this show, you won't be surprised to hear the creator of Cathy Comics talking about the unreasonable expectations often pushed on women, the sorts of expectations that make one say, act speaking hypothetically. Of course, Cathy Comics certainly changed in tone and mission as the strip went on, but it serves as a document of a woman's insecurities and concerns for thirty four consecutive years between nineteen ten, and the issues mentioned and not mentioned aligned pretty closely with mainstream liberal views on women of this time. There's also plenty to say about what this commentary does not reference, a reflection of how American feminism has historically either ignored or been actively hostile to the interests of women of color, queer women, and working class women. So in this episode, I'm gonna let Kathy lead us through American feminist issues according to the funny pages, and I'll fill in some blanks of what does not appear. So she burst into the world in nineteen seventy six, she's at what, she's out on dates, and she don't like politics. From Mama and urban to with feminist friends. She's fighting all the stands with chocolate and hand Kathy, she's fighting back to stressed with success. Let's cut her some slack, oh, Kathy Bkathyan Cather, She's gotta like go in all. So, not to be patronizing, but Kathy Curtins did not invent feminism, so we do require a little bit of set up here. In order for all of the expectations that eventually stress our heroine out during the second wave of feminism to exist in the first place, a lot of social gains had to be made beforehand. And quick disclaimer here, I will be the first to say that this episode will in no way be comprehensive, and so I want to see at the top I don't have the purview to give a full overview of the history of American feminism. You could be in school for years on that topic. But I will be including further resources in the show notes to help bridge those gaps. So to begin, we have to take a look at the first wave of American feminism, which leads us to where Kathy alternatively thrives and fails in the second wave. So let's go back to the year eighteen forty eight. Okay, I can already hear you grown, that's so long ago. Sit down and listen. This is going somewhere, I repeat. Was popularly considered to be the launch of the first wave of American feminism, with the first formal women's rights convention in Seneca Falls, New York. This wave, while containing many steps forward and eventually steps backward, is considered to have continued through when women got the vote in the US. Victories along the way included increased educational opportunities, wives being granted custody of their own children, women being able to own property in their own name, and of course, the vote. In the first wave of feminism and in every wave since, middle class white women have been disproportionately centered in how the activism is discussed and treated in pop culture. This was well on display during this First wave. The majority of commonly discussed women of this era in American feminism are white. Your Susan B. Anthony's your Elizabeth, Katie Stanton's your Lucretia Motts, You're Lucy Stones. While American feminists had certainly existed for some time, it's in the mid eighteen hundreds that they began to organize in large numbers. Much of this early organization drew inspiration from prior experiences with the tem prints and abolition movements. Here's what historian Manisha Sinha in The Slaves Cause, A History of Abolition said of first wave American feminism. If not all female abolitionists became women's rights activists, pioneering feminists owed their public careers to abolition, while women of color spoke not just about the oppression of their gender, but of race and class. The white middle class figureheads of the first wave often ignored or made their insights unwelcome. There were divides among white feminists as well. Working class women were concerned with factory conditions and labor exploitation, while white women of the middle class and above were primarily concerned with gaining rights as individuals outside of marriage, including the ability to own property, have child custody, and vote. Feminist scholar and general legend Angela Davis explains why upper class white women gained an interest in seeking suffrage for women around this time in her classic book Women, Race, and Class. An ideological consequence of industrial capitalism was the shaping of a more rigorous notion of female inferiority. It seemed, in fact, that the more women's domestic duty shrank under the impact of industrialization, the more ridge became the assertation that women's place was in the home. They have been productive workers within the home economy, and their labor have been no less respected than their men's, and manufacturing moved out of the home and into the factory. The ideology of women who begin to raise the wife and mother as ideal as workers, women had at least enjoyed the economic quality, but as wives there were destined to become appendagous to their men, servants to their husband's As mothers, they would be defined as passive vehicles for the replenishment of human life. The situation for that white housewife was full of contradictions, and it bear as much repeating that black feminists, many of them born into slavery prior to abolition, were instrumental in this movement, although their contributions are frequently an un fairly deemphasized by white feminists even today. So Journal Truth was one of the most prominent black women in the movement at this time, speaking about her experiences intersectionally as both a formerly enslaved black person and as a woman. Here's a quote from her famous speech Ain't I a Woman? From an Akrons Woman Convention in eighteen fifty one, read by Performer st for the Sojournal Truth Project. In I I am a woman's rights. I have as much muscle as any man, and I can do as much work as any man. I have plot and reaped and husked and chopped and mode, and can any man do better than that? I have heard much about the sexiest being equal. I can carry as much as any man, and I can eat as much too, if I can get it. I am as strong as any man. That is. Today the poor man seemed to be all in confusion. They don't know what to do. White children. If you have woman's rights, give it to her and you will feel better. You have your own rights, and they will be so much trouble. While truth speech was a huge hit in eighteen fifty one, Angela Davis explains that a number of white women at the conference did not want truth the only black woman at the convention to speak at all. The racism displayed by white feminists of this time is worthy of more discussion and has been chronicled in seminal text like White Tears, Brown Scars by Ruby hammad On, Intersectionality by Kimberly Crenshaw, and Davis's Women, Race and Class, among many many others. I will link to these books in the description of this episode. What needs to be said is this white feminist leaders like Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Katie stand In, who had supported the abolition of slavery and even worked with Frederick Douglas to win the vote quote for both women and African Americans unquote, would later actively work against the black vote and the interests of black women in particular, over and over in an attempt to get white women the vote ahead of black men. The message being sent by these leaders was clear, the white woman's vote took precedence over all women's votes for Anthony and Stanton following the dissolution of their alliance with Douglas, who had previously stood up for the women's vote at the Seneca Falls Convention in eighteen forty eight. Stanton and Anthony created the National American Woman's Suffrage Association in eighteen sixty nine, specifically to oppose the fifteenth Amendment, which granted black men the vote. Anthony famously said she would cut off her right arm before demanding voting rights for black men instead of women. With the significant biases of white leaders in mind, one of the strengths of the first wave of feminism as its clear goal and focus, which was suffrage, and after seventy years, that was achieved in n In these years, even the most liberal wings of the movement were met with vitriol from American patriarchy. A best selling book in eighteen seventy three stated that women could not last in careers and would suffer quote exhaustion of the feminine nervous system unquote, and President Theodore Roosevelt once said that a white woman who postponed childbirth to do literally anything else was a race trader. So in the years of this movement, steps were made in the right direction. Women gained access to higher education to keeping their wages, as well as early whisperings of widespread birth control access. Following the success of the women Suffrage movement in securing the vote, the nearly seventy five years of consistent feminist activism began to slow down, in part due to active antagonism from American patriarchal structures who blacklisted feminists from publishing their work in major publications and labeled many communists and a quote serious threat to the country. This led to one of the most notable backlashes against the gains of feminists in American history. But keep in mind that even with this passing, black women's votes were still not treated equally. Martha S. Jones, author of Vanguard, How Black Women Broke barriers, won the vote and insisted on equality for all told time in the following quote. The nineteenth Amendment did not eliminate the state laws that operated to keep Black Americans from the polls via poll taxes and literacy tests, nor did the nineteenth Amendment address violence or lynching. Some African American women will vote with the Nineteenth Amendment unquote. This backlash is carefully documented by writer Susan Faludi in her book Backlash, which documents both the major American feminist movements and the near certainty that periods of women's gains would be followed by a period of severe backlash, backlash that extends to the political, to the cultural, and within the feminist movement itself. Fluti describes the first twentieth century backlash as happening in the nineteen twenties, with a wave of anti feminist media, demonization of women who wanted to get divorces or abortions, and an increased emphasis on looks and consumptions, exemplified by the rise of the Miss America pageant that started in ninety, the same year that women got the vote. And the thing about backlashes is they tend to erase a lot of progress. According to Fluti, by nineteen thirty, there were fewer women doctors than there had been in nineteen ten. Fast forward a bit to the late thirties early forties, women surged back into the workplace in America. During World War Two, with men leaving the country to fight in the war, five to six million women entered the workforce, two million of which entered heavy industry jobs, the government began to provide wild stuff like daycare assistants. Working class women fought for unions, and young girls grew up wanting their own careers. And keep in mind that this is the era that Kathy guiss Wide's mother, as well as the comic character of Mom, would have been growing up in. But when the war ended, backlash again, where the Rosie the Riveter messaging of women's roles in war efforts led some to believe that their place in the workplace was here to stay. In came the nineteen fifties. Those two million women in heavy industry laid off and forced out of their job to make room for veterans returning from war. As ever, working class and women of color often remained in the workplace, but not with the same status or pay as in the wartime. Women were denied unemployment pay flat out, and middle class white women were generally pushed into the Donna Reeve nineteen fifties era cult of domesticity. Just ten years later, the culture dictated that jobs and education were very unfeminine, and calling yourself a feminist was once again and ama anathema, And calling yourself a feminist was once again and an athema never said that word out loud before. Good job, Jamie Okay. Integral to this an all periods of backlash is an emphasis on consumerism and on improving the individual. The economy is flourishing in the nineties and fifties in the US made women a larger consumer block than ever, and defining oneself through consumption was a great way to distract from, you know, being mad about not having rights. Kathy Guys White, born in nineteen fifty spent her formative years within a period of backlash that predated the second wave feminist movement, which most people consider to have been started in nineteen sixty eight, when a New York Times magazine article by Martha Lear coining the term was released. So where were women's rights by the sixties. The nineteen sixty three President's Commission on the Status of Women Report, which was initially commissioned by a preassassinated President Kennedy, Remember him? People love that guy? But would they have if he had We'll never know. This commission was led by Eleanor Roosevelt, and while it was still very you better be a mommy, eventually in its tone this report acknowledged a lot of commonly recognized discriminations against women, using hard federal data to back it up. These acknowledgements included recognition of the wage gap, of employment inequality, of low support for working class women and women of color, of a dearth of child care services, and on and on. And just like with the first wave, this feminist movement came on the heels of a major racial reckoning in the United States via the Civil Rights Movement, where again black women in leadership positions spoke on their role in American society, intersectionally with leaders like Marianne Weathers, Ella Baker, who founded the Student Non Violent coword Nating Committee and more. During the Civil Rights Movement, black women worked from the radical and liberal wings and were instrumental in community organizing that led to wins like the Civil Rights Act of nineteen sixty four and the Voting Rights Act of nineteen sixty five, and by the late nineteen sixties, a new wave of the women's movement had certainly been building. Challenging American white patriarchal structures were moved along by both the Civil Rights Movement and the energy from the protests surrounding the Vietnam War as well as the growing number of options in American feminist literature and organizations, which brings me to Betty for Dan. Oh, you thought we weren't going to get to Betty for Dan while buckle In, she is best known as the author of nineteen sixty three is the Feminine Mystique, a gospel for dissatisfied housewives that bucked and rejected the idea that a woman naturally derives purpose from marriage, children, and housework. We'll get to its shortcomings in a bit, but this mystique was as free Dan put it, quote the problem that has no name unquote, and this clearly spoke to a young Kathy Guy's white. She references the feminine mystique in her work constantly, both through her character and through herself. Here she is describing her teen in college years in a PPS News Hour clip promoting her essay collection Fifty Things That Aren't My Fault. My generation was right in between the two Betties Betty Crocker and Betty for Dan, and I wanted to be both of them, and a lot of women did at that time. It was and I literally gained forty pounds on one Betty's chocolate funge layer cake mix while reading the other Betty's feminine mistaque and a lot of women I think found themselves like the place I was in. But she's not wrong. Betty for Dan is a Betty of note for better and for worse. For Dan was one of the figureheads of the liberal wing of the Second Wave, going on to found the now the National Organization for Women in nineteen sixty six with forty eight others. Like Anthony and Stanton before them, The organization was extremely polarizing throughout the second Wave due to it say it with me over emphasis on the issues of straight, middle class white women above everyone else. Also, like the first movement, the liberal wing of the second Wave came with a pretty clearly defined goal. It was all about passing the e R, a equal Rights Amendment, a proposed constitutional amendment that had been unsuccessful in making progress since ninety three. The amendment sought to and get ready for some controversial stuff, guarantee legal rights regardless of gender. To this day, it's never been signed into law. Isn't that nice. This area of the movement was popularly referred to as women's liberation, and there was a part of it women's libbers. The struggle to apply women's lab to everyday life is thoroughly explored in the first few years of the Happy Comics. But women of color, while again being sidelined and actively disregarded by liberal, white centered organizations such as the n OW, were extremely active during the Second Wave years. Some organizations of note membership in the Black Panther Party was over sixty percent women. Kathleen Cleaver, who was a communication secretary with the Panthers, was once asked what a woman's role in the revolution was, and she replied, quote, no one ever asks what a man's place in the revolution is unquote. The National Black Feminist Organization, founded in nineteen seventy three, was one of the first to include a lesbian agenda as a part of their mission statement. Asian feminists were extremely active organizers as well, with projects like Asian Sisters in l A drug Abuse Center founded in nineteen seventy one, and the l A Asian Women's Center was an organizing hub until it closed in seventy six. In nineteen seventy four, Indigenous American women formed the Women of All Red Nations or WARREN, based on concepts of tribal women's traditions and with the key distinction that patriarchy and colonialism were inseparable concepts, and because of the hostility that these organizations were sometimes met with by the white feminist mainstream, the label of feminists sometimes be resisted. Here's Angela Davis speaking on this at talk at the Center of Contemporary Culture in Barcelona. Everybody started referring to me as a feminist, and my response was, I'm not a feminist, you know, I'm a black revolutionary because I didn't see how the two had anything to do with each other. But I realized that I was talking about a certain kind of feminism, a bourgeois feminism, a feminism that is still white, white bourgeois feminism, which is unfortunately the the most represented feminism today, and most people think of that as feminism. But that ignores the fact that huge numbers of organic and academic intellectuals who are women of color have transform the very nature of feminism. And the hallmark of feminism today is what we call intersectionality, a recognition of the and not only not only the inter relating um uh character of identities, but as I frequently say, I think intersectionality is is most helpful when we think about the intersectionality of social justice struggles. Queer women experienced active hostility from the mainstream movement as well. Activists Mercia Johnson and Sylvia Rivera organized for trans rights with Star after Johnson had been a key figure at the Stonewall Riots, and both worked with Degay Liberation Front during these years. Betty free Dan was actively homophobic, referring to lesbians as the quote unquote lavender menace in nineteen sixty nine and did not welcome queer women into the Now, and of course people were pissed. Rita May Brown, who was a lesbian activist, broke off from the New York branch of the Now and began radical lesbians who wore t shirts that said lavender menace and staged an action at the Second Congress to Unite Women in nineteen seventy, an action that forced a discussion about homophobia and the exclusion that lesbians experienced in society as well as within the feminist movement. While some straight feminists with the liberal mainstream movement, including Gloria Steinem, wanted to be more inclusive, Betty fre Dan purged lesbians and lesbian sympathizers, as she put it, from the now before in nineteen seventy one, change was made to once again allow queer people into the organization. So again, with the second wave of feminism, there were radical and liberal wings with very different interests, which created significant interior conflict. The Kathy comics are really only engaging with this mainstream liberal movement, in no small part because the strips author was a liberal white woman in a majority middle class white area, writing to some extent about her own experiences and opinions. Kathy strips do not feature people of color or queer people, and it's radicals like Andrea have politics that actually skewed pretty liberal. This is exemplified in the consciousness raising sessions that Andrea runs after work in the nineteen seventies, which Kathy originally finds to be kind of naval, gazey and bizarre, although she does give it a fair shake. Here's Andrea. Little boys are always encouraged to boast about their achievement. Well, little girls are scolded for boasting because it's unfeminine. But with assertiveness training exercise number two, women can rediscover the prad we have every right to express. Each one of you will stand up and say out loud the one thing you're most proud of yourself. I am very proud of the fact that I have never boasted. Andrea goes relatively hard in these early years. There's also a funny storyline from the late seventies where she gets a job as a mall Santa to challenge the patriarchal construct of Santa. Actual radicalism at this time took a very different form and often rejected consciousness raising groups on the same grounds that Kathy did. And he thought they were two centered on the self above the collective. Here's a quote I love from the nineteen seventy anthology Sisterhood Is Powerful, from radical feminist Robin Morgan. This is not a movement one joins. There are no rigid structures or membership card. The women's liberation movement exists where three or four friends or neighbors decided to meet regularly over coffee and talk about their personal lives. It also exists in the cells of women's jail, the welfare lines, in the supermarket, the factory, the convent, the farm, the maternity ward, the street corner, the old Ladies home, the kitchen, the Steno pool, the bet. It exists in your mind and in the political and personal insights that you can contribute to change and shape and help its growth. This interest in viewing consciousness raising as a wider construct was not shared by all feminists, but the emphasis that everyday lives of women should be up for discussion definitely was. New York Radical Women member Carol Hannish popularized the phrase the personal is political in the nineteen sixty nine essay, That is to say that women speaking about their problems in marriage and access to healthcare, in labor issues in appearance was important and emphasizing in these groups that it was counterproductive to say that not living up to this expected image was a personal instead of a systemic failure. Sidebar, Hannish was just very cool in general. He was one of four radical feminists who hung a women's liberation banner over the balcony at a Miss America pageant in ninety eight. Good stuff. So the Kathy character is at first resistant towards consciousness raising because of it's in her perspective, unwillingness to accept gradual change. While she is open and even wants to feel better about her station in life, she isn't a full women's liber in the sense that she wants romantic love with a man and has a tendency to not assert herself in the relationships she cares about, as well as in the workplace. The example of her screaming at a consciousness raising session when the leader suggests that men should be removed from women's lives altogether is a perfect example of this, and Kathy guys White has a vested interest in exploring how men reacted to the women's liberation movement taking off through characters like irving Mr. Pinkley and the Parade of Losers that Kathy dates and rejects throughout the nineteen seventies. Also referenced in these strips is the then new term miss, brought into the mainstream by feminist Sheila Michaels and popularize further by Glorious Dynham's magazine of the same name. The whole idea behind it is that women in the workplace and in general shouldn't be pressured to disclose their marital status when introducing themselves, and Cathy is on board with this. When the Kathy character asks to be called ms in the late seventies, a male employee comments this Mrs Mss or miss miss oh you're single, then no, I'm miss women invented miss, So you wouldn't be able to label us as single or married. Well that may be, but the only woman I see you actually use mss are single. Miss. Miss. You don't know that I'm a miss? Yes, I do. If you were married, you wouldn't worry so much about being labeled single. This is what I think Kathy strips do really well. Take this step forward for the feminist movement, like a simple demand to not be defined by marital status, and reflects how the institutions that resist these changes reacted, usually in a way that makes our heroine feel less than. This is also reflected in Cathy's relationship with Irving, a man who is clearly uncomfortable with the changing role of women in the world, and unlike some popular criticism would lead you to believe, Irving's behavior was criticized within the strip, although some took rateful issue with the Kathy character herself absorbing a lot of toxic and abusive qualities stemming from his own insecurities, and people were rightfully critical of the fact that she married him for some reason. I digress. Here is a late nineteen seventies strip with Irving and Kathy. You want me around until you read some women's article, and then all you care about is your career. Then you get disillusioned by your career and you search for some big romance to give meaning to your life. You do yo yo's. You beg me to come back. I come back, I threaten your space, you throw me out. You don't even know what you want. Kathy at last, a man who really understands me. Something that's always really fun is seeing Irving's character get torn to shreds whenever he comes into contact with Andrea, who thinks that he is not good enough for Kathy, all the way up until the two marry in two thousand five. Here's a seventies era interaction with the two of them, with Cathy sitting silently beside Irving. Throughout history, women have been suppressed, repressed, and oppressed. Irving, We've had miserable jobs, hideous pay, humiliating benefits, and not one shred of respect as close to equal human beings. What possible injustice is? Do you think men have suffered that even come close? We never learned to cry. You never had anything to cry about. While the Equal Rights Amendment ultimately failed. The nineteen seventies proved to be a very productive time for American feminists. According to Fluty, millions more women entered the workplace, the wage gap closed to about seventy for upwardly mobile white women in let's be clear, access to birth control increased. Title nine pass which welcomed women into high school and collegiate sports. The Equal Credit Opportunity Act of nineteen seventy four was passed, which banned discrimination in access to credit on the basis of gender, marital status, race, religion, national origin, and age. There was, of course, row View eight, the ninety three Supreme Court decision that finally four now gave people with uterus as the right to get an abortion for up to three months. This movement absolutely lacked in intersectionality and solidarity with women of color and with queer women, and the Cathy character benefits from much of the progress of this time. As a middle class white woman, she is able to eventually buy her own home. As a single woman, she ascends in the workplace. She struggles and fails to get equal pay, but at least isn't legally barred from pursuing it technically, and that is how the comic plays out in the seventies, but by the end of the nineteen seventies, the second wave feminist movement was considered to have ended. And it's when we get into Kathy's strips from the nineteen eighties that I think the strip really hits its stride. While Kathy comics were never designed to communicate or promote radical feminism, the semi autobiographical format was well equipped to comment on the backlash to second wave feminism that took place throughout the nineteen eighties. As a general rule, Kathy was a reactor to trends, not a creator of trends, sort of an ancestor to the hashtag relatable content that haunts a million abandoned Instagram pages today. In the nineteen eighties, as Reagan came into power, the vast majority of American women saw the winds of the nineteen seventies, and those who had advocated for them treated punitively. Here's how Susan Faludi describes the concept of backlash in a forward to a new edition of her book. The backlash against Women's rights works in much the same way. Its rhetoric charges feminists with all the crimes it perpetrates. The backlash line blames the women's movement for the feminization of poverty, while the backlash is own instigators in Washington pushed through the budget cutch that helped impoverish millions of women, thought pay equity proposals and undermine equal opportunity laws. The backlash line claims the women's movement cares nothing for children's rights, while its own representatives in the capital and state legislatures have blocked one bill after another to improve childcare, slashed billions of dollars in federal aid for children, and relax state licensing standards for daycare centers. The backlash line accuses of the women's movement of creating a generation of unhappy, single and childless women, but its purveyors in the media are the ones guilty of making single and childless women feel like circus fruits. To blame feminism for women's blesser lives is to miss entirely the point of feminism, which is to win women a wide range of experience. Feminism remains a pretty simple concept, despite repeated and enormously effective efforts to dress it up in grease paint and turn its proponents into gargoyles. Oh. This backlash of the nineteen eighties manifested both in large, systemic and small, innocuous, everyday ways. For as close as the Second Feminist had seemed to passing the Equal Rights Amendment just years earlier, there was significant pushback from the evangelical right and from former allies of the feminist movement throughout the decade. Cathy's strips focus on the more innocuous but still clear backlash, partially as a privilege of her race and class, and personally because nothing too depressing was really tolerated in the funny pages at that time. One of the things she addresses is a severe uptick and sexual harassment in the nineteen eighties workplace, as demonstrated by Cathy's boss, Mr. Pinkley, harassing and pressuring her to let him into her home. In two, Cathy, being way cooler than anyone ever, gave her credit for chi him in the face. He is not punished for this, but Charlene and Cathy then begin a whisper network in the workplace to protect others from it happening to them. In the first episode, we touched on Andrea's reaction in trying to motivate Cathy to advocate for herself in the aftermath. Here's the slice of that strip. All right, then, what are you going to do about Mr Pinkley. I'll show him. I'll quit my job. That wrong, wrong, wrong. The hopelessness of this situation is very Eighties Women who pursued justice after being harassed at work were often met with well, no job and further harassment. To this end, Andrea takes center stage in the comic strips commentary on the struggle of working mothers, specifically with maternity leave. Andrea began as almost a parody of nineteen seventies women's livers, originally vowing to focus on her career and ignore dating in children, but she has a change of heart in the nineteen eighties. She gets married and has her first child, Zenith. By the end of the decade, the comic basic clear that this isn't a betrayal of her values. Andrea's personality and tireless advocacy for women continues, both in the way that she ensures her marriage to husband Luke remains an equitable one and with her attempts to retain her power in the workplace while raising her daughter. After giving birth to Zenith. Andrea returns to work to confirm her maternity leave, only to discover there is no maternity leave. Here's a strip from with Andrea talking to the secretary at her work. What do I fill out to begin my maternity leave? We have no maternity leave here? What no leave, no pay, no job? When you come back, I think I'm going to be sick. Better say it. You only have three days of paid sick time coming. Andrea then goes to her boss to confirm that she was never guaranteed maternity leave and it's true. Personnel confirms that she can either quit, be fired, go broke, hiring childcare, or collapse from exhaustion doing it herself. She takes some time off without pay and returns to work again, asking to build back up to her normal workload while keeping Zenith at work to avoid expensive childcare she can't afford. But this time she's told her job has been given away altogether. In this trip, she's holding baby Zenith in her arms, and as someone trying to raise a young feminist herself, she's furious. Here she is talking to the same secretary, How could you give my job away? Companies aren't required to hold jobs for women who take time off to have babies. Andrea, well, that's ridiculous of the whole labor forces woman and of us will have children. This is six. Let's just say this company believes in old fashioned values. What they found someone who would take your job for a nineteen fifty salary. Andrea is using real statistics from six here. And she goes to the matt fighting for parental leave in her workplace, but ultimately loses in spite of the millions of mothers in this same era that we're facing the same issue. She tries to raise en in a gender neutral environment, but she fails at this too. The toys of this time are extremely binary, and she ends up giving up due to lack of options and energy. Is that an inspiring or motivational storyline. No, it's very bleak. And Andrea goes on to work as a tempt for six fifty an hour. But the thing is this was reflective of a very real possibility for working women of this time. Andrea comes into play again when campaigning from Michael Dukakis in his presidential bid against George Bush, Sr. Enlisting Kathy in the efforts as well. As I mentioned in episode one, including an overt political endorsement, got the Kathy strip dropped from some papers and moved to the editorial pages by other papers. But Kathy guys White and her characters held firm as fluty notes in Backlash, du Caccus with later pretty severely backpedal on his promise to working women in pearance by the end of his bid and a failed attempt to gain wider support, and so a decade after Andrea was dutifully raising consciousness in her community, she was a married mother who had been all but banished from the successful career she'd spent a decade building, and she was understandably piste off about it. Unfortunately, she starts to fade from the comics as the years go on, but the storylines involving Andrea in the seventies and eighties are truly some of my favorites. A lot of Kathy and Andrea's friendship is built around the cost of cards. That is, the woman who has it all, someone who is a career woman, a domestic goddess, and a doting mother, all without breaking a sweat. As the comic goes on, Guy's Whites commentary is clear not only is this an unrealistic expectation for anyone, but the powers that be in the workplace, government, and often a woman's own home were sometimes actively working against this being a possibility, and so in the nineteen eighties we see a lot of Cappy feeling bad about herself when asked by pop culture to compare herself to other women. To put that in context, a huge component of backlash against social causes is an increased focus on consumerism and self improvement through things like observing fashion trends, investing in self help books, and joining health clubs and gyms versus collectively organizing helping run, listen to world, Get you showing the world what you can do. Get in shape her you love feeling. Get it in shape. It's so feeling and run. Let's see what ju the wait if you work out? Twisted to All comes at formatons It's I'll be doing a whole episode on Kathy Guys Whites commentary on food, fashion, and beauty later in this series. But even outside of the advertising blitz that defined and distracted so many in the nineties, it's interesting to watch the Kathy character constantly feel that she isn't living up to the standards that she's supposed to, standards that are basically impossible to achieve. Here's a strip from the early eighties, Kathy sitting on her armchair at home watching a TV show that says this, Welcome to the Women's Hour, and now here's your host, Mr Bob Black. Hello, we're talking to Margie Miller, married, mother of two, founder and president of a small manufacturing empire, and author of two best selling novels and three plays. Margie at age nine, and with all this going on, how in the world do you have time to be on our show today? Margie says, Oh, it's nothing, Bob. The little ones are at their Greek literature workshop and the opera I have a small pardon doesn't begin until seven o'clock. He replies, well, must have a lot of help at home. As the show continues, Kathy begins to sink down in her chair, Margie says, actually, I find a well organized house rends itself. Of course, it has to be a bit cluttered because of the addition I'm building this week. The host says, my, my, you don't do anything the traditional way, do you. Kathy grabs her TV in anxiety. Margie says no, not unless you count the two fifty sweater sets nit each year for needy causes. The host says, Margie, thank you so much for being with us today. And the last panel, Kathy is sobbing in front of her TV as the host says, it's women like you who are helping women all over the world feel better about themselves. I love it. This came from a very personal place for guys White, who wrote on this, saying in Syrie, we all say we've rejected the notion of being superwoman. In practice, I don't know anyone who isn't still trying. Kathy, Guys White, was you meekly suited to comment on this time? Here? She is to the Detroit Free Press when asked about her works views on feminism, Kathy puts feminism in a light that's more acceptable to many women than the hardline feminism that turns some women off. It's true Kathy is vulnerable. She doesn't win all the time. She's always trying to improve her life, and she often falls short of her goals. Some may say that's a bad way to portray the new woman. Well, I say it's realistic. I know no woman who has it totally together, and I think that's okay. I think you can be a feminist and still balance your checkbook by changing banks every six months or so. I think you can still be a feminist and eat frozen donuts right out of the freezer and still say yes when you mean no, or no when you mean yes. My goal is to keep Kathy honest and close to real life. But declaring yourself a feminist was not necessarily a very cool thing to do in the eighties. It's no secret that women are not a monolith, and many have upheld their own oppression for power, profit, or just fun over the years. Phillish Laughley emerged as the big bat of the feminist movement in the nineteen seventies and successfully campaigned against the Equal Rights Amendment so hard that Kate Blanchett played her on a TV show and Women Have No Rights Awesome. The eighties uplifted many women, mostly white, who denounced the feminist gains of the seventies while visibly benefiting from those same gains. That is to say, the reason that many of these women, including Phillis Shlaughley, were able to become such prominent anti feminists was because they had child care and support to focus on their careers. You know things feminists fought for. So while feminism wasn't trendy in the nineteen eighties, to say the least, that doesn't mean that feminists weren't doing an important work during this time. In Bell Hooks published From Margin to Center, which included a strong critique of the feminine mystique, saying that it was solely concerned with the interests of upwardly mobile white women. Hooks wrote this Free Dan's famous phrase, the problem that has no name, often quoted to describe the condition of women in the society, actually refers to the plight of a select group of college educated, middle and upper class married white women, housewives, wood with leisure, with the home, with children, buying products when and more out of life. Free Dance concludes her first chapter by stating, but we can no longer ignore that voice within women that says I want something more than my husband and my children and my home. That more she defines as careers. She did not discuss who would be called in to take care of the children and maintain the home if more women like herself were freed from their house labor and given equal access with white men to the professions. She did not ask of the needs of women without men, without children, without alblems. She ignored the existence of all non white women and poor white women. She did not tell readers whether it was more fulfilling to be a maid, a babysitter, a factory worker, a clerk, or prostitute than to be a leisure class housewife. The closest Kathy's trips come to addressing these concerns are through Charlene. Charlene is Cathy's best friend at work and eventually her maid of honor, and was a stand in for a woman who was relegated to jobs that many feminists referred to as pink collar secretarial jobs, grossly underpaid and undervalued in spite of their importance to the workplace. Charlene has a story in the late eighties about her status as the lowest paid employee in the Product Testing Incorporated office. She advocates for herself her lack of pay, respect, and career mobility every secretaries week, and it's a running joke in the comic that her circumtan dance never changes. Even Cathy dismisses her concerns in a very upper management I pretend I do not see it kind of way. Here's a strip. When I started here at ten thousand dollars a year, they got me a three thousand dollar typewriter to type on. The yearly could only give me a two hundred dollar raise, they bought a two hundred thousand dollar phone system for me to operate. The year I got e three hundred dollar raise, they bought an eleven thousand dollar copy or a four thousand dollar fax machine, and a one million, five hundred thousand dollar computer system for me to use. Why do I get the feeling I'd be more valuable to this company if I came with a plug. Kathy guys White is again addressing a very real nineteen eighties trend here. While those who wanted feminist to shut up about workplace harassment and the pay gap cited figures indicating that women's presence in the workplace had increased, they tended to not get specific about where they were in the workplace. And it's not surprising why, but eighteen eighty six, a higher rate of working women were receiving poverty wages than in nineteen seventy three. In areas like the secretarial pool were overwhelmed with women, and historically, gender segregation by profession means that marginalized genders are making much less money for equal work. Charlene remained the secretary throughout the comic and is extremely good at her job, but never treated fairly, and by the end of the Backlash eighties, Kathy's strips were often focused around existing in the wreckage of the feminist backlash and the dissonance that it created in women's lives. Here's a strip with Kathy and Charlene from that hits on this theme exactly. I'm going to read the captions. While their friends got engaged, they got promoted. While their friends took Lama's class and made dinner, they took meetings and did lunch. Some call them the lost generation of women. Others say their time has just now come after years of devoting themselves to developing careers. The over thirties that emerges this march like the first flowers of spring, brave, confident, proud and ready for love. And then we see Charlene and Cathy. Their outfits are a lot of They're holding diet cookies. Cathy's wearing a shade shirt that says, I heart lean cuisine. They're just decked out in eighties consumerism. The comic concludes the debutante class of By the beginning of the nineties, George Bush Senior was president, the third wave of feminism was on the horizon, and Kathy guys White used Andrea's waspy helicopter parenting to poke some fun at how many upper class white feminists had taken to raising their kids. Most feel the third wave of feminism began around when Anita Hill spoke to an all white Supreme Court about being harassed by Judge Clarence Thomas. Guyswhite was extremely interested in commenting on how sexual harassment affected the workplace, interestingly, not how it affected the women in the workplace, who are all well aware that the happened all the time, but she focuses instead on the men's reaction to realizing that there could be consequences for their behavior. You might remember that Cathy had been sexually assaulted by her boss, Mr. Pinkley in her own house in two when he forced a kiss on her, she punched his lights out, But the Mr. Pinkley character remained this lovable misogynist boss in the workplace throughout the comic. And Mr Pinkley and Cathy's other male co workers could not handle the fall out of the Anita Hill hearing. Here's a strip from as you know, this office has always prided itself on its progressive attitude toward women. While most companies rushed into discussions about sexual harassment right after the Thomas Hill incident, I felt we all needed a few weeks for personal reflection. By waiting until today, I believe I've once again demonstrated my profound sensitivity to the feelings of the women in our workplace. And according to my wall calendar, the majority of you are now safely past your p MS days. Jeez. Later in this storyline, Pinkley uses what I am assuming his company money to bring the men at the company on a retreat to quote unquote reclaim their manhood. By the time it's over, the men have learned nothing, but they have taken a free vacation with company money. And that might sound ridiculous, but it's based in the real life bizarro work of Robert Bly, a poet who became the founder of the New Age Masculinist community. I want to turn men into men again. He would do this by having men pay him three hundred dollars. The grift is strong, meet him in the middle of nowhere in Minnesota, and would then encourage them to find the deep masculine through wearing wild animal costumes and walking around on all fours. This was a real thing after the Anita Hill hearings. Most of what Kathy guys White discusses about women issues are related to beauty standards, diet culture, changing fashion trends, and the commodification of radical movements like Riot Girls by Fast Fashion, but there are solid moments of workplace commentary as well. In guy's White's view, much of the financial gain that women, mostly white women, had made in middle management was squandered trying to achieve an unrealistic beauty standard that was pretty rigidly imposed in the workplace. Here's a strip from the late nineties to that effect, from a collection called I Am Woman, Hear Me Snore. In it, Kathy is attempting to write off these expenses on her taxes any deductions this year for the extra expenses women incur trying to dress appropriately for the twenty different images were supposed to maintain any write offs for the unpaid time women suspend, creating relationships, without which there'd be no family values, because there'd be no families, any allowances whatsoever. For the fact that our nation would screech to a halt of it weren't for the underpaid, overworked women cheerfully waiting through the mark. Forget Uncle Sam, what this country needs is an aunt Samantha. Kathy would remain in print for the remainder of the third wave of feminism, which ended around two thousand ten, when the comic did and she does comment on a fair amount of things going on. Third wave feminism was more inclusive, while still having a strong tendency to center white women. There were many critiques from women of color and trans women in particular. As gate keeping and the feminist movement continued, the riot girl movement took off in the nineties, with bands like Bikini Kill, Free Kitten, and Bratt Mobile using both their music and their determination to remain d I y to release politicized material and communicate their ideas even further using zines. The Riot Girl Zine created in Washington, d C. Were made and distributed by punk girls, for whom MS magazine had long become stale. For Kathleen Hannah, the front woman of Bikini Kill had become activated as a feminist after reading, oddly enough, the feminine Mystique, and she became a major advocate for including sex workers in the feminist movement as well, which gatekeepers of the Second Wave had not been enthusiastic about in the least. With this progressive surge also came the intense commercialism of feminist ideals in the nineties. This meant spice girls, gil Power, Disney princesses of the nineties having discernible personality is sure, but also existing in very rigid societal roles in heterosexual relationships still you aren't you distress and a damsel? And in distress I can handle this. These moves were often viewed as cynical, with male executives still the primary people and beneficiaries of choices like these. Watered Down feminist values often became more of a marketable tagline than an actual consideration in moving things forward. This still happens now. So while an attempt, I don't think that gil how A feminism really accomplished that much, because as it was happening, a slew of nineties tabloid stars were dragged through the mud by the emerging twenty four hour news cycle in a way that many are starting to scrutinize today. I think you're Anita Hills, think you're Tanya Harding's your Monica Lewinsky's your Amy Fisher's your Janet Jackson's shout out to the year wrong About podcast You probably listen already. Women of the second and third waves of feminism were also very often at odds. Many Second waivers felt that third wave feminists, who were the first generation to grow up with the benefits that the movement had made, did not appreciate the work and sacrifice that the women of the sixties and seventies had made, and third wave feminists wanted to move in a new direction, rejecting the extent of gate keeping and lack of inclusivity of liberal white feminist figureheads from the second wave. Writer Rebecca Walker explains this conflict from a unique standpoint. Her mother is author Alice Walker, who wrote The Color Purple, and her godmother is Gloria Steinham. Walker says this there is a definite gap among feminists who consider themselves to be second wave and those who would label themselves as third wave. Although the age criteria for second wave feminists and third wave feminists as Murky. Younger feminists definitely have a hard time proving themselves worthy as feminist scholars and activists. And you know who else commented on this rift year girl Kathy. Kathy's interactions with younger women is very interesting to me, in part because they're pulled from a semi autobiographical place. Kathy guys by It's daughter was growing up in the third wave of feminism, and the Kathy character's interaction with third wave women are very telling. Here's a strip from where the Kathy character talks with a female friend of her ten years younger Hattie boyfriend Alex. Of course, it's women my age who really paved the way for women your age, Shawnah, it must be incredible for you to face a world with so many options, no kidding. Now we women can use our college degrees to be underpaid in one hundred different professions. Now we can work and spend all the money on daycare, or not work and be homeless. Now women can demand more for ourselves and go bankrupt immediately, or charge it all and be slowly strangled by eighteen interest. Alex says, how's it going in there? Kathy, I've just been soaked by the fountain of you. Another issue Cathy addressed was the anxiety around fertility and age, yet another issue that was frequently misrepresented in the media in order to viewed cynically discourage people with uteruses for remaining in the workplace for too long or aiming their goals too high for fear of the almighty biological clock. Even in the comics Last Days After Kathy gets married in two thousand five, another comment on boomer women who delayed marriage and children to help develop their careers and themselves, Kathy guys White explored the frustrations and pressures that came with aging. Long after Andrea and her children have disappeared from the comic, after Charlene has gotten married and had two children, Kathy continues to pursue the idea of being an optimized woman, and it's just as impossible as it ever was. Third wave feminism sought to address a lot issues like rape and domestic violence, the fight to preserve reproductive rights. When conservative after conservative tried to remove them and included race, class, and trans rights in a more meaningful way in their platform, they ultimately lacked a clear goal. I would argue that one of the greatest accomplishments of third wave feminism was moving organizational efforts across mediums. In the nineties, Riot Girls pioneered zines, and by the two dozen tens the movement had been brought online. Many say fourth wave feminism is what's happening right now. I kind of reject the whole wave thing anyhow, but it's a clean way to organize a podcast. Here's my question. Why have feminists not embraced or even engaged with Kathy at any point? It's very possible that there's just a million bigger fish to fry, but different areas of different movements have found the time and energy to rally around other fictional women of different movements. Think you're Mary Tyler, Moore's your Joe March is your Lisa Simpson's. Come on, Stacy, have waited my whole life to hear you speak. Don't you have anything relevant to say? Don't ask me, I'm just a girl. In on Hating Kathy essay in the Comics journal writer Juliette Cohn takes a guess, but one of the feminists, why is there no defense from them? How has Kathy managed to fail them so utterly. She is, as they state, not a role model, and though the need for female role models is real, so too is the use of this argument towards patriarchal aims. But beyond this, there is a certain reproach in the tones of Cathy's female critics of frustration. Why couldn't you do better? How could you fail so visibly? It is an anger at her imperfection that reveals an implicit understanding that Kathy's circumstances are not fair, that her stumbling weighs more than a man's. It is a criticism born from fear of censure. What might Cathy's weakness bring upon us? Calm continues later in the same essay, womanhood is mundane, is what it comes down to, and Kathy operates squarely within what we understand womanhood to be. Women's work is diapers, typing, cooking, and data entry. Kathy dwarfed by stacks of anonymous paperwork, celebrated for her diligence but never innovation. Woman's play is frivolous, superficial, distracting, and materialistic. Kathy enjoying a chick flick, acute stiletto, and evening in with a friend and some ice cream. Women's sorrow is only poetic if it can become a symbol that means something to a man. Cathy cries most regularly over her inability to become that symbol. Of frustrations at work, including an episode of sexual harassment from her boss, could never be considered powerful in the manner of the man in the gray flannel suit or death of a salesman. Her play is goofy, and the strip itself is, of course an artifact of women's play. Her sorrow is to be mocked. No one remarks, going on a decade since the strips end, about the expressiveness of Guys White's line. No one discusses the artfulness of the interplay between Cathy, largely ambivalent to feminism with a capital F, and her more openly political friend Andrea. The consciousness of this choice, as Guys White once remarked, embodying the position of women. Quote launched into adulthood with a foot in both worlds, and quote will not be lauded. I really like watching characters funk up and adjust and grow over time, even if they don't grow as quickly as people would like. And again, Kathy is commenting pretty much exclusively on feminism's traditional beneficiaries. That's important to note, and I think it made her work a kind of safe choice to feature in the funny pages at first. The absence of black, brown, queer Asian Native women from the pages of the newspapers during this era is absolutely a failure, and I believe primarily an editorial and systemic one. So no, Kathy is not an ambassador of perfect feminism and certainly does not speak for all women, and she never claimed to by Guys. By its own admission, the Kathy character was created as comfort food for those who felt slower to apply the tenets of feminism to their daily lives, who were making an active effort to unlearned behaviors and instincts they've grown up with but maybe weren't quite there yet. If anything, I think the Kathy character reflects some of the gains made by American feminists between the seventies and the two thousand's, as well as the frustrating stop and start nature of progress and the exclusionary measures taken. When ending the comic in two thousand ten, Kathy guys White said this, I am not stopping the strip because I think anything has been resolved. When I see my daughter and her generation, I see that a lot of the games between men and women fixation on fashion. I'll die if my hair doesn't look right. And I really thought we could have lost that in the last thirty years, but I guess we haven't. She continues a bit later. I feel like a lot of the time my strip made sort of political comments about the state of women, their expectations, the state of women in the office, being harassed, being held back, being utterly confused by the mixed messages we get from everything from what size to be, how to feel about ourselves, how to look to me. That's all sort of political. A lot of what I wrote about was the woman's place in the world and the pressure were under to be a certain way, to think certain things, to have or not have certain opportunities. And that's where Kathy and American feminism stands. Her work does not represent the experience of all American women, because American women are not a monolith. There are a lot of perspectives that we don't see in her work. What we do see is how an average woman received the gains and stepped back around feminism. Whether you agree with her takes or not. I'm going to close this episode with some words from Roxanne Gay and her essay collection Bad Feminist. Gay says this, feminisms failings do not mean we should eschew feminism entirely. People do terrible things all the time, but we don't regularly disown our humanity. We disavow the terrible things. We should disavow the failures of feminism without disavowing its many successes and how far we have come. American feminism has been fractured and flawed as hell from the jump, and understanding that history feels important in order to move forward, though a small one. I think Cathy Strips are a part of that, and as the only woman in the Funny Pages at the beginning of her career, those contributions are significant. And speaking of those fun pages, what was going on there? Next week we take a look at the women who came before Kathy in this medium, at the men she was sharing the pages of, and how newspaper comics grew and changed during her thirty four year tenure. There will be boondocks, there will be Dilbert's, and with deepest regrets, there might be even a family circus. Next week, on ac Cast. Ac Cast is an I Heart radio production. It is written, researched, and hosted by me Jamie Loftus, Sophie Lichtaman is the World's Greatest producer, Isaac Taylor is the world's greatest editor. Zoe Blade writes the world's greatest music, and Brandon Dickard wrote the world greatest theme song for this show. In today's episode, you heard the vocal talent of Jackie, Michelle Johnson as Kathy, Melissa Lozada Oliva as Andrea, Maggie Mayfish as Charlene, Miles Gray as Mr. Pinkley, and Irving, with additional performances by the wonderful Joel Smith, Sure, Lonnie Unis, Caitlin Dernte, Julia Claire, and Isaac Taylor. Oh Boy, see you next week. M M M